Updated Feb 4, 2011 - 9:15 am
Warner: Roethlisberger not deserving of Hall of Fame spot yet
PHOENIX - Former Arizona Cardinals quarterback Kurt Warner said Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Ben Roethlisberger will not have done enough to be inducted into the Hall of Fame even if he wins a third Super Bowl this Sunday.
Warner was asked on Sports 620 KTAR's Gambo and Ash show if he thought Roethlisberger belonged in the Hall of Fame. Not yet, according to Warner.
Warner disputed the idea that winning championships alone should get someone into the Hall of Fame.
"I believe that this era has become about winning championships for a quarterback," Warner said. "But I just look at it from the fact that the best players to ever play this game belong in the Hall of Fame. And I'm not saying he won't be that guy. But I'm not sure he's there yet.
I'm not sure if he just wins this game if that classifies him as one of the best to ever play the game."
Warner said that it would take more than Super Bowl rings and Roethlisberger's 10-2 record in the playoffs to get him into the Hall of Fame.
"I like Ben," Warner said. "I think Ben's great and I think he's a winner. And to me that speaks volumes for your legacy. But when you're talking about the best quarterbacks in the league, you have to look at all the factors here.
I mean, he won a Super Bowl and he was 8-23. But he won the Super Bowl and he gets that on his resume. But he was still 8-23." (Roethlisberger completed 9-21 passes in Super Bowl XL against the Seattle Seahawks.)
According to Warner, Roethlisberger has never carried his team for long stretches, though he admits that is something he has never been given the chance to do.
Warner points to Tom Brady as a Hall-of-Fame-caliber quarterback who has both won Super Bowls and carried his team over the course of a season. He offered up Philip Rivers as an example of a quarterback who has carried his team over the past few seasons, but has yet to lead the Chargers to a Super Bowl.
Warner emphasized that if the 28-year-old Roethlisberger could prove that he could carry his team for a few seasons that he would be a "no-brainer" to make it into the Hall of Fame.
While Warner doesn't think Roethlisberger has earned his spot in the Hall of Fame yet, he does envy Roethlisberger's Super Bowl rings.
Warner, who has won two NFL MVP awards and won one Super Bowl, said that he would trade a spot in the Hall of Fame for more Super Bowl wins.
"What would I rather have - be in the Hall of Fame or …winning three championships? I'd take the three championships. To me that's what it's all about. That's the bottom line."
Warner came on the show to see why show co-host John Gambadoro said he would choose Roethlisberger over him.
- Carson Palmer: Arizona Cardinals are 'completely different team' from last year
- Arizona Cardinals sign wide receiver/kick returner Reggie Dunn
- The 5: Top storylines heading into Arizona Cardinals training camp
- Arizona Cardinals' Patrick Peterson and Michael Floyd rank high on ESPN's list of top under-25 players
- ESPN: Arizona Cardinals loaded with under-25 talent
- Impromptu Power Poll - Friday July 25What are the top 5 position battles for the AZ Cardinals heading into training camp?
- Carson Palmer, AZ Cardinals QB - Friday July 25Cardinals QB Carson Palmer describes the key to this offense winning games.
- John Clayton, ESPN NFL Insider - Friday July 25ESPN NFL Insider John Clayton talks about Marshawn Lynch’s impending holdout.
- Bickley Blast - Thursday July 24What will the future hold for the Cardinals and Larry Fitzgerald?
- Dr. Cynthia Arnson - Immigration and Central America Expert - Tuesday July 22Why are we seeing this influx of immigrant minors?