Baseball play-by-play announcers: The good and the not-so-good

Sep 18, 2013, 3:00 PM | Updated: 3:00 pm

Vin Scully is 85 years of age.

Earlier this season, he delighted baseball fans when he announced that he’d be returning to the Dodgers’ broadcast booth in 2014 for an unprecedented 65th season.

He hasn’t lost a step.

Last Friday (which happened to be the 13th of the month) the Dodgers were hosting the Giants in Los Angeles, and in the bottom of the second inning, Scully not only did his normal job of beautifully describing the action, but educating as well. The wordsmith informed the viewers on the history of the superstitious day without taking credit for any of the knowledge he shared.

“I’m not trying to get smart, just looked it up, figuring a lot of you folks might find it a little interesting,” Scully said. “Like you, I’d be lost without Google. I’m not trying to show off.”

It was simply Scully being Scully — the best play-by-play announcer that has ever uttered a syllable into a microphone.

Then Tuesday night in Toronto, we witnessed the other side of the coin.

Yankees’ third baseman Alex Rodriguez stepped to the plate against Toronto’s R.A. Dickey and hit a line drive to right field. New York play-by-play man John Sterling automatically went into his signature home run call, “it is high, it is far…it is gone!”

Except there was a problem, it wasn’t high. It wasn’t far. In fact, it was caught by Blue Jays’ right fielder Rajai Davis. This chain of events caused Sterling to shift into apology mode.

Painful to listen to, and obviously embarrassing for the veteran announcer, but it was funny.


David Peralta #6 and Eduardo Escobar #5 of the Arizona Diamondbacks celebrate after scoring on a si...
Haboob Blog

Former D-backs OF David Peralta rekindles Eduardo Escobar’s cat fear with Team Venezuela

David Peralta had some fun with Eduardo Escobar's fear of cats when they were teammates with the Diamondbacks.
3 days ago
Oumar Ballo #11 of the Arizona Wildcats is fouled by Maxime Raynaud #42 of the Stanford Cardinal in...
Haboob Blog

Arizona’s Oumar Ballo after win: Stanford can ‘go home … study science’

Arizona center Oumar Ballo heard Stanford's Harrison Ingram proclaim Stanford as the biggest, baddest team a day prior.
13 days ago
Deandre Ayton #22 of the Phoenix Suns shoots in the second half against Patrick Beverley #21 of the...
Haboob Blog

Patrick Beverley says he pestered Deandre Ayton in postgame food line

Seemingly every time Patrick Beverley matches up with the Phoenix Suns extracurricular actives ensue.
15 days ago
Arizona Diamondbacks OF Corbin Carroll (AP Photo/Matt York)...
Haboob Blog

Alek Thomas is not a fan of Corbin Carroll’s face when he runs

But while the Corbin Carroll is considered No. 1 in the organization for quickness, No. 2 is all teammate Alek Thomas sees when he runs.
22 days ago
Arizona Diamondbacks manager Torey Lovullo, right, greets son, Chicago Cubs minor league coach Nick...
Jake Anderson

Pitch clock rules force D-backs’ Joe Mantiply to start count 1-1 without throwing a pitch

Due to MLB's new pitch clock rules, D-backs lefty Joe Mantiply started a count at 1-1 despite not throwing a pitch vs. the Cubs on Monday.
22 days ago
Kevin Durant #7 of the Brooklyn Nets heads for the net as Mikal Bridges #25 of the Phoenix Suns def...
Austin Scott

Mikal Bridges favorite player growing up? Kevin Durant

The Brooklyn Nets learned about Mikal Bridges in a get-to-know-you video. Favorite athlete growing up? It was Kevin Durant, of all people.
27 days ago
Baseball play-by-play announcers: The good and the not-so-good