Login

Register | Forgot Your Password? | Close
Sunday's game between the Arizona Cardinals and Philadelphia Eagles at Lincoln Financial Field will mark the first time the two teams have met since the NFC Championship Game following the 2008 season.

It will also be the first time Cardinals' quarterback Kevin Kolb and Eagles' defensive back Dominique Rodgers- Cromartie will line up against their former teams after being traded for each other back in July. Although it's doubtful Kolb will get a chance to play in front of the fans that once cheered (and booed) him as he is still recovering from a turf toe injury suffered against Baltimore.

Both teams have played half of their schedule, and it's fair to say that the trade hasn't benefited one team more than the other.

In fact, Kolb and Rodgers-Cromartie are among the biggest targets for criticism in their respective cities. Don't believe me?

CSNPhilly.com pinpoints three plays in the Eagles' 30-24 loss to the Bears on Monday that were pivotal to the outcome and pinned to Rodgers-Cromartie.

And the commenters on such websites aren't exactly holding their tongues, either.

Rodgers-Cromartie is softer than Asante out there. So many plays where he hesistates to wrap up and tackle. - Cheese Steaks87

The Cards were rolling over with laughter when the Birds took this bum off their hands. What a waste. Soft as charmin and dumber than a box of freaking rocks. - sam.b

I think we could have switched Kolb to DB and gotten the same results we've gotten from this guy. Running around out there like he doen't have a clue. - ozmundo

Monday night's game wasn't the first time that notoriously harsh Philly fans have spewed venom toward DRC. Following a loss to Buffalo, Rodgers-Cromartie admitted that his effort wasn't up to par following a slant pass on which he moved away from tackling a receiver. The insult floodgates opened after that display as well.

Rodgers-Cromartie is the Eagles' nickel back and ranks 10th on the squad in total tackles. He doesn't have an interception and has broken up 4 passes this season.

Things haven't been much rosier in Phoenix for Kolb, considering that he has the added pressure of a shiny, new $63 million contract the Cardinals gave him following the trade.

Kolb ranks tied for 23rd in passer rating and the Cardinals are 2-6 at the midway point of the season. Only one of those wins came with Kolb at quarterback.

His footwork, pocket presence and accuracy have all been called into question. And now he's hurt and spent Sunday watching his teammates pull out an improbable win over the St. Louis Rams.

And you know what that means? It means the concoction of a quarterback controversy by fans, some who believe that backup John Skelton provides the Cardinals a better chance to win and others that believe the team should "Suck for Luck" and tank games to have a chance to draft Stanford quarterbacking phenom Andrew Luck.

Doesn't it seem like just yesterday that the Cardinals thought Kolb's presence in the offense would elevate them back to the top of the NFC West?

And it wasn't too long ago that some were trumping the acquisition of DRC by "The Dream Team" enough to make it sound like no opposing team would complete a pass on the Eagles set of corners.

What a difference half of a season makes.

Any way you slice it, the big trade between the Cardinals and Eagles has been a wash, and I don't mean that in a good way.

Then again, the Eagles did finagle a 2nd-round pick out of Arizona too, so...slight advantage Philadelphia.

11 Comments   |   Join the conversation »
  • Add A Comment 
  • Abuse
    esc R. wrote...
    slight?
    That pick is a big advantage for them. They can go get much needed younger talent on their team while we get worse for the Kolb trade. Bad, desperate move. Kolb is more of a disappointment then DRC. He plays a bigger role and suppose to be our future. time for the cards to suck it up, trade Kolb for a pick and rebuild.
  • Abuse
    AZSPORTFAN wrote...
    Wash What
    The only thing that needs to be washed is these articles. How can anyone call Kolb a wash? (It's Way To Early) Skelton wasn't any better and to already consider Luck a quarterbacking phenom is absolutely absurd. NOTHING IS A SURE THING.......... Well almost nothing..........These articles are always a sure thing......... ALWAYS CRAP
  • Abuse
    FitzIsMyHero wrote...
    Its been looking like that
    I havent seen anything promising or exciting or "wowwing" from him. I think its a combination of bad O Line play and bad Offensive Playcalling. Its not entirely his fault but its a matter of playing with what you have. You have the best WR in football who demands every DBs back on the field. How can you not get the others involved? He lacks a fast release and his WRs cant get seperation and his line cant block and his coaches cant coach. HIS COACHES CANT COACH!
  • Abuse
    Vince Marotta wrote...
    AZSPORTFAN
    Where in this article do I refer to Kolb as a wash? I said the trade has been a wash, thus the title of the article. It hasn't worked out for either team to this point, and I would agree with you that it's way too early to judge Kolb.
  • Abuse
    DanTheTimid wrote...
    I agree with Heath R.
    That pick is HUGE, especially when you consider how high of a pick its likely going to be. If it were straight up Kolb for DRC (as I and many others were suggesting it should be at the time) then yeah, definitely a wash, both have been disappointments so far. If we'd thrown in a 5th round pick I'd say slight advantage Philly. But we threw in a 2nd round pick, so yeah, Philly, so far at least, are the big winners. But, as many have said, the jury is still out on Kolb, so still crossing my fingers he can improve and be good enough to make this trade a wash.
  • Abuse
    hugUhbear wrote...
    To early to say but take Chicago for example
    Chicago QB J.Cutler was getting sacked so often he went to the Off. Co-ordinator and told him something had to change. So his OC talked with the O-line, pulled some plays, worked on schemes to add more protection and surprise..against the Eagles--no sacks. Why can't we protect Kolb?? Larry + Doucet + Roberts will get open if you can give Kolb time.
  • Abuse
    AZSPORTFAN wrote...
    Vince
    You bring up price for Kolb, Rankings on Kolb, Footwork, Pocket Presence and Accuracy on Kolb, and then title your article (Kolb for DRC: It's a wash). So where in this article do you NOT concider Kolb a wash. On the other side DRC wasn't dependable....... Rodgers-Cromartie was let go because he was never consistant. The so-called dream team is using him as an escape goat because they are like us and can't get anything going. They have some of the best players in the NFL and still suck. The Cardinals are putting together something great and no body sees it.
  • Abuse
    FitzIsMyHero wrote...
    AZSPORTSFAN
    There is nothing great about this team (except for Larry Fitzgerald). I agree with you that this team has some talent but they dont have enough. On top of that, the coaching staff cant get them motivated to play 4 qtrs (except against a sorry team like the Rams). AZ needs a new coach.
  • Abuse
    theuglytruth wrote...
    No, it isn't a wash
    Because if we needed a 1 win QB, we already had plenty of those on the roster. Considering the secondary play/injuries...it would have been better to keep DRC and the 2nd round pick.
  • Abuse
    sundevil7901 wrote...
    Definition of "Wash"
    I don't mean to interject, but I think Vince is just trying to say that the TRADE Kolb for DRC is a wash, meaning that neither side has benefitted from the trade (as of now). Since neither team is really better off (yet) for making the trade, the trade, at this point, is a "wash". Feel free to correct me if I am wrong.
close

Share: