ARIZONA DIAMONDBACKS

The trends of Wild Card teams pulling off the upset in the division series

Oct 6, 2017, 5:45 PM | Updated: 8:38 pm

(AP Photo/Frank Franklin II)...

(AP Photo/Frank Franklin II)

(AP Photo/Frank Franklin II)

If it seems to you like every October in the last half-decade has featured a Cinderella baseball team, you wouldn’t be wrong.

The Wild Card playoff round was integrated in 2012, and since then, there have been five winners of that round that were able to pull off the upset in a divisional series.

Those teams were the St. Louis Cardinals (2012) Kansas City Royals (2014), San Francisco Giants (2014), Chicago Cubs (2015) and the Toronto Blue Jays (2016).

Winners of the play-in game have a series record of 5-5 in the divisional series and have a promising record of 23-19 against those superior teams. Three of the five clubs that lost in the divisional series were able to take it to five games.

There have been more upsets in the National League, with Wild Card teams being 3-2 in winning the series and 12-10 overall.

There’s also been a theme for all the clubs that have been pulled off the upset: their ERA.

No team has been able to pull off the shocker in the five-game series unless they found themselves in the top 12 in ERA. Three of the five teams finished in the top eight.

The D-backs have the third-best ERA in baseball at 3.66. They also boast the sixth most strikeouts in the league for 1,482 on the season and allow the seventh lowest batting average at .240 against opposing teams.

An example of exceptional pitching carrying over to the playoffs for a Wild Card team is the Blue Jays, who had the best postseason ERA of 2.52 in the 2016 playoffs. The Giants and Royals, the 2014 Wild Card teams, finished with the second and third best postseason ERAs with 2.87 and 3.51 respectively. Those two clubs made the World Series.


Tune in to 98.7 FM Arizona’s Sports Station, your exclusive home for Arizona Diamondbacks playoff baseball.

Arizona Diamondbacks

Jordan Montgomery...

Alex Weiner

Diamondbacks’ lack of execution spoils Jordan Montgomery outing vs. Cardinals

Jordan Montgomery's quality start gave the Arizona Diamondbacks every opportunity to break Wednesday's series finale at the Cardinals open.

14 hours ago

Arizona Diamondbacks logo...

Haboob Blog

Diamondbacks minor leaguer accomplishes rare 5-strikeout inning

D-backs RHP prospect Jhosmer Alvarez struck out five hitters in a single inning for Single-A Visalia against the Inland Empire 66ers.

16 hours ago

Corbin Carroll swings and breaks his bat...

Arizona Sports

Corbin Carroll slides to 7th in Diamondbacks’ batting order vs. Cardinals

The Arizona Diamondbacks are shaking up the lineup against the St. Louis Cardinals with Corbin Carroll sliding down the batting order.

19 hours ago

D-backs assistant GM Mike Fitzgerald joins Wolf & Luke to discuss recent injuries to the team, incl...

Bailey Leasure

Assistant GM Mike Fitzgerald: It’s hard to read the Diamondbacks due to injuries

D-backs assistant general manager Mike Fitzgerald admitted judging Arizona has been difficult considering the rash of injuries.

20 hours ago

Pavin Smith drives in six runs as the D-backs beat the Cardinals 14-1....

Associated Press

Pavin Smith drives in 6 runs as Diamondbacks rout Cardinals

Pavin Smith hits a grand slam and drove in a career-high six runs to help the Diamondbacks to a 14-1 win over the Cardinals Tuesday.

1 day ago

D-backs put up 14 runs in six innings against the St. Louis Cardinals Tuesday....

Bailey Leasure

Diamondbacks drop Cardinals with home-run party

Pavin Smith hits a grand slam as the D-backs swung early Tuesday, putting up 14 runs as they beat the Cardinals 14-1.

1 day ago

The trends of Wild Card teams pulling off the upset in the division series