Login

Register | Forgot Your Password? | Close
AP: 78c7fe72-f6d8-4443-a9c1-5fe4a9fe8266
Minnesota Vikings defensive end Brian Robison pressures Arizona Cardinals quarterback Kevin Kolb (4) during the first half of an NFL football game on Sunday, Oct. 9, 2011, in Minneapolis. Kolb fumbled on the play and Minnesota recovered. (AP Photo/Jim Mone)
Without question, the rumors about where Kevin Kolb would land to play quarterback in 2011 were the most prevalent during the offseason and NFL lockout. Of course, most people knew that Kolb would end up in Arizona, and he did.

We know that the Cardinals gave up a lot to get him. We also know that the Cardinals rewarded Kolb with a hefty contract that guarantees him $21 million.

This decision split Cardinal fans into two different categories; those who though Kolb was the answer, and those who thought the price the Cardinals paid in the trade and the contract was entirely too steep for a player who had seven career NFL starts heading into the season.

After a 1-4 start including Sunday's 34-10 loss at Minnesota (and the Kolb era), and the number of fans heaping on criticism on Kolb, blaming him for the dismal showing and calling for his ouster is growing by the minute.

The question is, why?

I nearly fell off my chair on Sunday following the Cardinals' ugly 34-10 loss to the previously winless Minnesota Vikings, when a caller phoned into "Cardinal Talk" with Jon Bloom and Rob Fredrickson, and suggested that Richard Bartel is the answer for the Cardinals at QB.

Huh?

Look, I'm the first to admit that Kolb has been average at best. He was good against Carolina, decent against Washington and the Giants and bad against Seattle and Minnesota.

But if you're arguing that Kolb's not the answer because he doesn't have the experience at this level, you can't, in the next breath, suggest that a guy who has thrown a total of 34 garbage-time passes in the NFL is.

And don't throw the "Bartel was awesome in the preseason" argument at me either. So was Max Hall. The NFL preseason is nearly meaningless—it's a dressed-up practice. Seattle's Charlie Whitehurst was the league's top rated passer in the preseason. To quote Forrest Gump, "that's all I have to say about that".

On my list of concerns with this football team heading into the bye week, Kevin Kolb's play ranks 5th. The offensive line has done a less-than-stellar job in protecting Kolb. He was sacked four times against the Vikings, and was hit six more. There's already been a shuffle at right tackle with Jeremy Bridges replacing Brandon Keith. At left tackle, Levi Brown is, well, he's Levi Brown.

On defense, the pass rush from outside linebackers has been virtually non-existent. Veterans Joey Porter and Clark Haggans have combined for one quarterback sack this season. They've been able to hold off youngsters O'Brien Schofield and Sam Acho on the depth chart despite little production.

And the pass coverage, for the most part, has been bad as well. It's not that evident on the stat sheet from Sunday, mostly because Donovan McNabb isn't very good, and the Vikings ran the ball on nearly 64% of their offensive snaps. Both A.J. Jefferson (who was actually pretty good on Sunday) and Patrick Peterson have been picked on, and the safeties have lagged in coverage all season.

And there's also that issue of number two wide receiver. Andre Roberts has been a disappointment so far, and Early Doucet has been okay. But neither is a big enough threat to dissuade opposing defenses from bracketing Larry Fitzgerald. Fitz has more catches through five games this year (28) than last (26), but has been targeted 11 less times. This is simply because he's rarely open because of the defense's attention to him.

I won't sit here and say everything's fine with the Arizona Cardinals and that it's early, there's a lot of football left, and they play in the worst division in the NFL. From what I've seen through five games, I can't paint that picture with any kind of conscience.

This is a below-average football team at best. But the blame shouldn't be pointed solely in the direction of the quarterback.

No, this 1-4 start has been a total team effort.

11 Comments   |   Join the conversation »
  • Add A Comment 
  • Abuse
    the cooker wrote...
    Could not agree more
    Yes Kolb has made some screw ups, but the problem still is Coach Whiz and his approach of not holding anybody accountable. This is NOT a high school team (even though they play like one). These guys get paid lots of money, but Whiz acts like he is afraid of hurting their feelings, and like he is running a fast food joint and worried they will go to work for the competition and he won't be able to replace them for the weekend.
  • Abuse
    Jimmer wrote...
    Who is that man behind the curtain?
    Players are first and foremost responsible for their poor play but head coaches are responsible for their players. Wiz seems to be still riding all of the good feelings that came from going to the SuperBowl but I am beginning to think that Kurt Warner should be getting all of the credit for that. What has Wiz done since he left? The Cards were simply not prepared and ready to play yesterday and that is coaching. Holding players accountable starts with the coach being accountable for who he puts out there and the plays he is calling on offense.
  • Abuse
    theuglytruth wrote...
    Twitter
    ...it sure seems like these guys have plenty of time for twitter and bs'n around on their off days!
  • Abuse
    FitzIsMyHero wrote...
    Yea, Whizz...
    needs to hold the players and hisself accountable because we know thats why. I dont know who has been calling the offensive plays on gameday, but the calls they run don't make sense in certain situations. He passes A LOT! I can tell Kolb is playing out of his comfort level. Whiz isnt gameplanning to their strenghts (which right now is pounding Beanie because his body's a beast and he's motivated and has been producing). The O Coor calls a pass play when they should run, a run play when they should pass, and conservative when they should no huddle.
  • Abuse
    Guyinaz wrote...
    Kolb is basically still a rookie
    He is making rookie mistakes, he holds on to the ball too long, is not stepping up in the pocket - rather backing up too much. How many games has he played in? 7 or 8 total? He had basically 2 weeks of training camp to grasp the offense. His arm is sound and he has accuracy The thing that is glaring is Levi Brown's inability to stop ANYONE. Moreover the entire offensive line has to shoulder responsibility, look how many tipped passes there have been. Porter Haggans have lost several steps on their game and make zero impact. How they are starting OLB is beyond me
  • Abuse
    Lil Nigh wrote...
    Kolb has no chance
    Kevin Kolb has proven he simply can't read defenses. Although the offensive line and poor play selection, has also contributed to our failure. He is the leader of the team and needs to accept full responsibilty, especially after demanding a handsome contract.
  • Abuse
    AZCRAB wrote...
    CARDS NOT PREPARED TO PLAY
    I love whiz, and think he is a great guy and a good coach. However, this team has showed that it is soft, and was completely unprepared mentaly to play against the Vikings and the Seahawks. I put that on the Coaches, and the veteran leadership. The O-line(Levi Brown) and lack of pass rush on defense are also major ongoing problems. With SF 4-1 and Seattle traveling to NY and winning, I am not buying the excuse of this team "just needs time to click" because of a new Qb and D-coordinator anymore either. GET IT TOGETHER CARDS!!!!!!!!!
  • Abuse
    nateearl wrote...
    Remember Kurt
    For those fans screaming about Kolb, I would remind them of the pre-bandwagon days (before the Super Bowl). Kurt Warner's first season with the Cardinals ended with him going 2-8 as a starter. This from the QB who is easily the best this team has had since moving to Arizona. And he had already been in multiple Super Bowls so he was not as inexperienced as Kolb. Kurt Warner's record was 27-30 as a starter in Arizona, so let's give the kid Kolb at least a full year before we scream for his head.
  • Abuse
    giguy wrote...
    accountability for kolb and whiz
    yes the cards have many problems, but near the top of the list is kolb. Even if he has only had a handful of starts, there are certain redflags I see at this point. This guy has no pocket presence, cannot sense pressure, is scared to step up in the pocket to make a play and locks on a reciever without going through his progressions. At this stage in his career (even if it is early) he should be further along in these aspects. I think if we are in the andrew luck sweepstakes by the end of the year, we should cut our losses and go for him.
    sa
  • Abuse
    Jarrod P. wrote...
    Still has 3 games....
    to prove he can play. But really, what does he have to play with? Fitzgerald and......exactly. The Pittsburgh experiment has failed. Clear house- Whis is the main problem. I have never seen a coach deteriorate so quickly. Everyone pounced on me when I said Warner was making Whis look like he new how to coach. Well... cant argue that now, can you? Kolb will be a good qb but he has no shot at doing anything but learning this season.
close

Share: