Login

Register | Forgot Your Password? | Close
I'll admit it.

I get really frustrated sometimes when I watch Justin Upton play baseball.

Whether it's seeing him struggle with a ball in the corner or when he strikes out with runners in scoring position in key situations, there are varying levels of frustration reached.

Judging from the booing Upton has received in recent games at Chase Field, I'm not alone in this category. Hell, he's been labeled an "enigma" by the guy who signs the checks.

Considering Upton's immense talent, his 2012 season, to this point, has been a head-scratcher. As I write this, Upton is hitting a modest .273 with seven home runs and 36 runs batted in. Five Diamondbacks have homered more often through the season's first half. Four have driven in more runs.

Right now, Upton is tied for 63rd in the National League in home runs and 44th in RBI. On the heels of a very good 2011 campaign during which Upton helped the Diamondbacks win the National League West and finished fourth in the league's MVP voting, this year has been an unmitigated disappointment. There's no denying that.

Reports surfaced over the weekend that the Diamondbacks were (again) thinking of trading the two-time All-Star. Other reports indicated that the interest around the majors was "very high" and that Arizona GM Kevin Towers would consider pulling the trigger on a deal even though the team is only four games out of first place in the NL West at the break.

Upton's first half struggles make little sense. Trading him makes no sense.

Justin Upton is in his sixth big league season. He has played 660 games. He's 24 years of age.

Why would you give up on that when it is still so early in his career, when Upton (as far as we know) likes playing in Arizona, is affordable and has worlds of untapped potential that we've seen glimpses of since he came to the bigs as a 19-year-old in 2007?

To me, it's just not worth it.

What a difference a year makes. Last year at the All-Star break, Diamondbacks fans were defending Upton's honor. The Arizona outfielder wasn't picked by team captain Prince Fielder to represent the National League in the annual home run derby, and Fielder heard about it. The former Brewer was booed heartily throughout the All-Star festivities and his family even had water thrown on them in the name of "fandom" by D-backs supporters during an All-Star parade. Diamondbacks fans were willing to make fools of themselves in defending Upton a year ago.

Now, they're willing to make fools of themselves by booing a player who has played through injury and has endured an average first half of the season.

Maybe this is a motivational ploy by the D-backs' front office. Upton was reportedly shopped in the offseason prior to the 2011 season and responded with an MVP-caliber year.

In his last three games, Upton is hitting .385 (5-for-13) with five runs scored, two doubles, two triples and three runs batted in. Arizona won all three games. Oh, by the way, those numbers coincide with the trade rumors that trickled out into the public late Friday afternoon.

Coincidence? Maybe.

But at least for one weekend, we saw Justin Upton play baseball the way he's capable of over a three-game stretch. Going into the All-Star break, that's exactly what he and this team needed.

8 Comments   |   Join the conversation »
  • Add A Comment 
  • Abuse
    OldAzSportsFan wrote...
    have to agree
    I have to agree. At the price we have him over the next three years you hang on to him. If at the end of next year if he still is having problems, then you get something for him in his last year, or better case scenario you give him the money. He isn't yet great, but he is only 24 years old. We need to remember that. He is a great character guy, how many nineteen year olds can handle fame and fortune coming into the bigs? Football and basketball are littered with the remains of young men who couldn't handle it. Yes, he is frustrating at times, but you keep him.
  • Abuse
    DanTheTimid wrote...
    Tough but...
    I've never been an Upton fan but I've never had anything against him either. That said, Upton's numbers are bad in the most important stat no one looks at. Mediocre average, whatever, low power, not that big a deal, high Ks, second most over rated stat in baseball, but abysmal RISP BA, that is just unacceptable. RISPBA is quite possibly the most important stat for middle of the lineup hitters, in the same way OBA is more important then BA for top of the order hitters, and its a stat that Upton as of now is hitting .192 with 2 out as of the all star break.
  • Abuse
    DanTheTimid wrote...
    Continued
    I'm not saying Upton can't improve with runners in scoring position, but so far he's been so incredibly anti-clutch that even replacing him with a guy who hits .220, but .300 with RISP, would actually likely improve our runs scored as a team. A perfect past example of such a hidden gem player would be craig council when he was with the d-backs. He'd hit something like .260 every year, but .300+ with RISP. Most teams probably wouldn't have traded any real talent for him, yet he was secretly a huge part of our success for the time.
  • Abuse
    DanTheTimid wrote...
    Finished...
    Upton is the reverse. He shows enough upside in the less important stats that teams may be willing to give up something solid to get him, yet his failures in the important stats means his loss really wouldn't be felt as harshly as I think a lot of people fear it would. I'm not saying I want the team to give Upton away, unless a team offers us something really solid for him I'd rather they keep him, I'm just saying if they do make such an offer, I'm not opposed to at least considering a trade.
  • Abuse
    Jarrod P. wrote...
    DO NOT TRADE UPTON
    Brauns bets season came at 27. Cargo's best season came at 26. Mc Cutcheons best season is now as a 25 year old. J Up is only 24 and has had 2 all star games and a 4th place MVP season. Is he immature- YES- Is he an annoying whiny baby? YES- Is he a lazy player- YES. Will he figure it out and be a yearly superstar- I think so... I have said for three years that the team needs a respected veteran player to corral these young guys. Jarrod
  • Abuse
    the cooker wrote...
    Has nobody noticed!
    Justin has been a mirror image of his bother if nobody has noticed. Only runs out grounders when he feels like it which is not often. loafs in the field and never has a sense of urgency. Against the Dodgers I could not figure out why Gibby did not pull him in the first inning when he should have beat that broken bat roller out but instead was out by a good 10 feet.
  • Abuse
    Think4URself wrote...
    Its all between the ears...
    I can throw players out there that are much younger performing very well too. But that is missing the point on J Upton. Maturity is forced. If you want to succeed in todays world, even with a ton of talent, it will require hard work, passion and focus. Some get it, some dont. The DBacks had a careless, young culture just a short while back and the team is still experiencing the pitfalls of that philosophy. Until Upton realizes he is nothing more than potential right now, he will never get better. I just wish he realized how much he has already thrown away.
  • Abuse
    Think4URself wrote...
    that being said...
    I dont think he has got it between the ears. Effort is one key indicator in determining where a person is in their career. He certainly has proven so far, that he is behind the curve on that issue. And as others`have pointed out RISP BA is huge. And again, he sucks there. Lastly, careless attitude. There is no question, he suffers from this problem. He will likely be very good someday, but i think he is 4-5 years out because it takes so much more heart to be great. P.S. - Vince, horrible argument.
close

Share: