Analyst: McCarthy gives D-backs flexibility

Dec 9, 2012, 4:43 PM | Updated: 4:50 pm

Already with plenty of young pitching in waiting (Trevor Bauer, Tyler Skaggs and Patrick Corbin), two veterans at the top of the staff (Ian Kennedy and Trevor Cahill), a Rookie of the Year candidate (Wade Miley) and a former 16-game winner on the mend (Daniel Hudson), general manager Kevin Towers made one thing known when it came to his rotation at the MLB Winter meetings.

He wanted more.

The Arizona Diamondbacks agreed with veteran right-hander Brandon McCarthy on a two-year deal worth $15.5 on Friday, and the move without a doubt gives the team plenty of options moving forward.

Here’s what’s Keith Law had to saw on the acquisition:

McCarthy is a groundball/control guy who misses just enough bats to be an above-average starter, and he works better when he’s got a good infield defense behind him… McCarthy’s ability to sink the ball had to be appealing to the Diamondbacks given their home park’s habit of increasing home run rates, but he’ll have to be able to keep the cutter and sinker down in the zone more than he did in 2012, especially before his midyear DL stint for shoulder soreness. He’s likely to be worth 2-3 wins if he throws 160-170 innings this year.

Kevin Towers made it known on Arizona Sports 620’s Doug & Wolf Wednesday, that if the team remained in the market for a top-end shortstop — as has been rumored to be the case with the Asdrubel Cabrera — he’d be more incline to trade young pitching than outfielder Justin Upton to make the move.

As Law explained, the signing of McCarthy doesn’t just give Arizona another arm at the No. 2 or No. 3 slot in the rotation, it gives Towers more room to make a deal with young pitching as the main trade chip.

The move leaves the Diamondbacks with a modest pitching surplus that they could use to make a trade. Their Opening Day rotation includes McCarthy, Ian Kennedy, Wade Miley, Trevor Cahill, and likely one of three youngsters, rookies Tyler Skaggs and Trevor Bauer and sophomore Patrick Corbin. Bauer seems to have fallen out of favor in the organization and seems the most likely to be traded, although his stock just eighteen months after he was the third overall pick in the Rule 4 Draft is probably still pretty high. Corbin’s stuff played up in his handful of relief appearances, so while he’s the most experienced and could be a fifth starter, the ideal alignment of pitchers might have Skaggs in the rotation with Corbin as a long man, ready to move into the rotation if there’s a need between Opening Day and the return of Daniel Hudson.

While a surplus does give Towers more ammunition to work with, McCarthy is coming off a season which was cut short due to an epideral hemorrhage and skull fracture he sustained when an Erick Aybar line drive hit him in the head on September 5. Although his 8-6 record with a 3.24 ERA is promising, McCarthy just began baseball activities again last month and psychologically will have an uphill battle coming back from such an unfortunate on-field injury.

Also, with Hudson not expected back until near or after the All-Star break — as he continues rehabbing from Tommy John surgery — having depth in the rotation may not be the smartest thing to sacrifice before the season even takes shape.

Either way, though, it’s a good problem to have for Towers and Co.

Penguin Air


Comment guidelines: No name-calling, personal attacks, profanity, or insults. Please keep the conversation civil and help us moderate comments by reporting abuse.
comments powered by Disqus

Arizona Diamondbacks

Arizona Diamondbacks' Ketel Marte, left, congratulates Christian Walker, right, who crosses home pl...
Associated Press

D-backs’ Christian Walker drives in 4 runs in win over Rockies

Christian Walker had four hits and drove in four runs, leading rookie Tommy Henry and the D-backs over the Rockies 7-4 Sunday.
2 days ago
Arizona Diamondbacks batter Jake McCarthy, left, congratulates Daulton Varsho (12) after Varsho's i...
Associated Press

Diamondbacks match last season’s win total with shutout victory over Rockies

The Diamondbacks notched win No. 52 Saturday night, matching last year's win total with more than a month remaining on the season.
3 days ago
Emmanuel Rivera #15 of the Arizona Diamondbacks celebrates after hitting a third inning solo home r...
Sam Graveline

D-backs’ Emmanuel Rivera hits 2 home runs in win over Colorado

Arizona Diamondbacks third baseman Emmanuel Rivera is fitting right in with his new team, blasting two early home runs on Saturday.
3 days ago
Arizona Diamondbacks relief pitcher Chris Devenski works against the Colorado Rockies in the sixth ...
Associated Press

Arizona Diamondbacks drop series opener in Colorado to Rockies

The Arizona Diamondbacks only managed five hits in a loss on the road against the Colorado Rockies.
4 days ago
Arizona Diamondbacks' Sergio Alcantara (43) and Geraldo Perdomo, middle, celebrate after scoring ag...
Kellan Olson

Diamondbacks rally to beat Pirates, make up for odd defensive blunder

The Arizona Diamondbacks' seven runs in the seventh inning picked up starter Merrill Kelly after he was positioned for an undeserved loss.
5 days ago
Chicago White Sox pitcher Lance Lynn warms up in the outfield before a baseball game against the Ne...
Associated Press

‘Field of Dreams’ game Thursday sees Cubs, Reds clash

“Field of Dreams” gets another tribute when the Cincinnati Reds take on the Chicago Cubs in a throwback ballpark in the cornfields of Iowa.
6 days ago
Analyst: McCarthy gives D-backs flexibility