If D-backs rebuild immediately, it means trading Paul Goldschmidt

Sep 28, 2018, 7:13 PM | Updated: 8:35 pm

Arizona Diamondbacks' Paul Goldschmidt looks for a sign during the first inning of a baseball game ...

Arizona Diamondbacks' Paul Goldschmidt looks for a sign during the first inning of a baseball game against the Atlanta Braves, Sunday, Sept 9, 2018, in Phoenix. (AP Photo/Darryl Webb)

(AP Photo/Darryl Webb)

The Diamondbacks are rated PG. For Paul Goldschmidt.

For how long?

Following a sleepy farewell series in San Diego, the Diamondbacks must choose a path, confronting this awful question. To blow it up or bring it back revolves around Goldschmidt’s future in Arizona, a player who still holds iconic status in the Valley.

The head says it’s time to trade him. The heart says he needs to retire in Arizona, one of ours until the bitter end. Because we’ve learned that’s the stuff that really matters.

As of now, it sounds like the organization is straddling the same fence, open to all suggestions.

Goldschmidt has one year left on his bargain-basement contract. He’s 31 years old with one RBI in his past 17 games. He’s swooning for the second consecutive stretch run, once again bowing out of the MVP discussion. He is no longer untouchable.

He’s also one of the best ambassadors the franchise has ever employed, homegrown and humble. My 15-year old son was once indelibly moved by his grace and good nature, and would cease speaking to me if he knew how I pondered his departure.

That’s because Goldschmidt makes Arizonans feel good about the Diamondbacks, and is an asset the team will sorely need going forward. Whatever path they choose.

There is conflicting evidence clouding the process. The Diamondbacks were atop the National League West for 125 days, dwarfing their 18-day stay in 2017. They were in first place on April 1, May 1, July 1, Aug. 1 and Sept. 1. They never spent a day under .500, suggesting our baseball team is close to being special, especially if their bullpen can be repaired in the coming months.

They also had a losing record at home (40-41). They were 19-29 in one-run games entering the final series. The installation of a humidor at Chase Field was a really bad idea, leading to a power outage and psychological barrier for all Diamondbacks hitters.

The team hit 42 fewer home runs in 2018 than they did the previous season, unplugging a tangible home-field advantage at Chase Field, where they posted a 52-29 record in 2017. Their slugging percentage also plummeted from .492 to .398. And here’s the smoking gun:

The Diamondbacks were 21-8 on May 1. They’ve been a bad baseball team ever since. You don’t put off a much-needed rebuilding effort for one-month wonders.

It’s been a long, strange season. Chase Field staged the longest game in team history (5 hours, 46 minutes). It endured a power outage caused by a haboob, although a rogue baboon seemed like a better fit for the tone of the season. The Diamondbacks also lost one of their most passionate customers (Sen. John McCain), a man who once blamed an erratic political performance on a late-night watching his favorite baseball team.

The Diamondbacks drew 2.24 million fans, the most since 2008. But down the stretch, their stadium was stormed and conquered by Cubs fans and Dodgers fans mocking our bandwagon nature. Goldschmidt heard MVP chants inside his own stadium for a guy in the other dugout.

Some believe this team was extinguished by Matt Kemp and that awful series in Los Angeles, by a pair of roundhouse punches finally flattening a battle-weary boxer. It got so bad that manager Torey Lovullo later benched five starters, penciling-in a Triple-A team in the heat of a pennant race. The gimmick prompted serious questions:

Why did Arizona’s core players need so much rest in 2018? Wrong mix of personalities? Not enough alpha males or internal fire? And why were they so fragile in the end, out of fight and out of gas well before the finish line?

The 2018 Diamondbacks could only produce a pair of consolation prizes: a non-losing season and a series victory that kicked the Dodgers out of first place. They were a spoonful of sugar, akin to eating a cupcake. But it won’t last and it’s not enough. And the time is coming for general manager Mike Hazen to build a perennial contender from scratch, executing the job he was hired to perform, a job that has never been done properly in Arizona. So:

How soon is now? If immediately, it all starts with trading Goldschmidt, and I cringe at the sight of him finishing up in another uniform, like Brandon Webb playing for the Rangers, like Randy Johnson winning his 300th game with the Giants. I’m not ready for another lengthy rebuilding effort for another major professional sports team in downtown Phoenix, either.

But I also know this:

I don’t want to see another baseball season like this. Not at Chase Field. Not ever.

Reach Bickley at dbickley@bonneville.com. Listen to Bickley & Marotta weekdays from 10 a.m. – 2 p.m. on 98.7 FM Arizona’s Sports Station.


Comment guidelines: No name-calling, personal attacks, profanity, or insults. Please keep the conversation civil and help us moderate comments by reporting abuse.
comments powered by Disqus

Dan Bickley


Arizona Sports Video

Video: Bickley Blast: Do Phoenix Suns fans have the patience to see Mat Ishbia’s 3-year plan through?

Phoenix Suns owner Mat Ishbia joined Burns & Gambo to explain his three-year plan for the organization on Wednesday. Dan Bickley ponders if fans have enough patience to see the entire plan all the way through.

6 days ago

Ketel Marte #4 of the Arizona Diamondbacks fields a ball during Gatorade All-Star Workout Day at Gl...

Dan Bickley

Several themes swirl around Diamondbacks at All-Star break

The Arizona Diamondbacks have several questions facing them at the All-Star break with a turning point looming.

8 days ago


Arizona Sports Video

Video: Bickley Blast: How Diamondbacks’ Torey Lovullo, Ketel Marte can seize MLB All-Star Game opportunity

Arizona skipper Torey Lovullo will lead the National League team for the 2024 MLB All-Star Game while Ketel Marte starts at second base. Dan Bickley explains how the two D-backs' representatives can make the most of their time on the national stage.

8 days ago


Arizona Sports Video

Video: Bickley Blast: Diamondbacks ‘better make the playoffs or else’

The Arizona Diamondbacks are in Wild Card contention despite everything that could've derailed the team in the first half of the season. Dan Bickley is expecting big things for the team after the All-Star break, including another playoff berth.

9 days ago


Arizona Sports Video

Video: Bickley Blast: Is there something magical ahead for Diamondbacks?

Despite everything that's gone on in the first half of the season for the Arizona Diamondbacks, they're still in striking distance of a Wild Card spot in the National League. Dan Bickley wonders if this team can catch lightning in a bottle after the All-Star break, and make another run to the playoffs.

9 days ago


Arizona Sports Video

Video: Bickley Blast: Who’s to blame for Diamondbacks collapsing against Dodgers?

Dan Bickley wonders who should shoulder the most blame for the Diamondbacks loss to the Los Angeles Dodgers on Tuesday night.

21 days ago

If D-backs rebuild immediately, it means trading Paul Goldschmidt