Diamondbacks: Prove it, proven or problem

Apr 11, 2017, 1:43 PM | Updated: 2:02 pm

Arizona Diamondbacks' Yasmany Tomas, right, is greeted by teammate David Peralta, left, after hitti...

Arizona Diamondbacks' Yasmany Tomas, right, is greeted by teammate David Peralta, left, after hitting a home run off San Francisco Giants starting pitcher Matt Moore in the fifth inning of a baseball game, Monday, April 10, 2017, in San Francisco. (AP Photo/Eric Risberg)

(AP Photo/Eric Risberg)

At 6-2 and leading Major League Baseball in wins, the Diamondbacks are one of the best teams in baseball. After one week, four different 75-win or less teams from 2016 are in first place in 2017. It’s hard to separate what’s real from what is hope with this year’s Diamondbacks.

I got six things that are very important to the D-backs’ success. I can see two things in the first eight games that I believe are not a fluke; two items that I don’t trust; and, two things that are already an issue. Here’s what’s proven, left to prove and a problem:

The offense

Arizona leads MLB in runs. Arizona is first in hits. No team in baseball has more doubles. Only Philly has more triples than Arizona. Although the D-backs are middle of the pack in HRs, Arizona is only two long balls behind Texas, Houston and Cincinnati, who lead baseball with 11. In the slash stats (AVG/OBP/SLG), Arizona is 1st/4th/3rd and second in MLB with an .827 OPS. The Diamondbacks are even in first place for hits by a pinch hitter, stolen bases and extra-base hits.

Verdict: Proven

The offense won’t stay this hot all year but this is the strength of the team.  It’s only been one week but this offense can carry the team through the heart of the season.  This offense is for real.

Yasmany Tomas

He went hitless in the spring and in his first two games of the regular season. He’s batting .500 since. Tomas even ran down a ball in shallow left field in the first game of the current series with the Giants. After his bad start, Tomas finally started listening to every hitting coach he’s ever had. Now he’s raking.

Verdict: Prove it

I’m not buying anything Tomas sells for at least two months. He’s been hot before. As his confidence goes up, he thinks he can swing for the fences any time he wants. There have been too many examples of him not having any plan or clue as he approaches the plate. He even started this season as a free-swinger. If he’s still doing well approaching July, I’ll buy.

Infield defense

Brandon Drury made a play last week where he tried to pump fake a runner to death. Didn’t work. He turned a ground ball into an RBI single that never left the infield with no runner on third. In Monday’s home opener for San Francisco, Drury caught a deep pop-up in shallow right-center field with a runner prepared to tag at third. Although it’s up to the outfielders to call him off that, it should have been a run for San Francisco. Only braindead base running saved Arizona. Then, of course, there’s Monday’s meltdown with the bases loaded on the little league, 3-run infield “double.”

Verdict: Problem

This is only the beginning. It can easily get worse. The offense’s job all year will be to score more runs than the infield defense gives up. The problem is the starting pitching is too fragile to pitch around big innings that are being extended by should-be outs gift-wrapped into base runners.

Archie Bradley

He’s picked up almost 5 mph on his fastball. He hasn’t learned to throw it harder. He’s holding nothing back since he’s not a starter. Instead of trying to pitch to 20 hitters through 6-plus innings, Bradley is focused on only one thing: getting the next batter out. This simple change in focus has benefited him, greatly. He looks dominant. He’s thinking less about the scouting report and more about just manning up while mowing them down.

Verdict: Proven

Archie has struggled with his confidence for years now. Another trip to the minors to build confidence would have done nothing. He doesn’t need to learn how to get minor league hitters out. He’s been doing that for years. Bradley is pitching with an attitude that says, “I don’t care what you think.” He cares about his craft but no one else’s opinion. Archie Bradley will benefit greatly from the bullpen. As his confidence and production climb, his time in the bullpen won’t. He’ll be back in the rotation.

Patrick Corbin

Against the Giants was 2016: Almost 90 pitches thrown but only four innings of work. 2013 seemed to appear against Cleveland with a 4-hit, 6-inning shutout. Getting in front allows for the slider to devastate. Corbin showed some signs that he can (potentially) return to form.

Verdict: Prove it

It’s still about recovering from injury, but last year had to be a wake up call. Patrick Corbin has always been the darling prospect, then he got hurt. Obviously, there was great patience and care taken with his rehab. Everyone thought it was important that he returned in 2015, which he did. Corbin had plenty of time to show he was back in 2016, and he didn’t. He’s a great person who completely deserved his demotion to the bullpen. Corbin took it like a man. Now it’s time for him to continue his growth from prospect to top-of-the-rotation on a weak team or a solid starter on a playoff team.

Pitch count

All of the fun of saying “D-backs in first place” will be over by mid-May if the pitch counts don’t come down.  Arizona averages 97 pitches per starting pitcher, yet only gets 5.1 innings pitched. The efficiency of the staff is a disaster. Starting pitchers should be well into the seventh before hitting 100 pitches, but only one starting pitcher (Zack Greinke), in one outing (vs. Cleveland) has ever earned an out in the 7th inning.

Verdict: Problem

It’s impossible for a bullpen trying to fall into place to keep the D-backs in games while waiting for the offense to mount their comeback if the starting pitching is continually calling it a day after 16 or 17 outs. The pitch counts are way too high. Every game has too many high-pitch at-bats and too many jams to pitch out of in the early stages.

If the Diamondbacks want to repeat week one of the season 15 more times out of the next 25 weeks, the improvement of the infield defense must go up and the pitch counts of the starting pitchers must come down.


Comment guidelines: No name-calling, personal attacks, profanity, or insults. Please keep the conversation civil and help us moderate comments by reporting abuse.
comments powered by Disqus

Arizona Diamondbacks

Los Angeles Dodgers' Bobby Miller pitches during the first inning of a baseball against the Philade...

Associated Press

Dodgers beat Phillies, keep pace with Diamondbacks in NL West race

Rookie Bobby Miller won for the third time in four starts and the Los Angeles Dodgers beat Philadelphia 9-0 on Saturday.

17 hours ago

Ryne Nelson #19 of the Arizona Diamondbacks throws a pitch in the bottom of the first inning agains...

Arizona Sports

Ryne Nelson, Lourdes Gurriel Jr. lead Diamondbacks to shutout win over Tigers

Ryne Nelson pitched 5 2/3 scoreless innings and Lourdes Gurriel Jr. hit a 418-foot, three-run home run to lead the Diamondbacks to a 5-0 victory over the host Detroit Tigers on Saturday.

17 hours ago

Corbin Carroll #7 of the Arizona Diamondbacks celebrates his seventh inning grand slam home run wit...

Kellan Olson

Corbin Carroll’s 1st multi-HR game leads D-backs to beat Tigers

Diamondbacks outfielder Corbin Carroll has quickly gone from as advertised in his first full rookie year to a near lock for the All-Star game.

2 days ago

Arizona Diamondbacks Corbin Carroll...

Wills Rice

ESPN staff sees D-backs’ Corbin Carroll running away with NL ROTY title

The D-backs locked up outfielder Corbin Carroll to an eight-year, $111 million contract after just 32 games in MLB, and it's evident why.

2 days ago

General Manager Mike Hazen of the Arizona Diamondbacks watches batting practice during a postseason...

Wills Rice

Hazen: D-backs itching to be aggressive at trade deadline, attack pitching

The D-backs are in a position to attack the trade deadline, something they haven't seen since J.D. Martinez came to the Valley in 2017.

2 days ago

Los Angeles Dodgers starting pitcher Clayton Kershaw throws to the plate during the first inning of...

Associated Press

Dodgers avoid sweep with win over Reds; D-backs remain atop NL West

Clayton Kershaw pitched seven scoreless innings and the Los Angeles Dodgers defeated the Cincinnati Reds 6-0 on Thursday afternoon.

3 days ago

Diamondbacks: Prove it, proven or problem