Login

Register | Forgot Your Password? | Close
StephenDrew.jpg
Arizona Diamondbacks' Stephen Drew, left, is tagged out by Milwaukee Brewers catcher Jonathan Lucroy during the fourth inning of a baseball game on Wednesday, July 20, 2011, in Phoenix. Drew was injured his right ankle on the play and left the game. (AP Photo/Matt York)

Sometimes in life the decision gets made for you.

The sushi place is packed, let's go for pizza. Out of red cars? Blue it is. In both cases, if you really want sushi or really want a red car, you could go somewhere else and get it. Ultimately you ask the question. Can we live with pizza in a blue car? Or is it absolutely necessary to have sushi in the red?

Not the best analogy I've ever come up with but I think we've all been there.

The Arizona Diamondbacks are there. Stephen Drew is out for the year with a gruesome ankle injury suffered Wednesday night. The play will prompt sportscasters across the country to preface the highlight with the obligatory "gotta warn you, this doesn't look good, it's tough to watch" caveat. It was that bad.

The obvious questions are flying. How do you replace him? Will the team hang their heads without him? What does this say for the future of Stephen Drew and the D-backs?

Answers: You don't, certainly not with journeyman Cody Ransom. They won't, or at least they didn't on Wednesday night. And….well….you got me there. But those aren't the questions I'm asking. I'm wondering if the decision was just made for the Arizona Diamondbacks. The decision to add. To buy at the trade deadline. To be aggressive in their pursuit of help, because goodness knows they need all sorts of it now.

Or can the Arizona Diamondbacks just live with what they are?

I think the decision was just made for them. Because what you are, is good enough. Good enough to make 2009 and 2010 nothing but a speck in the rear view mirror. Good enough to believe that Kevin Towers and Kirk Gibson know exactly what they're doing. When you lose 189 games in two years you don't need to get it all back in one season. This season can already be classified as an immense success, exceeding most of the reasonable and even some of the unreasonable expectations. Parting with any of your minor league prospects who have even a whiff of potential in the name of winning now is foolish. Especially after Drew's devastating injury.

Not that he was having a bang-up year at the plate; his numbers this year are below his career averages. But asking Cody Ransom to be a poor man's Drew all while needing another starter and another bullpen arm and still trying to rebuild your farm system…..it's just too much to ask.

5 Comments   |   Join the conversation »
  • Add A Comment 
  • Abuse
    The Show Speak wrote...
    I like pizza too...
    "When you lose 189 games in two years you don't need to get it all back in one season." Spot on Dave.
  • Abuse
    Jarrod P. wrote...
    Why?
    Why would the loss of a sub par, poor hitting, consistently underachieving shortstop determine whether they win or lose? If anything, they are better off now. Now Roberts can can daily playing time or they can call up Cowgill or Abreu and move guys around. Thsi was not a true contending team anyway with this lineup. This team, though, has impressed greatly. It is a testament to Gibby. This team needed a true leader and good things are coming down the road. Jarrod
  • Abuse
    AzSunnyD wrote...
    To Jarrrod P.
    Do you really watch this team? Did you just say we are better off without Stephen Drew? You're outta your mind, while his offensive prowess leaves something to be desired (he has batted .280 or better in 3 of 6 years) his defense is so beautiful that when he occasionally doesn't get to some balls no shortstop would you wonder what's wrong. This guysavers fantastic. He regularly steals hits from batters. That means fewer base runners, which means fewer opportunities for runs allowed...and that means his lower average works out just fine...
  • Abuse
    Jarrod P. wrote...
    Hey Sunny D
    Sounds like you suffer from what I call AZ Fanitis.Its when you fall in love with a player for being a swell guy and being here for more than 4 years.Drew had one decent year,2008.This year he ranks 11th in fielding and 16th in hitting.In 4 full seasons he has batted over .280 one time.I don't hate him,but in response to this specific article,this may be a good thing.It may allow the D Backs to realize they are on the right path but not with this team, not this year.It may allow for different guys to get a shake now.Again, not a Drew hater, but this may be a good thing for this season.
  • Abuse
    Trey M. wrote...
    Drew
    I'm sure the club will miss Drew, but I think it may help inspire the team. 4 games back with only 2 months to go?? Pretty good and it's possible the Braves will fade even if the Giants keep it going. Drew is a leader and a good fielder but maybe a better bat makes up for that. For the D-backs to make a run we do need a lift from a few positions and maybe a decent middle reliever at least. It may be a lot to ask but I think we will see Gibson and his team in the race near the finish line.
close

Share: