Jets’ Xavier Gipson scored 1st NFL overtime punt return touchdown since Cardinals’ Patrick Peterson

Sep 12, 2023, 8:52 AM | Updated: 12:12 pm

New York Jets punt return man Xavier Gipson after his touchdown against the Bills...

New York Jets wide receiver Xavier Gipson (82) celebrates after running a punt return back for a touchdown against the Buffalo Bills in overtime of an NFL football game, Monday, Sept. 11, 2023, in East Rutherford, N.J. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig)

(AP Photo/Seth Wenig)

Xavier Gipson’s walk-off punt return touchdown in overtime to help his New York Jets pull off a stunning defeat of the Buffalo Bills on Monday Night Football acted as a brief salve for a team that hours earlier lost quarterback Aaron Rodgers to an Achilles injury.

The implications of Rodgers missing the rest of the season are obviously huge.

But Gipson’s play deserves its credit for the rarity.


How many overtime punt return touchdowns have there been in NFL history?

Gipson’s play is only the NFL’s third punt return touchdown in overtime.

All of them were scores for the win — granted the rules of overtime scoring have changed.

The Monday Night Football walk-off by Gipson was the first since 2011.

Arizona Cardinals then-rookie Patrick Peterson closed a 19-13 win over the St. Louis Rams with a 99-yard return that included four broken tackles, the last of which saw the cornerback do a 360-degree spin at full speed to squeak free.

The play was one of four return touchdowns that Peterson had during his rookie season after Arizona selected him with the fifth overall pick in the NFL Draft.

Before that, the first punt return touchdown in overtime on record was an 86-yarder by Kansas City Chiefs’ Tamarick Vanover, who secured a 29-23 win over the San Diego Chargers in October 1995.

Arizona Cardinals

Darius Robinson gets a drink of water...

Ryan Pasiecznik

The Athletic’s biggest question for Cardinals centers around run defense

The Cardinals have question marks at multiple spots on the field. But what is the biggest? The Athletic's Scoop City Podcast took a look.

2 hours ago

Trey Benson warms up during rookie minicamp...

Tyler Drake

Arizona Cardinals sign rookie RB Trey Benson to 4-year contract

The Arizona Cardinals signed rookie running back Trey Benson to a four-year contract, the team announced Thursday.

6 hours ago

Evan Brown runs out the tunnel...

Tyler Drake

Arizona Cardinals training camp battles: Left guard

Looking at Arizona's offensive line, the unit is set outside of left guard. Unlike the WR2 battle, there are several candidates to consider.

20 hours ago


Arizona Sports Video

Video: Which players in the Arizona Cardinals’ division would Wolf & Luke like to request trades?

With the news of San Francisco 49ers WR Brandon Aiyuk's trade request, Wolf & Luke share their wish list of other NFC West players they'd like to see traded out of the division.

1 day ago


Arizona Sports Video

Video: Kyler Murray is confident about the 2024 Cardinals, are you?

Kyler Murray is confident about the 2024 Cardinals, are you? Dan Bickley and Vince Marotta share their thoughts.

1 day ago

Paris Johnson Jr. runs out of the tunnel...

Tyler Drake

Cardinals OL Paris Johnson Jr.’s mindset at left tackle is simple, yet effective

Cardinals OL Paris Johnson Jr.'s mindset at left tackle is a two-step process: Win 1-on-1 battles and watch the football go down the field.

1 day ago

Jets’ Xavier Gipson scored 1st NFL overtime punt return touchdown since Cardinals’ Patrick Peterson