DAN BICKLEY

Patrick Mahomes moves closer to GOAT status with each playoff win

Feb 5, 2024, 2:30 PM | Updated: 3:39 pm

The HOV lane has a different name in professional sports. It’s called the GOAT lane. It offers speedy and exclusive access for the select few seeking athletic immortality.

That’s where you’ll find Patrick Mahomes, a quarterback speeding into Super Bowl LVIII.

If Mahomes prevails Sunday against the 49ers at Allegiant Stadium in Las Vegas, he will have three Super Bowl rings in his first six years as NFL starter. He will have six consecutive AFC Championship game appearances. He will be hailed as the only truly great quarterback in the current NFL, affirmed by the home-field playoff failures of Baltimore’s Lamar Jackson and Buffalo’s Josh Allen.

He will be on pace to surpass Tom Brady as the greatest of all-time.

There are no givens or guarantees in life. Tiger Woods was blistering hot in the first quarter of his career, once considered a shoo-in to pass Jack Nicklaus for GOAT status. It never happened, and it never will.

Yet Mahomes is already more dynamic, more athletic, and physically tougher than Brady. He has the moxie and the running ability to become a dual-threat quarterback in the postseason. He has learned the maturity to manage games and the patience to take and make the easy completions. Chiefs head coach Andy Reid deserves great credit for buffing out the rough spots, for the shiny coat of polish Mahomes is now wearing.

The Chiefs’ quarterback is also making a powerful declaration: that nobody can beat him come playoff time, no matter where the game is staged, no matter how ragged or disorienting the Chiefs might appear during the regular season.

For years, critics pinned Brady’s greatness with an asterisk. Yes, he was clearly the best quarterback of all-time. There was nobody smarter, nobody better in the clutch, nobody with a bigger chip on his shoulder, nobody with more jewelry. But Brady never once felt like the greatest football player. Not in the bone-crunching sense of the word. Not like Walter Payton or Lawrence Taylor.

But Mahomes could finally unify the title, becoming both the NFL’s GOAT and the greatest quarterback in history.

When Brady won his last ring in New England, he held a 6-1 lead over Mahomes with no other contender in sight. It was 7-2 after Brady’s final championship in Tampa. Yet if the Chiefs win on Sunday, Brady’s lead will narrow to four, and more poignantly, it will mark two consecutive rings for Mahomes in the two years since Brady has retired.

For Brady, it will be even more frightening to reconcile how ruthlessly Mahomes found and flicked the switch, shrugging off humiliating losses to the Broncos and Raiders; a lack of weapons on offense, particularly at wide receiver; and home-field advantage in the playoffs.

Granted, legacy discussions can be frivolous, tiresome, and premature. In tennis, Roger Federer was practically taking GOAT victory laps on tour near the end of his career, only to be passed in real time by two other rivals – Rafael Nadal and Novak Djokovic. Oops.

But this feels different. If Mahomes beats the 49ers, he will become the first quarterback since Brady to repeat as Super Bowl champion. We will be watching history repeat itself.

Only better.

Reach Bickley at dbickley@arizonasports.com. Listen to Bickley & Marotta weekdays from 6–10 a.m. on Arizona Sports.

Dan Bickley

The first three rounds of the 2025 WM Phoenix Open have delivered on the Thunderbirds promise of be...

Dan Bickley

2025 WM Phoenix Open delivering on promise of better not bigger

The first three rounds of the 2025 WM Phoenix Open have delivered on the Thunderbirds promise of better not bigger.

13 hours ago

Dallas Mavericks guard Luka Doncic drives against Los Angeles Lakers forward Anthony Davis (3) duri...

Dan Bickley

Luka Doncic trade proves again the Lakers are the luckiest franchise in sports history

The blockbuster Luka Doncic-Anthony Davis trade is not about the Lakers getting Luka. It’s about the Lakers getting lucky.

7 days ago

Phoenix Suns owner Mat Ishbia introduces the new Ring of Honor during the NBA game against the Utah...

Dan Bickley

Suns fans can both love a Jimmy Butler trade and hate everything it represents

I want Jimmy Butler with the Phoenix Suns. But I hate everything this trade saga represents.

11 days ago

Head coach Mike Budenholzer of the Phoenix Suns watches the action during the first half against th...

Dan Bickley

Trade rumors provide both hope and harm for these Suns

The Suns are a .500 team. Mediocrity isn’t supposed to be this difficult. Or expensive. Changes are coming despite a three-game win streak.

27 days ago

Kyler Murray Cardinals Rams embracing Trey McBride after first touchdown...

Dan Bickley

Kyler Murray has one last dance with Cardinals after season of close calls

There are no better options for the Cardinals than Kyler Murray in 2025. The quarterback has one last dance in the Valley. For better or worse.

1 month ago

Kyler Murray #1 of the Arizona Cardinals runs the ball against D.J. Wonnum #98 of the Carolina Pant...

Dan Bickley

Shame on the Cardinals for being eliminated from the playoffs in the worst of ways

The Cardinals fumbled around and found out and were eliminated from playoff contention after an embarrassing loss in Carolina on Sunday.

2 months ago

Patrick Mahomes moves closer to GOAT status with each playoff win