Login

Register | Forgot Your Password? | Close
AP: 761530cd-d505-4c9b-949a-189e2e4f1673
Arizona Cardinals' John Skelton, left, passes in the first half of an NFL football game against the Philadelphia Eagles, Sunday, Nov. 13, 2011, in Philadelphia. (AP Photo/Matt Slocum)
This so-called quarterback controversy for the Arizona Cardinals won't go away.

And while it's not as widespread as say, Team Edward vs. Team Jacob, the Kolb vs. Skelton argument has been an intriguing one in the Valley for the last three weeks.

Let me lay my cards on the table: I'm a Kolb guy. Okay, let me rephrase that. I'm a guy who believes that it's way too early to hand the offense over to Skelton, especially considering Kolb's injury and the hefty contract he signed after being traded to the Cardinals. Eight starts is not nearly a big enough sample size to form an opinion on Kolb's future (although I guess the Cardinals did that when they gave him $63 million, but I digress).

That being said, if John Skelton can go into San Francisco and beat the first-place 49ers, it'll get a lot harder for head coach Ken Whisenhunt not to give him the job.

Most Skelton supporters point to his 4-2 record as a starter as a reason that he should be the man steering the offense. It's almost like a mini-Tebow argument (with my sincere apologies to Skelton's ability to actually throw a football).

Think about it: Tebow supporters say "who cares what his numbers look like? He just wins games." And there is some truth to that. Winning is the ultimate statistic in any sport.

But a little deeper look into Skelton's win list reveals that he hasn't exactly beaten great teams on his way to that record. His four pro wins have come against Denver (2010), Dallas (2010), St. Louis and Philadelphia--four teams with a combined record of 12-29 at the time of the game.

But a win over the 49ers, a team that is not only 8-1 and has given up the least points in the NFL, but also has had the Cardinals' number over the last two years, might be enough to turn my thinking around.

And maybe Ken Whisenhunt's as well.

4 Comments   |   Join the conversation »
  • Add A Comment 
  • Abuse
    FitzIsMyHero wrote...
    Just win
    Stats are just #'s but wins are wins. We need them a lot around here John...
  • Abuse
    CardsFan_ wrote...
    Just wins...
    is short-term thinking. There are very few long-term winning QBs with mediocre-to-bad stats in the past 30 years or so. (It was possible in the old days, but not since the emergence of the pass in the late-70's.) Many QBs win for 6-8 games, but stats are a better indicator of long-term success than brief periods of winning games are. But, if Skelton can win on Sunday and look good in the process, I think you have to keep him in there to make a run for a wild card spot. But once the season is effectively over, or if Skelton is mediocre again, you have to let Kolb continue to develop.
  • Abuse
    hugUhbear wrote...
    We need to go into this ready to fight
    69's games are physical, at least they are when we play them. I sure hope that the Cardinals are mentally prepared for a brawl. Line play is going to be very intense and blood will flow, expect it. Rage on Big RED.
  • Abuse
    AZCrazy wrote...
    Audition
    Vince, You're right about this being Skelton's audition. There is no substitute for winning. This weekend, Skelton will either come out and win, which would be incredible - or he will lose well in a tight game to a good team, which would be very intriguing - or he looks like a dope and loses badly, in which case we see Kolb the rest of the year. If Skelton manages to win this game, it's a done deal. It has to be. It's very much like Denver's situation. Orton is a much better quarterback than Tebow. Orton is 0-5. Tebow is 4-1. You ride the winner.
close

Share: