Login

Register | Forgot Your Password? | Close
AP: 56af8dbf-bd46-413a-80af-be067201dc32
Arizona Diamondbacks' Justin Upton flies out to center field during the first inning of a baseball game against the Washington Nationals, Monday, Aug. 22, 2011, in Washington. The Nationals won 4-1. (AP Photo/Luis M. Alvarez)
It is now safe to look at the calendar. Yes, it is August, soon to be September, and the Arizona Diamondbacks are thisclose to winning the National League West and heading to the playoffs. But to get there Kirk Gibson is going to have to go against his better judgment and start riding his horses while keeping the ponies in the barn.

Nothing against Sean Burroughs, Collin Cowgill, Henry Blanco and Cody Ransom, but this is the stretch run of a pennant race and the Diamondback regulars can rest all off-season. Right now it is time to ride Willie Bloomquist, Miguel Montero, Ryan Roberts, Chris Young and Justin Upton all the way to the finish line.

How Upton can get a day off in the midst of a pennant race is beyond me. I'm sure the 2001 Diamondback core starters didn't get many days off with five weeks left in the season and neither should this group. If Gibson wants to rest some of his players, do it in blowout games. There will be enough one-sided games where the starters can come out early if need be and get a couple of innings off here and there. And I have no issues with taking Upton out for a late-inning defensive replacement.

Look, Arizona struggled against two of the best teams in baseball in the Phillies and the Braves. They didn't hit and I certainly didn't expect them to. Those teams have excellent pitching and everything the D-backs saw was away, away, away. Nothing over the heart of the plate. But if the D-backs are going to go down swinging they need to do it with their big guns.

Cowgill is batting .152 and has gotten 15 at bats in the last 6 games. Those at bats should have gone to Gerardo Parra, who is hitting .286 and needs to be in the lineup every day. Cody Ransom hit a huge two-run home run to beat Clayton Kershaw and the Dodgers a few weeks ago, but that is his only homer on the season and after going 0-for-4 Monday night vs Washington he is hitting .152 for the season. Bloomquist has been the heart-and-soul for Arizona this year and is hitting a respectable .262. And he doesn't need much rest seeing as he has only played in 76 games and has only 271 at bats. No need to rest him, he's fresh now. Blanco has done a nice job as the backup catcher this year and should play in day games after night games, but that's about it. Montero is one of the better offensive catchers in baseball and he has done a great job recently of throwing out runners. Burroughs got three starts in the six games against Philadelphia and Atlanta and went 2-for-12. Sorry, but I'd rather just have Roberts out there day in and day out at this point.

It's not that Gibby's philosophy of playing everyone didn't work. It has gotten Arizona to this point. But the whole point of resting the starters is to have them fresh for this very moment, for the stretch run so you can run them out there and let them carry this team to the playoffs.

There is a player on this team that needs playing time off the bench, Lyle Overbay. But that is because he is a veteran who understands how to play the game -- see his performance against Roy Halladay in the first game against Philadelphia. Cowgill and Ransom lack the necessary experience.

Arizona has inquired about Edgar Renteria, who cleared waivers in Cincinnati, and are looking for a veteran shortstop to back up Bloomquist. And if they can find one that player will be worthy of playing time based on his veteran status. But to run Cowgill and Ransom out there at this point is like showing up to a gun fight with a water gun. It's not going to work.

No need to panic here as Arizona is still in first place and the Giants are struggling and dealing with several key injuries. But I bet if you asked Upton, Roberts, CY, Bloomquist or Montero if they wanted any days off in these final five weeks you would get the same answer from all of them -- NO. With a little more than a month left in the season and three off days in September it is time to rely on the vets.

4 Comments   |   Join the conversation »
  • Add A Comment 
  • Abuse
    tharper wrote...
    Couldn't Agree More
    I usually have some sort of argument with your perspectives Gambo, but you are right on point with this column! Please explain to me how a player is supposed to find his rythym when he doesn't play for an extended period of time? Parra is a perfect example. He's hitting over .280 and has the highest BA for any 8th hole hitter in the league! What more do you want Gibby? I love 'Gibby-ball' and I think he does a great job, but I am beginning to question his 'everyone plays' mentality. Go Dbacks.
  • Abuse
    sundevil7901 wrote...
    Right on Gambo
    No sense in saving players for the playoffs when there is no assurances yet that we'll make it there. Dbacks need to play their starters, use their vets and treat every game like a playoff game.
  • Abuse
    Jarrod P. wrote...
    Remember, this is smoke and mirrors
    This will not be popular, but they are not playing for this season. This is great, feels good, and is unbelievable, but... lets face it. The D Backs are not a playoff team. They are the beneficiaries of a Giants team that has lost all their top players. They also had a good run of hitting. This team is what it is..Upton, Kennedy, Hudson, and..... Point is, the everyone plays mentality has to stay as they are playing for next year- playing to see who can be on the roster next season..
  • Abuse
    Jarrod P. wrote...
    A bit more
    I know, I know.. they can catch lightning in a bottle and who knows what can happen. We saw what will happen last week against the Phillies and Braves- they were a slider away to a recently acquired utility guy form being swept in both series, against playoff teams.. This team has been great- I LOVE them. But riding Montero, Parra, Roberts, and Young will not win a series this year, or ever.. This year is gravy. I know they have to fight to stay in the playoffs, but realistically they have to see what they have for next season..
close

Share: