A winning season: Did the 2019 D-backs overachieve or not?

Sep 26, 2019, 2:04 PM | Updated: Sep 27, 2019, 8:33 am
Archie Bradley #25, Wilmer Flores #41, Domingo Leyba #2, Eduardo Escobar #5 and Ildemaro Vargas #15...
Archie Bradley #25, Wilmer Flores #41, Domingo Leyba #2, Eduardo Escobar #5 and Ildemaro Vargas #15 of the Arizona Diamondbacks celebrate after defeating the Miami Marlins at Chase Field on September 18, 2019 in Phoenix, Arizona. (Photo by Jennifer Stewart/Getty Images)
(Photo by Jennifer Stewart/Getty Images)

There’s a dilemma with evaluating the 2019 Arizona Diamondbacks.

On one hand, they missed the playoffs. They won 11 out of 12 games in September and then lost six in a row to crush their hopes of going to the postseason. They lost some of their games against bad teams, an issue that might’ve made the difference in their chance at a Wild Card berth.

On the other hand, they clinched a winning record. They could get as many as 85 wins if they were to sweep the Padres in the final series of the season. They almost made the postseason despite losing Paul Goldschmidt, A.J. Pollock and Patrick Corbin in the offseason, trading Zack Greinke at the deadline and losing David Peralta and Ketel Marte down the stretch.

So which is it? Were they better or worse than they should’ve been?

D-backs president and CEO Derrick Hall was asked the question by Doug & Wolf on 98.7 FM Arizona’s Sports Station on Thursday: Did Arizona blow an opportunity?

“I think perhaps, yeah,” Hall said. “The plot has been the same all year long where we really step up and play well against teams that are considered stronger, and teams that we probably should’ve had an easier time against, we struggle. And that’s part of the maturity process, but it’s also something we have to solve for, because I do think we were good enough to make the postseason.

“I think it was right in front of us. We had a period of time a couple weeks back where we were just five outs away from being half a game back of that second wild card spot, and we let it slip away. But I think that’s also reason for big-time excitement for next year. I’m not happy. We made the playoffs in ’17, that was great, but we haven’t made it in ’18, we haven’t made it in ’19 and I just don’t think that’s acceptable, because our goal every year is to get back to the postseason and ultimately to the big game.”

The D-backs were 82-77 entering an off-day on Thursday with three games left to go in the season. The previous day, on Wednesday, the D-backs won their second game of a three-game series at home against the St. Louis Cardinals, capped by Archie Bradley closing out the ballgame to get the save.

It all came after the D-backs and Cardinals went 19 innings the night before, and then Arizona rallied for a seven-run inning to come back and win on Wednesday.

“I think it just kind of shows what this team is about,” Bradley said. “We can all look back and wish we would’ve played better throughout the year to make the playoffs, but I don’t feel negative or down about not making the postseason. I’m upset, but I feel like this team, we fought hard all year. And we weren’t good enough in some big games. It’s not going to stop now, just because we didn’t make it.

“Guys want to win. I think you saw last night, the way we celebrated in the 19th. Same thing — we want to come in and win a series. We want to win the next three and push our record to — what would we finish? 85 wins? — I think that would be a pretty damn good year for what people said and expected and something to build off of.”

Penguin Air

Penguin Air

Arizona Diamondbacks

Arizona Diamondbacks' Sergio Alcantara (43) and Geraldo Perdomo, middle, celebrate after scoring ag...
Kellan Olson

Diamondbacks rally to beat Pirates, make up for odd defensive blunder

The Arizona Diamondbacks' seven runs in the seventh inning picked up starter Merrill Kelly after he was positioned for an undeserved loss.
1 day ago
Chicago White Sox pitcher Lance Lynn warms up in the outfield before a baseball game against the Ne...
Associated Press

‘Field of Dreams’ game Thursday sees Cubs, Reds clash

“Field of Dreams” gets another tribute when the Cincinnati Reds take on the Chicago Cubs in a throwback ballpark in the cornfields of Iowa.
2 days ago
Arizona Diamondbacks right fielder Daulton Varsho leaps in vain for a triple hit by Pittsburgh Pira...
Kellan Olson

Bizarre double play, replay review costs Diamondbacks in loss to Pirates

The D-backs loaded the bases with nobody out down 6-3 in the ninth inning against the Pirates before one of the strangest plays of the year.
1 day ago
Arizona Cardinals wide receiver Larry Fitzgerald (11) is tackled by Philadelphia Eagles safety Marc...
Arizona Sports

Larry Fitzgerald, Pedro Gomez in 2022 Arizona Sports Hall of Fame class

Arizona Cardinals legend Larry Fitzgerald and late journalist Pedro Gomez are among the 2022 class entering the Arizona Sports Hall of Fame.
2 days ago
Tommy Henry #47 of the Arizona Diamondbacks delivers a first inning pitch against the Pittsburgh Pi...
Kellan Olson

D-backs starting pitching stays hot, Henry’s first W takes down Pirates

Diamondbacks rookie Tommy Henry continued the strong run of form from the team's starting pitching lately in a win over the Pirates.
3 days ago
Pittsburgh Pirates' Rodolfo Castro, left, watches along with Los Angeles Dodgers catcher Austin Bar...
Haboob Blog

Pirates’ Rodolfo Castro loses phone while sliding into 3rd base at Chase Field

Now here's something you don't see very often on the diamond: a cell phone popping out of a players back pocket mid-game.
3 days ago
A winning season: Did the 2019 D-backs overachieve or not?