The Consensus: Arizona Cardinals dip despite road win in Indianapolis

Sep 20, 2017, 8:03 AM | Updated: 11:34 am
Arizona Cardinals' J.J. Nelson (14) makes a catch against Indianapolis Colts' Quincy Wilson during ...
Arizona Cardinals' J.J. Nelson (14) makes a catch against Indianapolis Colts' Quincy Wilson during the first half of an NFL football game Sunday, Sept. 17, 2017, in Indianapolis. (AP Photo/Michael Conroy)
(AP Photo/Michael Conroy)

A team never has to apologize for winning a road game in the NFL. Winning away from home is tough, and whether it’s by a point or four touchdowns, teams will take what they can get.

However, that doesn’t mean experts will be impressed by said win.

That’s what the Arizona Cardinals are facing after their largely uninspiring 16-13 overtime win over the Indianapolis Colts last Sunday at Lucas Oil Stadium. When it comes to NFL Power Rankings, it’s about style points and how dominant a team might have been, and the voters from the battery of 10 rankings we use just weren’t all that impressed.

Each week in The Consensus, we’ll give you a look at where national outlets (and we here at are placing the Cardinals in their league pecking order.

arizonasports_lg_300Arizona Sports’ NFL Power Rankings Week 3: Third new team claims No. 1 spot

Cardinals rank: #18 (No Movement)

May have saved their season by converting that 3rd-and-20 play on Sunday. — Luke Lapinski

espnWeek 3 NFL Power Rankings: Let’s be optimistic

Cardinals rank: #21 (▼1)

Carson Palmer had three completions on passes thrown 20 or more yards in the fourth quarter of Sunday’s win after starting the season 2-of-8 on such passes. If that fourth quarter is a sign of things to come for Palmer and not an aberration, the Cardinals’ offense will be just fine.

nflnetworkNFL Power Rankings, Week 3: Kansas City Chiefs hit No. 1 spot

Cardinals rank: #19 (No Movement)

If Sunday’s win — yes, it was a win — is any indication, the Cardinals might be in trouble. With no David Johnson and no John Brown, Arizona’s engine was stuck in neutral at Indianapolis. Facing one of the worst defenses in the league, a unit that Jared Goff solved repeatedly, Carson Palmer was hit-and-miss. The completion percentage (barely over 50) and final tally (16 points) were off the mark. That said, the deep ball to J.J. Nelson midway through the fourth was unbelievable. What should consistently keep the Cardinals in games is the pass rush, which came alive late. Chandler Jones planted Jacoby Brissett in the turf. Tyrann Mathieu picked Brissett’s pocket. Those two might have to pull off these kinds of feats every week.

The MMQB NFL Power Rankings Poll, Week 3: Chiefs the New No. 1

Cardinals rank: #22 (▼2)

No comment.

cbssportsNFL Power Rankings: What Super Bowl hangover? Falcons firing on all cylinders

Cardinals rank: #17 (▲2)

They haven’t looked good the first two weeks, but now come home for a big one against Dallas. They had five offensive starters out last week against the Colts.

bleacherreportNFL Power Rankings: Where Does Every Team Stand Heading into Week 3?

Cardinals rank: #23 (No Movement)

The Arizona Cardinals won ugly against the Indianapolis Colts in Week 2. Unfortunately, this may be how they are forced to win games all year long.

The Arizona offensive line isn’t good enough to dominate, and without David Johnson, the run game isn’t capable enough to do anything special. The Cardinals are going to have to run just enough to keep defenses honest and hope Carson Palmer can take care of the football and make a few timely explosive plays.

The Cardinals defense is strong enough to keep the team in games. If Arizona can limit mistakes on offense, it can play through its defense. Eventually, Bruce Arians and his offensive scheme will break through and produce a big play. The defense is also capable of making big plays.

This is what we saw against the Colts. The offense did just enough to force overtime, where a turnover set up the game-winning score.

This isn’t a team I’m willing to give up on. The NFC West is looking like a weaker division this year, and the Cardinals have enough overall talent to make some noise there.

yahoosportsNFL Power Rankings: Superstar Kareem Hunt changes Chiefs’ outlook

Cardinals rank: #22 (▼1)

Chris Johnson looked OK, gaining 44 yards on 11 carries. Kerwynn Williams wasn’t so good, with 22 yards on nine carries. The Cardinals have to patch together a run game without David Johnson, and Johnson is going to be out a couple months. The Cardinals probably can’t get very far riding Carson Palmer and Chris Johnson for half of a season or more, but what choice do they have?

usatodayUSA Today Power Rankings – Week 3

Cardinals rank: #25 (▼2)

Quite a bit’s already gone wrong for this team, but it was good to see the Honey Badger re-emerge with that clutch INT in overtime.

profootballtalkWeek Two power rankings

Cardinals rank: #23 (▼2)

Bruce Arians has finally figured out what many already knew about this team — the quarterback is often more of a liability than an asset.

NFL Power Rankings: Broncos raise AFC West to power of three for Week 3

Cardinals rank: #20 (▲5)

Carson Palmer has seen his offensive line, backfield and receiving corps ravaged by injuries, and the crumbing is in full effect. It’s on the defense to keep making big plays to save the day.

Arizona Cardinals

Arizona Cardinals defensive tackle Corey Peters (98) walks out before an NFL game between the Arizo...
Nikash Nath

PFF’s Doug Kyed advises Arizona Cardinals to bring back DL Corey Peters

With the Cardinals' current roster construction, PFF's Doug Kyed believes Arizona should bring DL Corey Peters back once more in 2022.
2 days ago
Ohio State Buckeyes offensive lineman Paris Johnson Jr. (77) protects his quarterback during the fi...
Sam Graveline

Cardinals take OT Paris Johnson Jr. in ESPN 2023 NFL mock draft

ESPN's Matt Miller thinks the Cardinals will beef up the offensive line in his first 2023 mock by selecting Ohio State OT Paris Johnson Jr.
2 days ago
Arizona Cardinals coach Kliff Kingsbury, right, and Byron Murphy Jr. (7) celebrate after an NFL foo...
Wills Rice’s Patra ranks Cardinals’ cornerbacks among weakest rooms in league

The Cardinals enter training camp with a few question marks personnel-wise on the defensive side of the ball, especially at cornerback.
3 days ago
Nick Scott #33 of the Los Angeles Rams tackles Zach Ertz #86 of the Arizona Cardinals after a recep...
Sam Graveline

PFF: Tight end shaping up to be biggest position battle for Arizona Cardinals

The Arizona Cardinals head into training camp expecting to have healthy competition at a handful of positions, including at tight end.
4 days ago
Kyler Murray #1 of the Arizona Cardinals celebrates with fans after beating the Houston Texans 31-5...
Arizona Sports

Cardinals Corner: The timeframe of Kyler Murray’s contract extension

We haven't heard much lately when it comes down to Cardinals QB Kyler Murray and a contract extension. When will a new deal get done?
4 days ago
Markus Golden #44 of the Arizona Cardinals reacts to a defensive play during the first half against...
Nikash Nath

Cardinals LB Markus Golden among players with best team-friendly deals

Arizona Cardinals LB Markus Golden's contract cracked PFF analyst Brad Spielberger's top team-friendly deals ranking.
4 days ago
The Consensus: Arizona Cardinals dip despite road win in Indianapolis