Updated Jan 9, 2013 - 6:21 pm
ESPN insider: D-backs 'running the risk of devaluing' Justin Upton
In five full seasons, the former No. 1 overall pick has already made two All-Star Game appearances, while also hitting over 100 home runs and 350 RBI.
However for the third consecutive offseason, general manager Kevin Towers has not shied away from making Upton available to interested teams.
While Upton has survived yet another tumultuous winter of rumors so far, one ESPN MLB insider believes his value might be diminished because of Towers' inconsistent behavior.
"Everyone thinks he is going to be traded," Keith Law told Arizona Sports 620's Doug and Wolf Wednesday. "The conversation I had the other day with a pretty high-ranking scout was that [the D-backs] put out feelers enough and have given out signs that they are interested in trading him to other clubs, that they're running the risk of devaluing him at this point."
Although Upton has remained quiet in regards to the latest round of trade talks, Law can't see a situation where the right fielder would want to be in a D-backs uniform moving forward.
"They've created an environment where it's going to be very uncomfortable if Upton is still a Diamondback when spring training starts," said Law. "Other clubs are coming to Arizona and saying 'Why should we give you 100 cents on the dollar, when you've made it clear you don't really want this guy anymore?'"
Last month's signing of free agent Cody Ross gives Arizona an excess number of outfielders, but Law doesn't believe Upton, who is due to make $9.75 million next season, will be the fall guy simply based on payroll concerns.
Law previously worked in the Toronto Blue Jays front office from 2002-2006 and said that if he were a general manager pursuing Upton, he'd buy low not based on the player but how the player is being presented.
So the question is, has Towers screwed up with the manner in which he's handled Upton?
"I don't like the way [Towers] has handled it," said Law. "It remains to be seen if his strategy will work out or not. We will see what they actually get for him. I personally, and some of this is just a philosophy thing, wouldn't have handled it this way.
"Once you've put a player out there, especially once you've done it twice, you've probably got to move him or make a commitment that makes it clear that he's not available anymore. But constantly dangling him on the market, it's all about return. You risk not getting much in return, especially when a player has a down year as Upton certainly did."
In 2012, Upton hit .280 with 17 home runs and 67 RBI. However, he did finish the season tied for fourth in the league with 107 runs scored.
- The Yoke of Leadership
- D-backs' GM Kevin Towers: If improvement doesn't happen, 'heads are gonna roll'
- Four-run fifth inning does in McCarthy, D-backs in loss to Cubs: By The Numbers
- D-backs manager Kirk Gibson: 'If we don't start winning, I should be held accountable'
- Diamondbacks didn't have a chance after Sydney
- Kevin Towers, D-backs GM - Wednesday April 23What can be done to save the season?
- Kirk Gibson, D-backs manager - Tuesday April 22D-backs manager Kirk Gibson talks about the team's struggles.
- Bickley Blast - Monday April 21Dan goes off on the struggling D-backs.
- Tim Kurkjian, ESPN MLB Insider - Thursday April 17Tim Kurkjian talks about the Diamondbacks' tough start to the season.
- Bickley Blast - Thursday April 17Bickley blasts Kevin Towers' philosophy and the need for an analytics GM.
- Derrick Hall, D-backs President and CEO - Thursday April 17Is it too early to make a change?
- Kevin Towers, D-backs GM - Wednesday April 16Can the D-backs weather the storm?