Login

Register | Forgot Your Password? | Close
AP: c7fa08ba-6e90-465b-ba13-f8f39636ca67
Arizona Cardinals quarterback John Skelton (19) throws against the Oakland Raiders during the first half of a preseason NFL football game, Friday, Aug. 17, 2012, in Glendale, Ariz. (AP Photo/Rick Scuteri)
Nobody likes a speed trap.

Whether you are really going "too fast" or not, you can fall victim to one at pretty much any time.

I annoyingly learned this the hard way over weekend coming back from California. The highway patrolman said I was going too fast and decided to give me a ticket.

Interestingly enough, Cardinals coach Ken Whisenhunt deserves a ticket -- or at least, a warning -- for going too slow in naming a starting quarterback.

After all, he has one.

Let's pretend for a moment Kevin Kolb did not enter training camp as the starter. It was not "his job to lose" nor did he have an advantage over John Skelton. Put both QBs on equal footing and let them battle, with the best man winning the job.

Three games in Kolb has completed 5-of-15 passes for 47 yards with one interception.

Three games in Skelton has completed 10-of-15 passes for 90 yards with one touchdown and one interception.

They've each been pressured by defenses, yet Skelton is able to handle it and still make plays. Kolb, on the other hand, is not.

The former Eagle's struggles are so pronounced now that opponents are calling him out, saying he's "scared back there."

Not surprisingly, Kolb disagreed with the assessment.

"I have never been afraid of anyone on the field and that will never change," he told AZCardinals.com's Darren Urban.

Kolb was sacked three times by the Raiders; he's clearly not afraid to take a hit. He is, however, afraid to take chances in the name of making plays.

Yes, the offensive line deserves some blame, which is something Coach Whiz noted after the game Friday.

"Some of it, I will say, a couple of times Kevin's gotta get the ball out, but to be perfectly honest with you our protection has broken down a couple of times," he said.

It's broken down more than a couple of times because it's a bad offensive line. There's simply no getting around that fact (unless the line is trying to stop you, in which case it shouldn't be too difficult).

We've seen this exact same script play out before so we know how the movie ends.

Two years ago a Tennessee Titan was quoted as saying, "I got a buffalo nickel that says he checksdown" in reference to then-Cards QB Matt Leinart.

Leinart had gained a reputation for being unwilling to throw the ball downfield and reluctant to stand in the pocket behind a shaky line and take a hit, even if it meant trying to deliver the ball down the field. He would dump the ball off to a tight end or running back as soon as he could, completing the pass but gaining little yardage.

That -- among other things -- led Whisenhunt to demote Leinart during the preseason and releasing him a week before the regular season opener in a move that ended weeks of speculation.

Back then the coach may have waited to officially make the move because if it wasn't Leinart it was going to be Derek Anderson or Max Hall, neither of which were options worth getting excited about.

Now, though, he can turn to Skelton, a QB who not only shows promise, but an ability to make plays even when things are crumbling around him. He did it as an inexperienced rookie, he did it last season after Kolb went down with an injury, and he's doing it now in the preseason while trying to win a job he was never supposed to even contend for.

Coach Whisenhunt may not have expected a real competition and, to be honest, probably didn't want one. In a perfect world Kolb would have played well and earned the job, validating the organization's faith in him and setting the team up for what should be an exciting season.

But as they say, "the best laid schemes of mice and men often go awry," and this one is no exception.

The Cardinals did get a competition, and it has determined a winner.

So it begs the question: why is Coach Whisenhunt slow to acknowledge it?

12 Comments   |   Join the conversation »
  • Add A Comment 
  • Abuse
    Steve L. wrote...
    Does it matter?
    Does it matter if Skelton becomes the starting QB? Sure he has looked better than Kolb but that's not saying much. Skelton was the 32nd ranked QB last year behind 3 new rookies and he had Larry Fitzgerald to pass to. The guy is too inaccurate. Looking good in preseason does not equate to being a star in regular season. After this year, the Cards will be looking for another QB. It might even happen before that.
  • Abuse
    esc R. wrote...
    whiz needs
    to man up and DRAFT and DEVELOP a real QB. stop trading and signing crappy FA players. Time to get one in the draft that you can build around.
  • Abuse
    theuglytruth wrote...
    Build around Skelton
    He's progressed nicely wihtout commitment to build around him. It will be ugly this year, but if the Cards can commit to build around him, I think he can be solid...not probowl, but maybe flacco/alex smith solid. If we start all over again, we burn another 2-3 years developing the new guy. They'll miss Fitzgerald's prime. It's clear you cannot plug and play a QB (example: DA, Kolb) into this system.
  • Abuse
    sundevil7901 wrote...
    No official announcement because
    Skelton was going to start anyway on Thursday, so likely the gameplan was not going to be affected.
  • Abuse
    SpaceRig wrote...
    Why the rush?
    Why are we so desperate for Whiz to name the starter? He knows we're in a @#%# situation, we know we're in a @#%! situation, why the rush? This 3rd game should be the dress rehearsal for a real game and we'll have plenty of time to name the starter once it's over. The truth is that neither player has shined and Whiz probably doesn't feel that either of them is worthy of the starter title at this point.
  • Abuse
    hugUhbear wrote...
    To be honest, whoever becomes the 1st string QB
    is going to get hurt and be out of the line-up for a while. Skelton or Kolb are going to get blitzed many many times without the CARDs starting LT getting a finger on the rusher. I say this based on Levi starting. Now that we will have to start an even worse OT than Levi all us cards fans can hope for is that our starting QB is not the 1st QB in NFL history to get killed on the field. Only half joking there. Our starting QB is probably going to be psychologically damaged from this season; start seeing a therapist ASAP Skelton.
  • Abuse
    thorjeremy501 wrote...
    Skelton time
    I never have been more excited to see an AZ QB play and develop until now. Skelton has what it takes to win a super bowl and he was higher in the draft than Brady!
  • Abuse
    Think4URself wrote...
    Why? Really?
    Ummm, not sure exactly how to say this, but...it is all about ego. No one on that staff wants to admit they supported the signing. Some may not remember, but it is clear as day to me. That decision was a kneejerk emotional decision following Bidwell hearing 'Boos' week-in and week-out as fans watched Anderson make a mockery of the position. Since, there were and have been better alternatives, but, poor decision making skills and large egos have perpetuated the QB problem. TIME TO MAKE A CHANGE IN THE FRONT OFFICE...hint, hint, GM.
  • Abuse
    Mgoblu62 wrote...
    SKELTON really???
    the dude is a loser at qb if hes the cards future its as dim as it has ever been good luck card fans on your 4-11 season this year
  • Abuse
    FitzIsMyHero wrote...
    theuglytruth has a point
    I think this should be a pursuasion year for Skelton. In other words, "pursuade me to stick with you". Larry is in fact in his prime or maybe even on the verge of coming off of the prime of his career. Obviously, AZ will be keeping their eye out for a prospective QB in Free Agency or in the draft until they find that "Franchise QB", but, I think, Skelton can be developed, and a contending team can be built around him. Like I said - this is probably a pursuasion year for Skelton. His destiny is in his own hands. @Mgoblu62, Skelton, as a starter, has a winning record (8-5). Google it.
close

Share: