Login

Register | Forgot Your Password? | Close
AP: 0192d11c-a1a6-45cb-b39d-04705d179d96
Arizona Cardinals quarterback John Skelton (19) works as Atlanta Falcons defensive end John Abraham (55) pursues during the first half of an NFL football game Sunday, Nov. 18, 2012, in Atlanta. (AP Photo/John Bazemore)
It may not have resulted in a win, but Cardinals coach Ken Whisenhunt made the call of the season early in Sunday's game at the Georgia Dome.

After four first quarter possessions, quarterback John Skelton got the hook in favor of rookie Ryan Lindley.

Skelton suffered yet another bout of ineffectiveness, completing just 2-of-7 passes for six yards. But the problem wasn't necessarily Skelton's completion percentage. The problem was his on-going struggles with accuracy, which led to several missed opportunities. And this time, there were no receivers dropping passes to blame.

The play that stands out like a sore thumb is a first quarter throw into the end zone intended for a wide-open Larry Fitzgerald that wound up soaring out of bounds. Earlier, Skelton had a chance to hit Fitzgerald for a first down but missed on that one as well. Neither throw appeared to be all that difficult.

The Cardinals defense intercepted Falcons quarterback Matt Ryan three times in the first quarter but had only a 13-0 lead to show for it. They wound up with five picks and a fumble recovery on the afternoon. A team with half an offense would have won by a minimum of three touchdowns with that kind of defensive performance.

Unless Lindley gets hurt, Skelton should not see the field again this season.

At 4-6, chances are slim to none this team is bound for the playoffs, although no one inside the organization would dare admit that now, nor should they. Both the division and the conference are way too competitive for a team with less than 10 wins to reach the postseason. So unless you think the Cardinals have a six-game winning streak in them with December road games at New York, Seattle and San Francisco, then hear me out.

Skelton has had multiple opportunities to take the starting quarterback job from Kevin Kolb. He didn't have a good preseason. He wasn't off to a good start in Week 1 before getting hurt. And, with the exception of a decent second half in Green Bay two weeks ago, he's been inaccurate way too often since Kolb got hurt five weeks ago. There's no reason to believe the Cardinals can win with Skelton under center. In fact, they haven't yet this season.

Although Lindley wasn't anything special against the Falcons, he wasn't expected to be. He hadn't seen any game action since the preseason, and presumably did not receive many snaps with the first team offense in practice during the bye week. He looked like a sixth-round draft pick making his NFL debut.

Unfortunately Skelton has looked like a rookie since August. I think that given a full week to practice with the starters, we'll see a better Lindley next Sunday against the Rams.

In fact, Lindley should play until Kolb is healthy enough to return, especially if the Cardinals have the slightest inkling he could be their signal caller of the future. Maybe they have already secretly decided to move on from Kolb after the season.

There are still more questions than answers surrounding their future at quarterback.

Would Larry Fitzgerald be okay with a rookie under center the rest of the way? He only caught one ball for 11 yards on Sunday. Of course it was Lindley who threw it to him.

And did you read his body language when Skelton missed him in the end zone?

John Skelton is a nice guy. I think he works hard and does his best to prepare as thoroughly as he can. He's got a good arm. The Cardinals had an impressive run with him running the show down the stretch last year -- thanks in larger part to Patrick Peterson and a great defense -- but the proof is in the pudding this year.

2012 started with so much promise, but has gone down in a hurry. Now it's time for the Cardinals to give fans a reason to have hope for the future.

28 Comments   |   Join the conversation »
  • Add A Comment 
  • Abuse
    CroDawg wrote...
    Want to give me hope?
    Get rid of Whiz, bring in Horton or Todd Haley as head coach. Blow up the entire offense and I don't what else.
  • Abuse
    FitzIsMyHero wrote...
    message recieved way too late
    Cards can't put it together at QB and o line. Larrys trade could give them players or draft picks to gain depth at those positions. The horrible o line play delayed all our QBs development in Whizs offense. We've found out Kolb is injury prone, Skelton is too inaccurate. Even behind a revamped o line, ant QBs progression in this offense will be delayed 2-3 yrs before the offense is rythmatic. I got bidwills "comitment to winning" memo,but,based on their offensive FA acquisitions (Snyder), larry and I, are a little convinced otherwise.
  • Abuse
    FitzIsMyHero wrote...
    cards need a qb
    Kolbs always hurt (even in PHI). Skelton sucks. I don't want to speak on Lindley. They should trade Wells, R.Williams, LSH, Fitz, and any underacheivers on this team, for; the best QB from this draft and o linemen. Obviously fire Graves, Whiz, and all his offebsive coaching staff. Do what u have to do to keep Horton cuz he's doing a phenomonal job with that defense. Offensively its time to rebuild and liquidate your biggest asset (trade fitz) bcuz he's wasting your money and time. By the time he's past his prime and after he's paid all that money, you still won't be good at OLine and QB
  • Abuse
    MrMwman wrote...
    What???
    Do you hear yourself? "Only" a 13-0 lead against an 8-1 Atlanta Falcon team on their turf? Sure Skelton was sucking it up but he's always started slow. Wiz did make the call of the year, heck, 40 years I've been watching football and have never seen a starting quarterback yanked for a rookie when the team was ahead and defense was lights out. Wiz proved his point by yours and his accounts but lost the team today. Putting in a rookie to ignite a Falcon's defense. Wiz's constant sound bite is playing the players that give him the best chance to win. Well, today with that decision, he didn't.
  • Abuse
    Jarrod P. wrote...
    I am a genius....
    I posted this in the preview thread: think Atlanta is waaaay over-rated. I think the Cards are waay worse than they are as well. At least with Whis as coach. What can he do or say to motivate? Nothing. What does he have to offer after Skelton..nothing. This is the game where we see Lindley. Skelton 9-19 145 yards, 2 int. Lindley 18-34 225 yards 2 yd. Falcons- 27, Cardinals-17 WHIS FIRED-- sorry, wishful thinking..
  • Abuse
    Jarrod P. wrote...
    Kidding, of course
    Just felt like today would be the day for Lindley-- now we can start the Lindley to Floyd relationship- two guys the Cards should have NEVER spent draft picks on. Imagine a 1st round and a 6th round O lineman... Hmmm....
  • Abuse
    tcman wrote...
    Feel bad for
    the players and coaches who join the most losing team in the history of professional sports in the United States. Look, no other NFL owners play the game to make money; its all ego and winning. Yet the Cards are still run for family profit. After losing for 50plus years i cant believe fans still donate their money. Good luck guys, we feel bad for you!
  • Abuse
    sundevil7901 wrote...
    The timing of the benching
    was all wrong. Benching Skelton at a very winnable point in the game was a bad move. I get he was playing poorly, but we've seen games where Skelton played bad for most, but was still able to do enough to get the win. Do we need to see more Lindley? Absolutely, but not like it was handled today.
  • Abuse
    gijoe516 wrote...
    Just wrong
    Wiz's call was idiotic. He should lose his job now. He made his bed, now lay in it. You have no qb, no running backs, no line, crap coaches and you're winning a game and you pull your qb (who was good enough to be your starter ) for a rookie. Its just insane. Either you're a horrible judge of talent, or too stubborn.
close

Share: