ARIZONA FOOTBALL

NCAA writer discusses potential playoff system

Jun 21, 2012, 11:57 PM | Updated: Jun 22, 2012, 1:28 am

You hear that? It’s the collective cheering of collegiate
pigskin fans countrywide. Goodbye SEC dominance, so long
arbitrary computer rankings, and say hello to a fair and
balanced, conspiracy-free college football postseason.

But what would college football be with a little
controversy?

The four-team playoff announced Wednesday sparked debate
amongst the sport’s enthusiasts, including Sports
Illustrated and SI.com writer Stewart Mandel, who has
covered the sport since 1999. Mandel joined Arizona Sports
620’s Burns and Gambo Thursday to shed light on the
playoff system and how it came to be.

“The problem with [college football’s] current system is
that the voters don’t have to explain how they vote, and
all but one of the computer formulas are a secret,” said
Mandel.

The new playoff will consist of four teams decided by a
“selection” committee. These teams would then play in
semifinal games to determine who would play in the BCS
National Championship Game.

Where these semifinal games are played has yet to be
determined, but Mandel points to the current BCS bowls
being involved, meaning the Fiesta, Sugar, Orange and Rose
Bowls would all rotate as hosts in some fashion.

“I don’t know any specifics yet of that rotation or which
bowls will be involved in that rotation,” said Mandel. “I
think the current BCS bowls have a shot to be part of
that. Whether you get to host a semi-final every other
year or every third year, we just don’t know yet.”

This means the Rose Bowl, traditionally played between
champions of the Big Ten and Pac-12 conference, may
feature a team like LSU or Oklahoma in Pasadena.

Mandel explains this is one of the many reasons the Big
Ten conference is the loser in the decided playoff format.

“The Big Ten reluctantly joined this cause,” said Mandel.
“They’re doing it because the rest of college football
wants to.” He elaborates, stating the nature of bowl games
give Midwestern schools such as Ohio State and Michigan a
“geographic disadvantage”.

“Bowl games were designed to be a nice vacation for the
fans. They weren’t necessarily designed to determine a
national champion.”

Comments

Comment guidelines: No name-calling, personal attacks, profanity, or insults. Please keep the conversation civil and help us moderate comments by reporting abuse.
comments powered by Disqus

Arizona Football

Wide receiver Tetairoa McMillan #4 of the Arizona Wildcats celebrates with Noah Fifita #11 after ca...

Arizona Sports

ESPN’s Rittenberg: Arizona Wildcats’ QB room ranks 10th in nation

Led by the final Pac-12 Freshman of the Year Noah Fifita, the Arizona Wildcats' quarterback room was ranked 10th in the nation.

11 days ago

Grand Canyon forward Duke Brennan...

Vincent DeAngelis

Duke Brennan uses inspiration from family and high motor to propel GCU basketball

Grand Canyon's Duke Brennan has strong Arizona connections and comes from a family of athletes in Colt and Brent Brennan.

19 days ago

Jordan Morgan...

Arizona Sports

Arizona OL, potential 1st-round pick Jordan Morgan shows off speed at NFL Draft Combine

Arizona left tackle Jordan Morgan had the opportunity to show off his speed and athleticism at the NFL Combine on Sunday.

25 days ago

Jacob Cowing...

Arizona Sports

Arizona’s Jacob Cowing shows off elite speed at NFL Scouting Combine

NFL Draft prospect Jacob Cowing from Arizona put up one of the fastest 40-yard dash times among wide receivers at the combine.

25 days ago

An empty podium is seen at the NFL Combine at Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis, Indiana. (Photo by...

David Veenstra

What to watch for: 2024 NFL Scouting Combine schedule, preview and more

The NFL Scouting Combine begins this week in Indianapolis. Here's a complete guide for college and professional fans across Arizona.

30 days ago

Quarterback Jayden de Laura #7 prepares for a game at Arizona Stadium on October 28, 2023 in Tucson...

Tom Kuebel

Former Arizona quarterback Jayden de Laura declares for NFL Draft

Jayden de Laura declared for the NFL Draft and will forego his fifth season of college football eligibility.

1 month ago

NCAA writer discusses potential playoff system