Login

Register | Forgot Your Password? | Close
SSUpton.jpg
Justin Upton was supposed to be 'the man' for the D-backs, but now people can't wait to run him out of town. (AP Photo)
Sports fans have a problem, and nowhere has it been more evident than right here in Arizona.

We don't like our best and most talented athletes.

Going back as long as I can remember, we've always had a great appreciation for the less-talented, hard-working players.

It's why guys like Brian Henesey, Elliot Perry, Andy Fox, Andy Stankiewicz, Craig Counsell and Louis Amundson, Ryan Roberts and Max Hall gain a cult-like following.

We root for the underdog, the player who, despite his physical limitations, tries as hard as he can and gets what we think is the most out of his meager abilities.

And, conversely, it's why players like Amare Stoudemire, Matt Leinart, Justin Upton and Trevor Bauer struggle for support, have fans constantly questioning their effort and, generally, waiting for the day the team can "rid" itself of its biggest problem.

Except, you know, talented players are rarely a team's real problem.

We have a nasty habit of focusing on what a player can't do, all the while failing to understand how much he actually can do.

Ever wonder why our teams don't win?

If sports prove anything, it's that greatness generally comes out on top. You need stars -- faults and all -- to have a legitimate chance to win. While a group of underdogs winning makes for a good story, the truth is that only happens in the movies and my indoor soccer league.

Talent is a requirement, and it almost seems as if Arizona, due to a lack of bona-fide stars, does not know it when it sees it.

Sure, Stoudemire's defense was lacking and he wasn't a great rebounder, but wow could that guy score points. And yes, Upton has had a down year and made some questionable comments about fans, but rarely do you find the blend of skills he has in one player. While he hasn't been nearly as successful at any point in his pro career as those two, did Leinart really get a chance with Cardinals fans? Or, maybe, were people ready to run the "golden boy" out of town the second they saw photos of him in that hot tub with a few ladies?

Oh the horror, young guys doing what young guys do, be it on the field with some struggles or off it with learning how to deal with their social status.

And now it's happening with Bauer, who has been sent back to Triple-A just four bad starts into his career. Hell, just three innings into his major league career people were giving up on him, and ever since there's almost been this anticipation of his impending failure.

It's almost as if people wanted him to stumble, possibly because they didn't like his routine or feel like he's too arrogant and needs to be humbled.

In sports the difference between arrogance and confidence is success. It's that simple.

Fans have an idea of what their athletes should be like, and if one doesn't fit into that mold -- be it style of play, personality or something else -- they will not be accepted.

Sports fans don't like rooting for the player who tells us he's going to be great, and then actually goes out and is just that, nor are we fond of the player who fails to meet what may very well be unrealistic expectations. They are supposed to be great, after all, so why celebrate them for doing what was expected? And, if they're not? That's simply unacceptable.

Good isn't great, and great isn't enough.

And until that changes our teams will struggle to be good, and rarely be great.

15 Comments   |   Join the conversation »
  • Add A Comment 
  • Abuse
    daamage wrote...
    great article
    your one of the better writers of the franchise
  • Abuse
    CroDawg wrote...
    So much to say
    Although I appreciate the article there are a lot of examples that could dispute the gist of it. Example #1- Fitz. So as devils advocate I'll just say that in my opinion there's no evidence that points to J Upton being an actual star. He's above average at best, and when you basically say you don't care what the people say who buy your tickets and your jersey, you do have an attitude problem or at the very least are not in touch with the fans. In another point, we as AZ fans are blessed with a guy like Fitz and maybe he has just set the bar too high for anyone else.
  • Abuse
    theAdamGreen wrote...
    @ CroDawg
    Agreed on Fitz, though I think he's generally the exception. As for Upton's comments, I think it's a matter of fans reading into them what they want. Upton was saying his concern is what his teammates think of him and his effort, and when he's struggling that makes total sense. Of course he doesn't want to let the fans down.
  • Abuse
    CroDawg wrote...
    I agree with your point....
    I also think AZ fans are somewhat fairweather. It seems there is always some sort of controversy going on: kolb/skelton, now many fans are ready to get rid of K. Marshal after one D-league game, and certainly Upton. I want J Upton to succeed because I want the DBacks to succeed. And I'm against trading him. I will say it seemed as though the national media is what really projected the Upton trade rumors. I guess that all started with the fans booing. As a fan I just hate to think that we were somehow responsible if J Up does get traded. I'm just ready for the Cards!
  • Abuse
    kjfeil wrote...
    Great is compelling
    I would argue that Arizona sports fans, like those in any market support their stars more than anything. The proof is in what fans find compelling, and that pans out in television ratings. Fans SAY they love underdogs, but ratings plummet when they advance. Ratings SHOW that fans actually prefer watching favorites; storied franchises and star players.
  • Abuse
    kjfeil wrote...
    Great is compelling (2)
    The NBA playoffs reached numbers not seen since the Jordan era, and they didn't do it because fans tuned in to see a bunch of underdogs, they did it because the league's #1 superstar (Lebron James) was putting together a statistical run like we've never before seen.
  • Abuse
    kjfeil wrote...
    Great is compelling (3)
    It is the same with local sports, Steve Nash and Amare Stoudemire are compelling, Elliot Perry is not, so while the latter may gain cult following (manifested by otherwise reasonable people wearing goofy socks!), the former is what fans will actually tune in to watch and shell out cash to attend.
  • Abuse
    arkaic wrote...
    No.
    I like when writers take one instance and extrapolate it to be taken as a city's entire history. This town loves it's stars. I don't know what you are talking about. The town loved Kevin Johnson, Charles Barkley, Kurt Warner, Fitz, Curt Schilling, Randy Johnson, Gonzo, Boldin, Stoudemire. There are so many more that you could name that this town loved. To say that a town doesn't love it's stars and that is why they lose is totally ignorant.
  • Abuse
    bonedoc wrote...
    Rediculous article
    I am a DIE HARD AZ sports fan and I find this article offensive. Maybe if one of our franchises would WIN (2001 Dbacks excluded) there would be more accolades for so-called "franchise" athletes. J-up has been AWFUL this year and deserves to get booed. He should be professional enough to take it like a man. Do you think Fitz or Nash would have responded like Upton did? What about Charles Barkley, Kevin Johnson, Tom Chambers, Louis Gonzales? I'd say its clear that we AZ Sports fans have always respected them as world-class athletes.
  • Abuse
    DX4our wrote...
    Real fans
    My theory is that the real Arizona fans, the ones who actually know the ins and outs of the games know that trading Upton and our bona-fide stars is not in the best interest of the franchise. The other half of the fans, fans who live in AZ but are really fans of someone else don't care if they go to a game and boo our best players. That is AZ's biggest problem. Half of our fan base are people who come from somewhere else and root for other teams. The real AZ fans know whats best for our teams, and know we need star players. As for the rest they could care less.
close

Share: