Don’t compare Martin Prado to Justin Upton

May 15, 2013, 4:03 AM | Updated: 4:09 am

By now the Justin Upton trade has been evaluated every which way possible. And unfortunately for Martin Prado, he will always be compared to the former D-backs’ top overall pick, and there is not much he can do about it.

But while I am a big believer that in every trade there is a winner and loser, I do think there is an angle to this trade that hasn’t been discussed but needs to be. And that is that Prado, while traded for Upton, did not replace him. Prado, in essence, replaced Chris Johnson. It’s Cody Ross who actually replaced Upton.

So it’s a better indicator to look at how Prado compares to Diamondback third basemen from last year and how Ross compares to Upton. Now Ross missed the first 10 games of the season with a bum calf, but since coming off the disabled list, he is hitting .290 with a homer and 10 RBIs. Not comparable to Upton’s 13 homers, 23 runs batted in and .285 average, but numbers that aren’t bad.

It’s easier to compare player for player when they play the same position, ala Jarrod Parker for Trevor Cahill.

Now history shows that the team that gets the best player almost always wins the trade, so I do expect history when all is said and done will show the Braves got the better of the deal.

But if you compare Prado to D-backs third basemen and Ross to Upton, it’s a more fair comparison.

Arizona Diamondbacks

Jorge Soler #12 of the Miami Marlins celebrates with teammates in the dugout after scoring during t...

David Veenstra

ESPN’s Schoenfield: Under-the-radar MLB free agents for Diamondbacks to consider

While Shohei Ohtani will command most of the attention this offseason, there is still value to be had elsewhere on the open market.

2 hours ago

Jose Castillo...

Alex Weiner

Diamondbacks sign LHP Jose Castillo to minor league deal

The Diamondbacks signed left-handed pitcher Jose Castillo to a minor league contract with an invitation to major league spring training.

2 days ago

Andres Chaparro...

Alex Weiner

Diamondbacks add power-hitting minor leaguer Andres Chaparro, assign him to Triple-A

The Arizona Diamondbacks added pop to the system by signing former New York Yankee prospect Andres Chaparro to a minor league deal.

3 days ago

Diamondbacks season ticket pass...

Arizona Sports

Arizona Diamondbacks offer 2024 season ticket pass for $299

The Arizona Diamondbacks announced a new season ticket package for all home games at Chase Field for $299.

3 days ago

Tommy Pham...

Alex Weiner

Free agent Tommy Pham does not want to platoon after Diamondbacks run

Free agent outfielder Tommy Pham, who spent the latter three months of the season with the Diamondbacks, has a clear objective this winter.

7 days ago

(Photo courtesy @GenoDellamorte)...

Arizona Sports

Bickley & Marotta fan creates custom jersey to celebrate Diamondbacks’ World Series run

One Arizona Diamondbacks fan made a custom jersey to represent the MLB club as well as Arizona Sports' Bickley & Marotta.

7 days ago

Don’t compare Martin Prado to Justin Upton