Comparing the Tyrann Mathieu contract with other defensive backs

Aug 4, 2016, 12:08 PM
Arizona Cardinals free safety Tyrann Mathieu (32) celebrates his sack of Baltimore Ravens quarterba...
Arizona Cardinals free safety Tyrann Mathieu (32) celebrates his sack of Baltimore Ravens quarterback Joe Flacco during the second half of an NFL football game, Monday, Oct. 26, 2015, in Glendale, Ariz. (AP Photo/Ross D. Franklin)
(AP Photo/Ross D. Franklin)

Cardinals defensive back Tyrann Mathieu agreed Tuesday with the Cardinals on a contract that gives him the biggest contract among NFL safeties.

Does he deserve it?

The Honey Badger got a deal worth $62.5 million, $21.25 million of which is guaranteed.

The 24-year-old Mathieu is entering his fourth NFL season, coming off an abbreviated 2015 in which he tore his right ACL. He also tore the ACL in his left knee in 2013.

In three NFL seasons, Mathieu has played 40 games (31 starts), picking off 8 passes for one touchdown, defensing 30 passes and making 196 tackles along with two forced fumbles.

Last season alone, Mathieu had five interceptions (T-6th in NFL) and one touchdown with 17 passes defensed (T-9th in NFL), one forced fumble, one sack and 89 tackles (14th among safeties) in 14 games.

Mathieu’s stats and popularity among fans likely both contribute to his brand new contract, but how does his on-field performance stack up with other players at his position? Here’s where he stands, dollar-wise:

Top-paid safeties by total contract value:
1) Tyrann Mathieu – ARI; $62.5 MM
2) Jairus Byrd – NO; $54 MM
3) Harrison Smith – MIN; $51.25 MM
4) Devin McCourty – NE; $47.5 MM
5) Earl Thomas – SEA; $40 MM

Top-paid safeties by total guaranteed money:
1) Harrison Smith – MIN; $28.58 MM
2) Devin McCourty – NE; $28.5 MM
3) Jairus Byrd – NO; $26.3 MM
4) Earl Thomas – SEA; $25.73 MM
5) Tyrann Mathieu – ARI; $21.25 MM

Mathieu is ranked fifth among safeties in total guaranteed money, first in total contract value and first in average salary. Here’s how his statistics compare to other top-paid safeties:

saintsJairus Byrd

Byrd, a free safety on the New Orleans Saints, has a contract worth $54 million (2nd) with $26.3 million guaranteed (3rd). Last year, Byrd played 13 games with one interception, three passes defensed, one forced fumble, one sack and 53 tackles.

The 29-year-old has one Pro Bowl to his name and is signed through 2019.

vikingsHarrison Smith

In four seasons with the Minnesota Vikings, the 27-year-old Smith has four touchdowns on 12 interceptions. Last season, he had two interceptions for one touchdown to go along with three passes defensed, 1.5 sacks and 66 tackles.

Smith’s contract is worth $51.25 million (3rd) with $28.578 million guaranteed (1st).

patslogoDevin McCourty

This former first-round pick is a six-year NFL veteran with New England, ranking fourth in the league with a $47.5 million contract with $28.5 million guaranteed (2nd). His first three years were more statistically productive than his most recent three, and in 2015, McCourty had just one interception, no touchdowns and five passes defensed in 14 games.

Still, the 28-year-old and brother of Titans cornerback Jason McCourty has proven to be a productive player for Bill Belichick’s Patriots.

seahawksEarl Thomas

Impressively, Seattle’s Earl Thomas has started 16 games in each of his six NFL seasons. He has 21 interceptions and one touchdown in his career, and put up nine passes defensed, five interceptions, one forced fumble and 61 tackles last season.

The productive and reliable Texas alum boasts a contract worth $40 million (5th) with $25.725 million guaranteed (4th).

chiefsEric Berry

Berry’s $10.8 million average salary is second-most among NFL safeties behind Mathieu, but that’s at the end of a six-year deal, putting his total current contract value at 28th. In the first four years of that deal, $25 million was guaranteed.

The 27-year-old has battled injuries and Hodgkin’s lymphoma, but has stayed resilient to play four full NFL seasons in six years in the league. Last season, Berry had two interceptions with no touchdowns and 10 passes defensed, along with 61 tackles. He and the Badger were also the two safeties who made the All Pro team last year.

Part of what makes Mathieu valuable is his versatility. Listed as a safety, he can also come down to play man coverage as a corner. Among other NFL cornerbacks, Mathieu is well-paid:

Top-paid cornerbacks by total contract value:
1) Josh Norman – WAS; $75 MM
2) Darrelle Revis – NYJ; $70.12 MM
3) Patrick Peterson – ARI; $70.05 MM
4) Joe Haden – CIN; $67.5 MM
5) Byron Maxwell – MIA; $63 MM
6) Tyrann Mathieu – ARI; $62.5 MM

Top-paid cornerbacks by total guaranteed money:
1) Josh Norman – WAS; $50 MM
2) Patrick Peterson – ARI; $47.37 MM
3) Richard Sherman – SEA; $40 MM
4) Darrelle Revis – NYJ; $39 MM
5) Janoris Jenkins – NYG; $28.8 MM

13) Tyrann Mathieu – ARI; $21.25

Mathieu’s new contract has him tied for sixth among corners in contract value, 13th in guaranteed money and tied for eighth in average salary. Mathieu’s numbers compare with other top-paid corners as follows:

redskinsJosh Norman

After a strange turn of events in which the Panthers rescinded their franchise tag, Norman wound up with the Washington Redskins this offseason. His new contract makes him the highest-paid cornerback in football, boasting a contract worth $75 million (1st) with $50 million guaranteed (1st).

In 38 starts in four seasons with Carolina, Norman had seven interceptions with 36 passes defensed. Last season, he had 18 passes defensed – just one more than Mathieu –  with four interceptions, two touchdowns, three forced fumbles and 56 tackles.

jetsDarrelle Revis

Revis has nine years in the league with the Jets, Patriots and Buccaneers. At age 31, he boasts both experience and production to back up a contract worth $70.1 million (2nd) with $39 million guaranteed (4th).

Now in his second stint with the Jets, the four-time Pro Bowler caught five interceptions last year (tied with Mathieu) with nine passes defensed and 39 tackles.

cardinalsPatrick Peterson

Peterson had fewer interceptions, touchdowns, passes defensed and tackles last year than Mathieu did – and he played two more games. Still, Peterson has been called one of the game’s top corners, and it shows with a contract worth $70.05 million (3rd) with $47.4 million guaranteed (2nd).

As a starter in all 16 games last year, Pat Pete had two interceptions and eight passes defensed with 33 tackles (all solo). For what it’s worth, he also had a 72-yard interception in the playoff loss at Carolina.

seahawksRichard Sherman

Seattle’s Sherman once called himself the best corner in the game, but he’s not paid like it. His $14 million average salary is 4th in the NFL (behind Peterson, Revis, Norman). His current contract is worth $56 million (9th) with $40 million guaranteed (3rd).

The 28-year-old was picked in the fifth round in 2011, but has gone on to be one of Seattle’s biggest standout players. In his five seasons, Sherman has 26 interceptions and 84 passes defensed. Last year, he had two interceptions, 14 passes defensed and 40 tackles.

brownsJoe Haden

Haden has been in the NFL for six years, all with the Cleveland Browns. Though his team has finished in last place in the AFC North every year but his rookie season (3rd), he has managed to be a productive player, earning a contract worth $67.5 million (4th) with $22.7 million guaranteed (12th).

Multiple injuries limited Haden to just five games last year, but in 2014, the Florida alum had three interceptions, 20 passes defensed, two fumble recoveries and 73 tackles in 15 games.

Among non-quarterbacks, Mathieu ranks 30th in average salary. The top three highest salaries for non-QBs belong to Broncos OLB Von Miller, Dolphins DT Ndamukong Suh and Jets DE Muhammad Wilkerson.

Arizona Cardinals

Arizona Cardinals WR Marquise Brown looks on during minicamp on Wednesday, June 15, 2022, in Tempe....
Sam Graveline

Shook: Marquise Brown best Cards’ candidate to be 1st-time Pro Bowler

Cardinals wide receiver Marquise Brown has yet to make the Pro Bowl in his career, but's Nick Shook thinks that could change in 2022.
24 hours ago
Head coach Sean McVay of the Los Angeles Rams talks with players before mini camp on June 8, 2022 a...
Tyler Drake

NFC West offseason outlook: The Los Angeles Rams

After diving into the 49ers' current state of affairs, it's time to take a look at the 2021 Super Bowl champion Rams.
24 hours ago
Detroit Lions fullback Jason Cabinda (45) pulls away from Arizona Cardinals inside linebacker Isaia...
Wills Rice

PFF’s Linsey: Arizona Cardinals have NFL’s No. 23 ranked roster for 2022

Pro Football Focus' Ben Linsey has the Arizona Cardinals as the No. 23 ranked roster heading into the 2022 season.
24 hours ago
Kyler Murray #1 and Justin Pugh #67 of the Arizona Cardinals react after a penalty during the secon...
Arizona Sports

ESPN: OL Justin Pugh is Arizona Cardinals’ most underrated player

ESPN posted a list made by Football Outsiders of every team's most underrated player, and Justin Pugh was selected to represent the Cardinals.
2 days ago
Deebo Samuel #19 of the San Francisco 49ers runs with the ball during the game against the Los Ange...
Tyler Drake

NFC West offseason outlook: The San Francisco 49ers

The offseason has twisted and turned not only for the Cardinals but for the rest of the NFC West. A look at the current state of the 49ers:
2 days ago
Arizona Cardinals defensive tackle Corey Peters (98) walks out before an NFL game between the Arizo...
Nikash Nath

PFF’s Doug Kyed advises Arizona Cardinals to bring back DL Corey Peters

With the Cardinals' current roster construction, PFF's Doug Kyed believes Arizona should bring DL Corey Peters back once more in 2022.
4 days ago
Comparing the Tyrann Mathieu contract with other defensive backs