Login

Register | Forgot Your Password? | Close
AP: 77598514-41e2-41a1-8a13-eb13a942aa39
Phoenix Suns center Marcin Gortat (4), of Poland, walks past Utah Jazz center Al Jefferson (25) during the first half of an NBA basketball game, Tuesday, April 24, 2012, in Salt Lake City. (AP Photo/Jim Urquhart)
Was it worth it?

Three years or so ago the Phoenix Suns had a decision to make:

Trade Amare Stoudemire before he likely left as a free agent, or make one last run with him, future be damned.

They decided to make one final run, and were rewarded with a trip to the Western Conference Finals before he decided to bolt for the bright lights (and extra money) New York had to offer.

Similarly, the last two seasons the team has had a similar decision to make with regards to Steve Nash and, like with Stoudemire, they've elected to keep him around in hopes of making a final run or two before he possibly left as a free agent.

They were rewarded with a pair of trips to the NBA's draft lottery.

Recently, plenty of teams have had similar decisions to make with regards to their own stars.

Last season alone we saw the Denver Nuggets and Utah Jazz part with Carmelo Anthony and Deron Williams, respectively, deciding that whatever they could possibly win with them was not worth receiving nothing in return for them over the summer.

The Nuggets shipped ‘Melo out for Wilson Chandler, Raymond Felton, Danilo Gallinari, Timofey Mozgov, one first-round pick, two second-round picks and $3 million cash.

They made the playoffs the season of the trade. They made the playoffs the season following the trade.

The Jazz, on the other hand, received Derrick Favors, Devin Harris, two first-round picks and cash considerations for Williams.

They bottomed out the year of the trade, and just clinched a playoff spot (over the Suns, mind you) the year after.

Now, this isn't to say the Suns would have received a similar package for Stoudemire or Nash. Neither player carried anything close to the value an Anthony or Williams had, so it's tough to say what exactly the team could have received in return.

But they would have received something, and that's the point.

The Cleveland Cavaliers lost LeBron James for nothing, and look at them now. Same with the Toronto Raptors and Chris Bosh. Losing stars for nothing is not a way to build a winner. Letting them go on their terms - not yours - is the way to ensure your team crumbles in their absence.

"At some point, you have to start rebuilding," TNT NBA analyst and Suns Ring of Honor member Charles Barkley said Tuesday night. "I love Steve Nash but at some point you have to start rebuilding for the future.

"He can still play but they don't need him in Phoenix."

By the way, Barkley said the Suns re-signing Nash would be "stupid."

Unfortunately for the Suns, the "stupid" part of what they've done has already come to pass. The team held onto Nash and whatever was left of a great run, squeezing some excellent basketball out of an aging player on a bad team.

And now, as the saying goes, the chickens will come home to roost.

Nash will explore free agency, just as he's said he will, and may very well leave for another team - one that has a chance to win in the coming years.

And in return, the Suns will have a roster void of impact players, instead filled with role players who can be good some nights, but struggle with consistency.

Jared Dudley and Marcin Gortat are nice players, but neither are the type you build around.

Channing Frye and Robin Lopez have had their moments, but cannot be relied on night in and night out.

The team's prized rookie, Markieff Morris, looked overwhelmed every time he was inserted into the starting lineup, and Grant Hill may follow Nash out of town.

After that, it's just a collection of players who either won't come back or have had little impact on the team to begin with.

In other words, if Nash leaves, the Suns will be bad. Very bad. Think Cavaliers, Raptors kind of bad.

Teams that do not prepare to move on without their stars struggle mightily when having to do just that. The Suns surrendered the option to part with Steve Nash on their own terms, instead leaving it up to the player.

The Suns' finale Wednesday at home may very well be the two-time MVP's final game in a purple and orange uniform. Remember to enjoy it and appreciate what you are watching, fans, because keeping Nash the last two seasons may cost the team its future.

20 Comments   |   Join the conversation »
  • Add A Comment 
  • Abuse
    Dbackjose wrote...
    Thank you MV Steve
    I want to thank you for the last 8 great years you gave us, you will be missed but it's time for the Suns to rebuild. I don't want to see crapy basketball for the next couple of years but this needs to happen and we can get some great players thru the draft and build a young team like OKC. I hope Nash wins a championship I wish it was with Phoenix but he deserves a ring.
  • Abuse
    azgbayfan wrote...
    Again?
    Green has been beating this dead horse all year. He has demonstrated his mastery of hindsight. I don't know if any time in the last 4 years would the Suns have been able to trade Nash and gotten the return that the Nuggets did for Melo. The Knicks were desperate and they overspent. They have the money. The price for Williams was very high because he was considered a top 3 point guard and was only 25 yrs old. I also question whether either team Utah or Denver make those deals had the players not forced their hand.
  • Abuse
    theAdamGreen wrote...
    @ azgbayfan
    I'd say it's not hindsight when you call it like this long before it happens, but that's not the point. None of us know what the Suns could have got in exchange for Nash, but there were offers out there. And, chances are what they could have gotten is better than the nothing they'd receive for him if he leaves.
  • Abuse
    azgbayfan wrote...
    Huh?
    You just stated that no one knows what the Suns could have got. Which I agree with, but you brought up 2 players with far more value to compare. I would dispute that deal for a couple of role players and a late round draft pick would have been better. I realize that there is no way for me to know what the offer would have been, but the same holds true with your point. I don't know that something is better than nothing holds true in the NBA. Quality is evrything. There are a lot of somethings out there
  • Abuse
    Josh M. wrote...
    One point of clarification
    Adam, you make good points but to say that Amare "decided to bolt for the bright lights (and extra money) New York had to offer" is, while technically accurate, a bit misleading. Robert Sarver offered a contract that was not a legitimate offer to keep Amare around. No NBA player has ever signed a contract contingent on games played. Sarver knew very well that a team would offer Amare a fully guaranteed max deal, and that there was zero chance that his "offer" would be signed.
  • Abuse
    Josh M. wrote...
    One point of clarification (part 2)
    The only reason Sarver offered this deal was as a PR move to con fans into thinking that Amare left for more money, when in reality, Sarver had no intention of signing Amare.
  • Abuse
    Rainex80 wrote...
    lottery
    I have put Phoenix Suns 2013 Draft Lottery Winner shirts into production.
  • Abuse
    desert designer wrote...
    Not So Much The Talent as The Identity
    When Steve signs with a contender and the Suns are left with nothing. The most striking thought to me is that this team will no longer have an identity figure. Once Steve is gone the identity of this club goes with him. That will be the hardest thing to replace not only for it's own sake but to the guys that may sign for next year and beyond. Whose team will it be? We have nobody that can assume that role. The Suns are in deep doodoo and it's mgmnts fault.
  • Abuse
    Tennisgrandpa wrote...
    Simple
    Get rid of the dead weight and hoard draft picks. This is going to be one of the best drafts in a long time. No superstars but alot of very good stars. Load up, go young and forget Nash. He was great while he was here but when we lost Amare, we were done then. The western conference final thing was a fluke and could not be duplicated again. GO YOUNG!!
    Dale
  • Abuse
    sundevil7901 wrote...
    Suns
    Hoarding draft picks WOULD have been a good strategy, and Nash probably could have fetched the Suns a late first rounder, or a 2nd rounder as a throw-in with another player. Too late for that now.
close

Share: