Login

Register | Forgot Your Password? | Close
AP: bf67b5ef-e95e-4cf5-b2f3-8a1b2814f3b6
Arizona Cardinals quarterback Kevin Kolb (4) is helped by a team trainer after being hit by New Orleans Saints defensive tackle Sedrick Ellis (98) during the first quarter of the NFL Hall of Fame exhibition football game, Sunday, Aug. 5, 2012 in Canton, Ohio. (AP Photo/Scott Galvin)
I got a text from the producer of the Burns and Gambo show last night at halftime of the preseason opener. It simply read:

Skelton 1, Kolb 0

Yep. That's about right.

All of our fears about Kevin Kolb were realized in the first 15 minutes of the preseason. The biggest of which has nothing to do with performance. It has to do with the ability to stay on a football field.

Concerns about Kolb have morphed from "is he good enough" to "can he stay upright long enough". Last night's chest injury is merely the latest example and an unfortunate metaphor for the big picture problem facing Kolb. The pick was bad. The injury worse.

Some will say I'm questioning Kolb's toughness; his willingness to play through the injuries that have plagued him over the last calendar year. Not at all. As Mike Sando pointed out on his ESPN NFC West blog, Kolb would have been a fool for playing through a concussion late last year and it was pointless to gut it out during a silly preseason game. Ken Whisenhunt correctly pointed out that it irrational to make judgments this early in the process.

But the facts remain. He's played in a little more than half of the games in his Cardinals tenure. And once again, as Sando notes, this is the fourth consecutive preseason or regular season that an injury has knocked out Kolb.

I will say this though; at the start of camp the NFL Network's Willie McGinest suggested that the players he was talking to in the Cardinals locker room favored Skelton over Kolb. While this report was dismissed as hooey, I thought at the time that - hypothetically, if it were true - it was in part because the players may view Skelton was able (notice I did not write "willing") to absorb the punishment in ways that Kolb would seem to struggle with.

Either way, the smile on Skelton's face was obvious every time the cameras cut to him Sunday night. He knows his candidacy took a step forward with his steady play during the TD drive. And in a moment that some may consider revelatory and some will describe as merely interesting, as Kolb was gingerly walking off the field, Skelton approached him to give him a high five. Kolb left him hanging. The pain of yet another injury and a night gone horribly wrong was apparently just too much to bear.

11 Comments   |   Join the conversation »
  • Add A Comment 
  • Abuse
    Wanabeafan wrote...
    Corn Kolb !
    Kolb's a wuss and a poor team mate. Dissed Skelton on live tv. I hope this guy gets cut!!! Yep, Dr Do-LITTLE for sure! QB's should be 1. Skelton 2. Lindley 3. Bartel Get rid of the corn kolb.
  • Abuse
    Aaron W. wrote...
    Kolb
    Kolb has been unlucky with injuries in his young career. Injuries are not a sign of toughness. Playing "banged up" and playing "injured" are completely different things. I hope he can stay healthy the rest of the pre-season, so we can get a real look at both him and Skelton. Let the better man take the job, not the backup taking over due to injury again.
  • Abuse
    mesa mad man wrote...
    long season
    Ill be the first to admit - i was a huge kolb advocate that thought he could be something special. After last night (yes - i know it was preseason) I really question that. It looked like a mirror image of last year - hurried passes, scrambling, and injury. I dont know if he will ever truly realize his potential, especially in AZ. As far as skelton - if he is our guy, its going to be a long season. Yes, he can withstand punishment. Other than that, he isnt the most accurate and doesnt make the best reads. The only way this team will win this season is if they depend on the run game.
  • Abuse
    Hummer71 wrote...
    Skitish
    You have to wonder now with all the hits Kolb has had to deal with the last 4 years that he has the David Carr syndrome. Carr basically was finished as a NFL QB when he became paranoid about getting hit. I think that's why Kolb takes off running so soon when goes to pass. I'm not sure if he will ever overcome this fear.
  • Abuse
    Wanabeafan wrote...
    Skelton No 1 Guy
    Skelton is miles ahead of Kolb He stands in the pocket. He's learning to step up and around pressure. ( Can't really teach that ) He can see over the linemen. He's got a cannon. He just needs some playing time. He knows the offense better than Kolb. I think he manages the game well and gets the ball to our play makers. Which is really what QB is all about.
  • Abuse
    DeeGirl wrote...
    Help me understand
    Is Kolb's proneness to injury a result of physical durability (or lack thereof) or is it related to how he plays and moves in / out of the pocket ?
  • Abuse
    fenix3030 wrote...
    Knob
    Knob is a bust. He hates the pocket and runs from his O-line. He refuses to step up in the pocket, he falls akwardly alot, he doesnt tuck, he makes bad reads, how long do we extend this?? Get it over with.
  • Abuse
    hugUhbear wrote...
    Kolb has not even felt the heat from the kitchen
    That first throw of his that was INT was not a professional QB's read or throw. It was Max hall strength and the CB was looking at Kolb staring down his WR and licking his chops when he saw the weak throw come sailing in his direction. Easy pickin's. I think the next play I remember was a run. Kolb went down the field with the play and even the announcers were commenting that he better get out of that play before a lineman wallops him. Then 3rd posession where he finaklly got what he wanted, an exit from his nightmare
  • Abuse
    SportsInfo247 wrote...
    Kolb injury prone and is just not good
    Not only is Kolb injury prone, but he threw a pick on his first pass of the game. He made a bad read, a bad decision, & under threw his receiver. His second pass looked as though it was under thrown to Andre Roberts. Then, the next two pass attempts, Kolb ran around the backfield like he was running for his life. Kolb had 9 TD & 8 INT last year, with 8 fumbles, 30 sacks, and an 81.0 QB rating in 9 games. I'm not saying Skelton is any better, but Kolb is not the answer, & it's not just because he gets hurt all the time. How many more opportunities are the Cardinals going to give this guy.
close

Share: