Tom Brady isn’t the GOAT, but is the greatest quarterback in history

Feb 8, 2021, 6:13 PM | Updated: Feb 9, 2021, 7:02 pm

Tampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback Tom Brady (12) celebrates following the NFL Super Bowl 55 football...

Tampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback Tom Brady (12) celebrates following the NFL Super Bowl 55 football game against the Kansas City Chiefs, Sunday, Feb. 7, 2021 in Tampa, Fla. Tampa Bay won 31-9. (Ben Liebenberg via AP)

(Ben Liebenberg via AP)

Tom Brady isn’t the Greatest of All Time. Not among professional athletes. Not even among NFL players. That honor belongs to Walter Payton or Lawrence Taylor.

But he’s the greatest quarterback in history. That’s undebatable and undeniable. The proof is in the jewelry. And that’s no small feat.

Playing quarterback is the hardest job in sports. The position requires leadership, intelligence and emotional maturity. Someone who knows how to give the credit and take the blame. It requires total devotion and dedication to the craft, like the week that Bruce Arians asked Carson Palmer to learn 171 plays before a game against the lowly Bengals. It requires great ambition, arm strength and accuracy. It requires someone comfortable in the spotlight, someone who understands the power of media.

Brady does it better than anyone. As a 43-year-old underdog, Brady just beat Patrick Mahomes in the Super Bowl. That should cool the overzealous fans who thought Mahomes was ready to enter the Pro Football Hall of Fame after three years on the job. And it’s a reminder to every young quarterback in football, notably Arizona’s Kyler Murray:

Brady’s greatness isn’t found in his athleticism or his avocado milkshakes. In Tampa, he had six rushing yards in 16 games. But he remains nearly unbeatable in high-pressure situations, plowing through three road games and three MVPs along the way (Drew Brees, Aaron Rodgers, Mahomes). And that’s because nobody is more prepared than Brady.

That’s how you succeed under pressure, knowing you have left no stone unturned in pursuit of victory.

After Sunday’s triumph, Arians said Brady taught a young, talented team how to win. He also taught them how to work.

Brady showed up in Tampa immediately after signing a free agent contract. He was chided by the city’s mayor for breaking Covid-19 protocol, for training in a park that was closed during the pandemic. He famously walked into the wrong house because he was looking for his new offensive coordinator, Byron Leftwich.

The message was obvious. Brady didn’t come to Florida to retire. He came to work and it starts immediately.

Brady also showed great leadership. He decided not to unduly pressure one of his wide receivers, Chris Godwin, to relinquish the No. 12. Instead, Brady decided he’d wear No. 7 as a member of the Buccaneers, even though his brand is “TB12.”

Godwin gave Brady the jersey out of deference. But the delicate way Brady handled the situation fostered kinship and respect.

Shrewdly, the Buccaneers gave Brady everything he wanted, from players like Rob Gronkowski and Antonio Brown, to a huge stake in the game plan and easy access for his personal trainer. The results speak for themselves.

To reach the pinnacle of the quarterback profession, you have to dedicate your life to football, embracing the enormous parameters of the job. You have to love the grind, the work, the pressure. You carry the hopes and dreams of your city on your shoulders like a privilege. You don’t dare complain or ask anyone to lighten the load.

Anything less is a compromise, proof that you really don’t want it that badly. Not like Brady does.

Dan Bickley

Jonathan Gannon...

Dan Bickley

Cardinals’ Jonathan Gannon has become Eagles’ Super Bowl scapegoat

Thanks to the perceived outrage in Philadelphia, Jonathan Gannon is suddenly considered one of the more unscrupulous coaches in the NFL.

3 days ago

Phoenix Suns Devin Booker...

Dan Bickley

Devin Booker’s silence raises questions on his state of mind

This isn't the time for brooding silence and cryptic tweets. This is time for a franchise player to reassure a fan base the future is bright.

5 days ago

Phoenix Suns head coach Monty Williams hands off the ball during a break in the action during the f...

Dan Bickley

Monty Williams deserved to be fired by Suns, more changes warranted

Monty Williams once stood on a pedestal, praised for instilling culture, mentoring young players, returning respect and dignity to Phoenix.

14 days ago

Phoenix Suns Kevin Durant...

Dan Bickley

Suns are latest failure of championship dream in Phoenix

Championship dreams always die hard. In Phoenix, they die angry. The 2022-23 Suns are just our latest failure.

17 days ago

Phoenix Suns Denver Nuggets...

Dan Bickley

All margin for error has vanished after Suns lose Game 5 to Nuggets

The next episode of the Devin and Kevin Show will be set in an extreme location. It will take place on the brink of elimination.

18 days ago

Devin Booker #1 of the Phoenix Suns reacts after scoring against the Denver Nuggets during the seco...

Dan Bickley

Devin Booker’s coronation begins as Suns even series vs. Nuggets

In England, a new king has officially assumed the throne. In Arizona, the coronation is just getting started.

20 days ago

Tom Brady isn’t the GOAT, but is the greatest quarterback in history