Login

Register | Forgot Your Password? | Close
PeytonManning.jpg
Quarterback Peyton Manning, who will be released by the Indianapolis Colts, speaks during a news conference in Indianapolis, Wednesday, March 7, 2012. (AP Photo/Michael Conroy)

If the Arizona Cardinals are truly interested in Peyton Manning, aren't they admitting that they are not settled at the quarterback spot?

And if they aren't, why stop at Manning? Look, I understand fully the attraction to sign a quarterback who won a Super Bowl, won four MVP awards, has thrown for 399 touchdowns and 54,828 yards and has 141 wins.

I get it.

Nothing not to like about trying to lure Manning here to the desert.

But if not Manning, why settle for what you already have?

Clearly, more than half the teams in the league have no interest in Manning and that's because they believe in the signal caller they have.

Arizona is not in that boat.

They have major questions at the position. Kevin Kolb missed seven games due to a concussion and turf toe in his first year with the Redbirds and, when he did play, he wasn't very good, throwing eight interceptions and being sacked 30 times.

Second-year quarterback John Skelton won games, going 6-2 as a starter, but he did throw 14 interceptions to just 11 touchdowns and was sacked 23 times.

Clearly the organization isn't sold on either one of these players.

So I ask again, why just stop at Manning? Why not consider trading up for Robert Griffin, signing free agent Matt Flynn or even considering another quarterback later in the draft?

Look I know the Cardinals have needs, especially on the offensive line and they don't have a second round pick thanks to the Kolb trade. But make no mistake about it -- you don't win in this league without an elite quarterback and, right now, you have to question whether Arizona has one.

Most experts will say no.

So if Arizona makes a pitch for Manning and it fails, why not kick the tires on Flynn, who started the final regular season game of the season against Detroit and set a Green Bay franchise record for yards passing (480) and touchdowns (6)?

Or why not give up your first round pick this year and next plus an extra pick or two to get what many consider to be a franchise quarterback in Griffin?

Look, Arizona could keep their picks, draft an offensive lineman and keep Kolb and Skelton.

Will that create any buzz? Will they be a serious contender? Probably not.

Get a franchise quarterback and everything changes -- just look at Kurt Warner to see what having a great quarterback means.

I am all in on going after Manning. Roll the dice, why not? What do you have to lose?

Nothing but money.

If it works it could be magic, if it doesn't you can always say you tried and were committed to winning.

Definitely worth a chance.

But if Arizona fails on delivering Manning, they shouldn't give up on looking for that franchise quarterback. Because in this league, you don't go anywhere without one.

12 Comments   |   Join the conversation »
  • Add A Comment 
  • Abuse
    AZSPORTFAN wrote...
    WRONG
    So what if Flynn set a franchise record in ONE game... it doesn't make him a sure thing either. Kolb became the first quarterback in NFL history to throw for more than 300 yards in each of his first two career starts and then named the NFC Offensive Player of the Week..... Manning is is different.... Also, more than half the teams in the league do have interest in Manning but they know they have no chance in getting him. I also think no matter who you have there is always someone better to take that job. Every NFL orginazation knows this. I persnally like KOLB he just needs a chance....
  • Abuse
    FitzIsMyHero wrote...
    AZSPORTSFAN,
    I don't know how to run a NFL team. Mostly bcuz of money. It's all politics. Who gets paid more. Who should get paid more etc. I do know football tho. Played football. I know what it takes for a football team to win. This football team ain't winning bcuz of their O Line and QBs. It's my opinion that the O Line makes the QB. Manning, Brady, Breese, Rodgers have excellent protection. But then there's QBs who make themselves w/o a line. Guys like Warner, E. Manning, Rivers, Roethlisberger etc. WE DON'T HAVE EITHER ONE RIGHT NOW!
  • Abuse
    FitzIsMyHero wrote...
    So...
    The Cards are either going to improve the line and give Kolb & Skelton a open competition for the job (which I think they should cuz Kolb didn't prove anything other than that he's truly prone to concussions). Skelton could only produce results in the 4th qtr. But to win you also have to play the first 3 qtrs too... Or their going to hire a guy like Manning and hope something good turns out of it. Sometimes, you need to put aside the facts and hope it goes your way. Like it was a fact when AZ signed Warner he was obviously washed up, and they hoped he'd be a good enuff backup.
  • Abuse
    esc R. wrote...
    Kolb
    sucks. He was a waste of a 2nd rd pick and DRC. pathetic and desperate move by the cards. Neither guy is not a franchise qb. I agree you roll the dice with Manning because this is a once in a lifetime opportunity. But you have to find ways to stretch your dollar if you are the cards. Need to fill needed spots and weakness on the line and at the #2 WR spot. If it works, its a great move, if not, this team was not a playoff contender with either of these scrubs behind center.
  • Abuse
    DanTheTimid wrote...
    I agree with AZSportsfan
    AZ going after Peyton says nothing about their opinion of their current QBs, just that they're not idiots, one of the greatest QBs ever to play the game becomes available, you try to get him. Everything I've heard within the organization suggests they still believe pretty strongly that Kolb will pan out, very few QBs look great in their first year with a team. And lets be serious here, Flynn, RG3, they have potential, but they haven't proven a thing yet (not unlike a certain AZ QB). Continued...
  • Abuse
    DanTheTimid wrote...
    continued....
    If we're going to roll the dice on a QB, lets continue to do it with what we've got and use picks to build a framework around them so that if we roll snake eyes, at least maybe we can win some games with a run game and defense, rather then sacrificing everything on the hope we get a top notch QB only to find he's struggling despite his skills cause we lack the tools around him (or picks/resources to get more) for even a great QB to have success.
  • Abuse
    Chuck H. wrote...
    Gambo, this is probably your worst article
    Flynn?? Really?? Isn't he just this years Kolb? A back up who's had a flash, but there is still no certainty? And what would you have to give up to get him? A 1 and 2? A 2 and 3? Seems to me they would be doing the same thing they tried to do last year. Griffin?? At what cost?? 2 #1's for a player who hasn't played a down? Why? To create a buzz???? What your asking the Cards to consider is something they tried last year and gets a grade of "I"-Incomplete. Come on Gambo. You're better than this. You already know the logical answers to your illogical article.
  • Abuse
    test354 wrote...
    Franchise QB?
    Come on,Gambo, Manning WOULD BE the Cards' franchise QB! By your definition,Warner wouldn't have been regarded as a franchise QB when he got here. All he did was get us to a SB and set new expectations for the organization,which,I'm not sure can be met with the current situation. Plus, Coach Whiz doesn't have 3 or 4 yrs to nurture the process along. The turnaround in 2011 kept him off the hot seat. I'm sure he doesn't want to feel that pain again. Win now, win often, and good things will evolve. Maybe we'll have a franchise QB in the future. After all, a QB can get a PhD learning from Manning.
  • Abuse
    ProCardinals wrote...
    Peyton's choice.
    I've heard all of the arguments of why or why not Peyton will chose the Cards as his next team, but there in lies the rub--it's Peyton's choice. Which team is similar to the Colts--the Cardinals. Which team requires an immediate answer to decide about keeping or releasing their present QB? The Cardinals. Which team has employeed under their roster one of Peyton's favorite QB coaches? Once again the Cardinals. Peyotn has been quoted to say that money is not the incentive for his choice, but rather which team can offer him a better fit for another Super Bowl ring. It's Peyton's choice.
  • Abuse
    JVC wrote...
    Manning
    Release Kolb that's first thing to do. Shore up the O-line get that RT Guard and Left Tackle. Then go get TO for a 1 year veteran minimum. Yeah I know, but name 2 receivers that is better that TO and for a Vet minimum you can send him home if he acts up. TO will pull the double team of Larry and TO will be hungry to prove that he belongs back in the NFL. Then Go get Manning. Draft ASU's old QB Oswiller ( I think hes better than Skeleton)just in case Manning say no. But then I don't own an NFL team so I can do some wishfull thinking.
close

Share: