’s Custance: Coyotes should trade up to select Auston Matthews

May 8, 2016, 2:00 PM

USA's Auston Matthews celebrates his 4-2 goal during the 2016 IIHF World Junior Ice Hockey Champion...

USA's Auston Matthews celebrates his 4-2 goal during the 2016 IIHF World Junior Ice Hockey Championship match between USA and Canada in Helsinki, Finland Saturday, Dec. 26, 2015. (Roni Rekomaa/Lehtikuva via AP) FINLAND OUT

(Roni Rekomaa/Lehtikuva via AP)

The match between likely No. 1 overall selection Auston Matthews in the 2016 NHL Draft and the Arizona Coyotes isn’t hard to see.

Matthews, born and raised in Arizona, would become the new face of the franchise for his hometown team that has only reached the conference finals once in 36 seasons.’s Craig Custance sees the match.

One action can go a long way in doing both: an all-out effort to acquire the No. 1 overall pick in the draft from the Toronto Maple Leafs. It’s something the Coyotes need to seriously explore.

Trading up for the No. 1 pick might seem like fantasy talk to some, but the Coyotes do actually have the assets required for such a bold move.

Even in a deal without franchise defenseman Oliver Ekman-Larsson — former GM Don Maloney attempted to squash such talk in March —  the Coyotes possess some big-time value they can throw at the Maple Leafs.

That still leaves a stable full of young players for the Coyotes to include to try and pry the pick away.

Credit Maloney for stocking the cupboard at the end of his tenure. Chayka, if he decides to go down this path, has young players like Max Domi, Dylan Strome, Christian Dvorak and Christian Fischer to include in a blockbuster.

Custance doesn’t even include right winger Conor Garland and center Ryan Macinnis in the discussion, who were both rated top 50 prospects by TSN earlier this year. Strome and Dvorak were No. 2 and No. 3 on the list, respectively.

Those players, along with their draft picks (Arizona has two first rounders this year) could be enough for a team like the Maple Leafs that need multiple young players to have more of a chance at a successful rebuild.

The Coyotes themselves would have to ask if a deal like that is worth it, even though Matthews is assured as the next big potential franchise player to come out of the draft. While they are arguably top-heavy on forward prospects, giving up the farm is always a difficult proposition, especially for a brand new general manager.

Even if they were, Custance himself is unsure of what would be the right deal to get the job done.

Does a deal that includes Strome, Dvorak, Fischer and both firsts get it done? Would it at least keep Lamoriello on the line?

Arizona Coyotes

Mesa Mayor John Giles, Tempe mayor Corey Woods...

Arizona Sports

Mesa mayor ‘encouraging’ Coyotes to look at private sites for new arena

Could the Arizona Coyotes find a new arena home in Mesa and find a way to avoid a public vote like the squashed Tempe plans required?

6 days ago

Logan Cooley #92 of the Minnesota Golden Gophers warms up before a game against the Quinnipiac Bobc...

Wills Rice

Coyotes prospect Logan Cooley to stay 1 more year in college

Arizona Coyotes highly regarded center prospect Logan Cooley announced he is staying in college for one more year.

8 days ago

Clayton Keller, Arizona Coyotes...

Arizona Sports

Arizona Coyotes reportedly inquire about Mesa’s Fiesta Mall site in arena land search

Mesa's old Fiesta Mall footprint is among the land the Arizona Coyotes have inquired about, CBS5's and 3TV's Dennis Welch reported Thursday.

10 days ago

Mullett Arena, Arizona Coyotes, tempe...

Arizona Sports

Coyotes to play at Mullett Arena in 2023-24, seeking new Valley site

The Arizona Coyotes expect to play at Mullett Arena as planned in the 2023-24 season amid uncertainty about their future, the team confirmed.

11 days ago

Arizona Coyotes Tempe arena...

Jake Anderson

Hockey world reacts to Tempe voters’ rejection of Coyotes’ arena plan

One of the Arizona Coyotes' captains and a face of the franchise Clayton Keller made his reaction felt with one simple emoji.

11 days ago

Coyotes arena vote...

Arizona Sports

Coyotes’ arena denied by voters, franchise’s future in Arizona looks uncertain

Tempe voters rejected a bid on Tuesday by the Arizona Coyotes and the city of Tempe to build a new arena complex.

11 days ago’s Custance: Coyotes should trade up to select Auston Matthews