PHOENIX SUNS

If the Suns traded Hill and Nash…

Apr 8, 2011, 6:47 PM | Updated: 8:08 pm

Editor’s Note: Kristofer Habbas is a writer for NBADraftInsider.com and this is a special piece for ArizonaSports.com

Imagine for a second the Suns management personnel had a Suits Convention to decide what direction this team should go in. They debate whether or not to trade key players away, sign others and which way is up. During this meeting they bring up the question every Suns fan asked from January to the trade deadline of February 24th: Should we trade Steve Nash and Grant Hill out of respect?

During the whirlwind NBA trade deadline the Suns made a few transactions thought to make the team better for a playoff push, but neither proved to change the inevitable fact that the Suns were not that good this year.

Last year at the trade deadline the Suns had a chance to trade a star that was bound to walk in the summer. They knew he wanted and would likely receive a max contract; they also were very public in letting him know they would not offer him a max contract. Off Amare Stoudemire went to New York leaving a void in the locker room and on the court that could not be replaced, but boy did Suns’ owner Robert Sarver try.

He tried to sell the faithful fans of the Valley that Hakim Warrick, Hedo Turkoglu and overpaying to keep Channing Frye were the solutions to all the Amare woes. A few months later they admitted to being wrong by shipping Turkoglu and Leandro Barbosa off in separate trades in an effort to boost the team towards the playoffs. The Suns tried numerous ways to replace the initial mistake of letting a superstar walk for nothing; all failed and proved to other teams they need to get value for a guy who could walk.

That left veterans and fan favorites Steve Nash and Grant Hill on a gutted team with a lack of direction or future. Both under contract and the classiest guys you will ever meet, they’re not going to demand out. Fans want to pay to see them; the team needs them to be remotely competitive, but was it fair for Sarver to force them to go down with his sinking ship?

From a business standpoint trading Nash and/or Hill would have allowed the Suns to save money, bring in youth and build a future. Would fans be disappointed? Yes. But in this situation the fans were more torn on this than maybe any other situation in team history. They are beloved players, even to the extent that people wanted to see them go to a winning team for their last few years.

Looking at it from a win/loss standpoint, with Nash and Hill the Suns are competitive, but nowhere near a championship contender. Without them the team is rebuilding, but then again they were never a championship contender.

At the end of the day Sarver decided to keep them to sell tickets, hope for playoff revenue and keep his marquee names attracting fans. That is all.

If you ask Hill today what it would feel like to be on the Celtics or Thunder pushing towards a title, he would probably politely answer with how much he loves Phoenix and his teammates. Turn to Nash and see what he would look like in a Knicks, Lakers or Mavericks uniform and he will make you laugh with some funny anecdote from a Jared Dudley tweet. Both are too loyal to publically consider what could have been because they are still focused on what could be.

Phoenix Suns

Nikola Jokic #15 of the Denver Nuggets is guarded by Kevin Durant #35 of the Phoenix Suns during th...

Kellan Olson

Suns respond to season’s low point with thorough win over Nuggets

The guessing game of which Suns team shows up on which night persists. The best current version did on Wednesday in a win over the Nuggets.

8 hours ago

Bradley Beal #3 of the Phoenix Suns looks on during the second half against the Boston Celtics at T...

David Veenstra

Bradley Beal in, Jusuf Nurkic out for Suns’ matchup with Nuggets

Phoenix Suns guard Bradley Beal is active for Wednesday's matchup with the Denver Nuggets while center Jusuf Nurkic is out.

12 hours ago

Tyler Kolek, Marquette...

Damon Allred

Here’s who Phoenix Suns fans should watch in the NCAA Tournament Sweet 16

The Suns' first round pick in the 2024 NBA Draft sits at No. 19 overall, and they could select a star from the NCAA Tournament.

15 hours ago

Phoenix Suns take on San Antonio Spurs...

Arizona Sports

O’Neale: Phoenix Suns took Spurs ‘too lightly’ in glaring loss

The Phoenix Suns' lack of effort was on display Monday night against the San Antonio Spurs, leading to an honest film session.

1 day ago

...

Arizona Sports Video

Video: Royce O’Neale: Suns took Spurs “a little too lightly”

Phoenix Suns forward Royce O'Neale joined Burns & Gambo to talk about the team's disappointing loss to the San Antonio Spurs on Monday night, and to look ahead at the team's remaining schedule, as they continue to make a push toward the NBA playoffs.

1 day ago

...

Arizona Sports Video

Video: How the Suns lost to the Spurs before they stepped on the court

Burns & Gambo react to the Phoenix Suns stunning loss to the San Antonio Spurs on Monday night, and try to figure out why it happened.

2 days ago

If the Suns traded Hill and Nash…