SI’s Mandel: ASU would have a ‘strong case’ to be part of College Football Playoff

Dec 4, 2013, 5:08 PM | Updated: 5:08 pm
LISTEN: Stewart Mandel, college football writer

The four-team College Football Playoff may be coming a season too late for the Arizona State Sun Devils.

Had the format been around this season, there is a good chance ASU would be on the precipice of a playoff spot.

Monday,’s Stewart Mandel wrote that should the Sun Devils beat Stanford Saturday and improve to 11-2, they would be champions of one of the nation’s two toughest conferences.

They would also hold an eight-game winning streak and boast a strong nonconference schedule, beating 9-3 Wisconsin (32-30 on Sept. 14) and losing to 8-4 Notre Dame (37-34 on Oct. 5). All metrics say Arizona State has played one of the toughest schedules in the country. Here’s guessing the committee would view them much more favorably than this season’s pollsters.

Timing is everything, right?

A guest of Burns and Gambo’s Tuesday, Mandel elaborated on his thinking.

“Obviously it depends on what else happens this weekend, but I think that’s going to be one of the fascinating things about this new system,” he said. “It’s going to change what we currently consider to be the pool of teams.”

Mandel added that the current system leads to a team basically needing to go undefeated to reach the national championship game, and next year that won’t necessarily be the case.

“There’s really no mind paid to, for instance, ASU has played a much tougher schedule, much tougher schedule than Ohio State or Florida State,” he said. “So yeah, I think that a committee that’s truly dedicated to looking at a team’s overall body of work would see that ASU first of all, beat Wisconsin out of conference, scheduled tough — scheduled Wisconsin and Notre Dame out of conference — and then played a nine-game, actually a 10-game conference schedule where they played all the top teams in the league except Oregon, I think they’d have a strong case to be made to be in the top four depending on who else is in that pool.”

Unfortunately for the Sun Devils, that possibility will not be available to them until next season. Though they are ranked 11th in the BCS standings now, a win over Stanford will not get them into the championship game.

Still, few in Tempe would likely go the Oregon route and complain about the Rose Bowl, so the season would most definitely go down as a success.

Arizona State Football

Arizona State wide receiver Javen Jacobs during 2023 spring ball in Tempe, Arizona. (Sun Devil Athl...
Jake Anderson

ASU’s pass-catcher competition includes ‘deep wideout and tight end positions’

The Arizona State Sun Devils have a plethora of talent on the offensive side of the football when it comes to pass catchers.
1 day ago
Arizona State true freshman quarterback Jaden Rashada gives the "forks up" after a spring ball prac...
Jake Anderson

Arizona State’s QB battle heats up after 1st week of spring ball with Jaden Rashada

There are six on the roster, half of which are returners, while two are transfers and one is freshman five-star dual-threat QB Jaden Rashada.
4 days ago
Arizona State defensive back Chris Edmonds, celebrates his pass interception with linebacker Will S...
Jake Anderson

Communication is key for Arizona State’s new defense early on in spring ball

Communication is key in defense, especially in the modern era of college football where offenses are running quick-tempo, hurry-up offenses.
6 days ago
Arizona State University president Michael Crow interviews with Doug & Wolf on 98.7 FM Arizona'...
Kevin Zimmerman

ASU, Arizona presidents: Not preparing to leave for Big 12

The presidents of Arizona State University and the University of Arizona went on the record reaffirming their commitment to the Pac-12.
7 days ago
Kenny Dillingham. (Twitter Photo/@ASUFootball)...
Jake Anderson

Kenny Dillingham instills ‘just compete’ philosophy on Day 1 of ASU spring ball

The first day of spring ball for ASU with new head coach Kenny Dillingham had a vastly different vibe than previous regimes.
8 days ago
Quarterback Trenton Bourguet #16 of the Arizona State Sun Devils throws a pass during the second ha...
Kellan Olson

ASU QB Trenton Bourguet far more healthy in 2023 after 2-year foot issues

ASU's spring starter at quarterback will be able to utilize his skill set in a way he hasn't been physically able to since training camp of 2021.
9 days ago
SI’s Mandel: ASU would have a ‘strong case’ to be part of College Football Playoff