The Arizona Diamondbacks have lost the Brandon McCarthy gamble

Aug 22, 2013, 3:10 PM | Updated: 3:11 pm

Sometimes you win and sometimes you lose, and in the case of Brandon McCarthy, the Diamondbacks have clearly lost.

The free agent pitcher may have looked good on the rack last year, but when you took him home and tried him on, he resembled a cheap suit — one you paid way too much money for and unfortunately can’t take back to the store for a refund or even store credit.

In one of the biggest, if not the biggest games of the year Wednesday in Cincinnati, McCarthy flopped. He couldn’t get out of the third inning, put his team in a 7-0 hole and completely exhausted Arizona’s bullpen, which used seven pitchers to clean up his mess.

Thus far for $15.5 million — $6.5 million paid this year and $9 million next year (which I’m dreading already) — the Diamondbacks have gotten a whopping two wins in 15 starts and two months on the disabled list. Overall he is a miserable 2-8 with a career high 5.44 ERA. He has failed to get through six innings in six of those 15 starts and failed to complete five innings three times.

Sorry, that’s not good enough, not even close. McCarthy’s been a major disappointment and cause for concern for next season. The right-hander came to Arizona with a career record of 37-39 with a 4.02 ERA, which is nothing to write home about and more in line with a dime a dozen pitcher in this league. But he was 8-6 with a 3.24 ERA for Oakland in 18 starts last year before being hit in the head, so there were some signs that he was getting his career on track.

It’s just not happening here. There is little confidence when he takes the mound. He is now 0-4 with a 6.98 ERA in August and you have to wonder if phenom Archie Bradley was pitching those games would Arizona have given themselves a better chance at the playoffs?

Look, Pittsburgh spent a million on Francisco Liriano this year with the chance to make $3.75 million in incentives. Over the previous two seasons, he went 9-10 with an ERA of 5.09 and 6-12 with an ERA of 5.34. This season, his first in Pittsburgh, he is 14-5 with a 2.53 ERA.

Sometimes you win, sometimes you lose. With Brandon McCarthy, the D-backs have clearly lost.

Arizona Diamondbacks

Arizona Diamondbacks' Josh Rojas (10) celebrates his home run against the Colorado Rockies with Dav...
Haboob Blog

D-backs’ Josh Rojas calls David Peralta ‘a traitor’ while mic’d up vs. Dodgers

D-backs 3B Josh Rojas didn't mince his words on Thursday when talking about former teammate and current Dodger David Peralta.
1 day ago
Arizona Diamondbacks starting pitcher Merrill Kelly speaks to reporters for the first time after pl...
Jake Anderson

D-backs need to get Merrill Kelly ready for 1st start after return from WBC

Thursday at Salt River Fields marked the return of Arizona Diamondbacks starting pitcher Merrill Kelly from the World Baseball Classic.
1 day ago
Drey Jameson #99 of the Arizona Diamondbacks pitches during the third inning of the Spring Training...
Jake Anderson

Drey Jameson settles down after rocky 1st inning in penultimate spring start for Diamondbacks

Drey Jameson rescued his penultimate start of spring training in his quest to be selected by Torey Lovullo as the D-backs' No. 5 starter.
1 day ago
Arizona Diamondbacks P Zac Gallen (Tyler Drake/Arizona Sports)...
Arizona Sports

Trio of D-backs land on ESPN’s 2023 MLB Rank top 100 list

Zac Gallen and Ketel Marte made the MLB Rank top-100 list for 2023, but so did Corbin Carroll and his 32 games of MLB experience.
1 day ago
Jordan Lawlar #1 of the National League throws for the third out in the fourth inning during the Si...
Kellan Olson

ESPN’s Passan buying D-backs rise, eyeing Jordan Lawlar 2023 debut

Could the Arizona Diamondbacks be much more competitive a year earlier than expected? ESPN's Jeff Passan believes so.
2 days ago
Catcher Carson Kelly #18 of the Arizona Diamondbacks prepares to take the field before the MLB game...
Tyler Drake

D-backs’ Carson Kelly dealing with forearm fracture, no timeline for return

The Arizona Diamondbacks will have to navigate the beginning of the regular season without starting catcher Carson Kelly.
3 days ago
The Arizona Diamondbacks have lost the Brandon McCarthy gamble