Gambo- DA was terrible, Max was terrible the difference is DA has been around for years and it is reasonable to conclude that he is not going to get any better at least not better enough to warrant losing games with him.
Max has had two bad games. the first one was his debut in the nfl, the second was in a rainstorm in a division game at one of the more hostile environments the nfl has to offer.
If he flounders again against Tampa Bay at home you might have a point otherwise i think you have jumped the gun big time on this one.
I didn't understand why Max Hall was getting so much hype. I think the guy has potential but he needs a year or two of NFL experience before I would expect him to be ready to play as a starting NFL quarterback. If this season is going to be on-the-job training for Max Hall then it will likely be an ugly season for the Cardinals. I understand Maxx Hall suffered a concussion in yesterday's game so I hope it's a mild one.
Your opinion means nothing to Cardinal fans. You don't even like them. Your a typical east coast fan that thinks nothing good happens west of the New York state. We would actually listen to you, if you ever felt the pain of being a real Cardinal fan. The reason people want Hall is because he gives us hope for a future. If he fails, we will get someone else to believe in. Anderson gives us no future, and that is why real cardinal fans want him as a back-up only. We have no chance of re-signing Fitz with Anderson as a starter.
The QB position is a coin flip. Wiz has expectations and if you fail to meet them you are out. Evidence by Hightower's fumble, if you can't hold on to the ball you will sit. If you can't perform at your position you will sit. For Wiz, Max Hall gives the coach what he expects, D.A. most certainly does not. He is a pro bowl QB and that is what Wiz expects to see. You can disagree with his philosophy but he stands by it and does not apologize for it. He is a man with strong conviction and that is hard to find.
I've been battling fans at azcentral ever since Max replaced DA. It's easy to see that many of them are only casual observers, but one would think you might be better. Apparently not.
There was nothing wrong with Max's reads. He threw to the right guys; he just couldn't hit them. That was an anomaly. Max is usually very accurate, and it will get better. DA gives us NO chance.
Btw, I agree with phoenixfan about your NY bias. Wish you had stayed there.
This has been my first foray into the KTAR comment board, and I see, now, why it is so barren. The editors won't even pass on a paragraph break, as if they would like to make all of us look like incompetent writers. (paragraph break)
What ever happened to a free press, KTAR? Is that only for you Lord Overmasters? Publish it the way I write it, or don't bother, Lord Censormaster.
Gambo, don't listen to the idiots on this site. You were right on the money as you usually are. AZ fans are so hypersensitive to any criticism of their boys, in this case Whiz. And they just love to bash radio talk show hosts. The golden boy Whiz totally blew this whole QB situation. Leinart had issues and yes his contract was going to blow up next year, but he was by far the best QB on the team and he should have been given those first 6 games to show us one way or the other. This season is in the tank and it looks like Whiz knows it and is already playing for next year.