Olney: Bumgarner is a Diamondbacks-sized Cole, Strasburg deal

Dec 17, 2019, 9:02 AM | Updated: 9:02 am
From left to right: Gerrit Cole (AP Photo/Patrick Semansky), Madison Bumgarner (AP Photo/Ben Margot...
From left to right: Gerrit Cole (AP Photo/Patrick Semansky), Madison Bumgarner (AP Photo/Ben Margot), and Stephen Strasburg (AP Photo/Mike Ehrmann, Pool).
(AP Photo/Mike Ehrmann, Pool)

While the Arizona Diamondbacks received mostly positive reviews for the acquisition of LHP Madison Bumgarner, the metrics might indicate the four-time All-Star is on the decline.

But that might not matter.

“If there’s anybody in baseball that metrics don’t apply to him, it’s Madison Bumgarner,” ESPN MLB insider Buster Olney told 98.7 FM Arizona Sports Station’s Burns & Gambo on Monday. “He’s such a competitor, that unbelievable post-season history tells you that there’s a lot more to baseball’s Paul Bunyan than simply numbers.”

Olney compared Arizona’s signing to the New York Yankees inking Gerrit Cole or the Washington Nationals signing Stephen Strasburg.

Strasburg set the pace on the free agent market by agreeing to a $245 million, seven-year contract with the Washington Nationals. The next day, Cole picked up a nine-year deal worth $324 million.

The D-backs plan to sign their next ace to a five-year, $85 million deal, nearly a third of what other top free agents are getting.

In a way, it’s a more responsible version of signing former pitcher Zack Greinke. In December 2015, Greinke joined Arizona on a six-year, $206.5 million deal. Greinke’s deal worked out to $34 million a year while Bumgarner’s will consume nearly half of that at $17 million a year.

“It’s proportional risk,” Olney said.

With that risk, there were underlying metrics that made other teams around the league hesitant to sign the 30-year-old pitcher.

“That was not like an isolated opinion,” Olney said. “The reason why Madison Bumgarner, a year younger than Stephen Strasburg, got a third of what Strasburg did was because of what the people see in the underlying numbers.”

As Olney notes in his story, Bumgarner comes from a pitcher-friendly park in San Francisco; his numbers were far more favorable at home than on the road. Opponents are hitting hits fastball at an increasing rate, and hard-hit balls are on the uptick off Bumgarner.

Regardless of how Bumgarner pans out in the long run, it demonstrates that the D-backs have been able to consistently do one thing: prepare for the future without tanking in the present.

“At a time when tanking has been a serious problem in baseball, the Diamondbacks have been able to do all of this —manage the payroll between Goldschmidt and dealing with Greinke’s contract and making that deal at exactly the right time — they never tanked,” Olney said.

Penguin Air

Penguin Air

Arizona Diamondbacks

Joe Mantiply #35 of the Arizona Diamondbacks throws a pitch during the ninth inning against the Mil...
Associated Press

Diamondbacks bullpen blows 2 late leads in extra-inning loss to Brewers

The D-backs bullpen blew a three-run lead in the 9th inning and a one-run lead in the 10th in Monday night's 6-5 loss to the Brewers.
2 days ago
Arizona Diamondbacks' Stone Garrett hits a double against the San Francisco Giants during the eight...
Arizona Sports

Stone Garrett embraces competition for spot in Diamondbacks’ outfield

Stone Garrett is using the final week of the Diamondbacks' season to cement the notion that he belongs in Major League Baseball on a regular basis.
2 days ago
Arizona Diamondbacks' Jake McCarthy slides home to score against the San Francisco Giants during th...
Associated Press

Diamondbacks bullpen blows lead in extras vs. Giants

David Villar hit a two-run single in the 10th inning to give the Giants a 4-3 victory against the Arizona Diamondbacks on Sunday.
3 days ago
Emmanuel Rivera #15 of the Arizona Diamondbacks prepares for a game against the Pittsburgh Pirates ...
Alex Weiner

D-backs place Emmanuel Rivera on IL, select INF Jake Hager

The D-backs selected infielder Jake Hager Sunday from Triple-A Reno to replace Emmanuel Rivera on the roster. 
3 days ago
Arizona Diamondbacks' Stone Garrett celebrates with Ketel Marte (4) after hitting a two-run home ru...
Jordan Leandre

ESPN’s Doolittle poses biggest offseason question for Arizona Diamondbacks

ESPN's Bradford Doolittle poses the biggest offseason question for the Arizona Diamondbacks, as the team builds on exciting end to 2022.
5 days ago
Emmanuel Rivera #15 of the Arizona Diamondbacks at Dodger Stadium on September 19, 2022 in Los Ange...
Jake Anderson

D-backs 3B Emmanuel Rivera out for season with small stable fracture in left wrist

D-backs 3B Emmanuel Rivera will miss the remainder of the season due to a small stable fracture in his left wrist, manager Torey Lovullo said.
4 days ago
Olney: Bumgarner is a Diamondbacks-sized Cole, Strasburg deal