ASU BASKETBALL

ASU’s NCAA Tournament resume pokes holes in selection process

Mar 7, 2018, 4:34 PM | Updated: Jul 26, 2024, 11:32 am

Arizona State's Kimani Lawrence (14), along with Colorado's McKinley Wright IV (25) and Namon Wrigh...

Arizona State's Kimani Lawrence (14), along with Colorado's McKinley Wright IV (25) and Namon Wright (13), reaches for a loose ball during the second half of an NCAA college basketball game in the first round of the Pac-12 men's tournament Wednesday, March 7, 2018, in Las Vegas. Colorado defeated Arizona State 97-85. (AP Photo/Isaac Brekken)

(AP Photo/Isaac Brekken)

If Arizona State is included in the NCAA tournament field, the system is flawed.

If Arizona State is not included in the NCAA tournament field, the system is run by hypocrites.

In this year’s tournament, there’s a massive difference in who deserves to go to the dance and who belongs in the dance. The Sun Devils went 1-5 to end the season and close with an 8-11 record against teams in a throwaway conference — that is not worthy of a tournament bid. The catch is, the NCAA has trumpeted for the last eighth months its new magic word: “quadrant.”

The NCAA can’t be telling every college basketball fan it’s about the quadrant if ASU is heading to the NIT.

RPI stands for ratings percentage index. Since this enormous collection of schools of higher learning can’t use updated analytics, they use RPI — a terribly outdated metric — to rank teams based on the schedule they’ve played. All 347 Division I teams are ranked, and each win by an individual team is then ranked by which quadrant the win falls into. Quadrant 1 is any home win versus a team ranked 1-30, any neutral site win versus a team ranked 1-50 or any road win versus a team ranked 1-75. Quadrant 2, 3 and 4 continue in a spiral downward.

Imagine if I said my beloved Ohio Bobcats beat Villanova (they didn’t). You’d be impressed. Would you care if Ohio beat Utah Valley? Ignorantly, the tournament committee has decided beating RPI No. 2 Villanova at home is the same as beating RPI No. 74 Utah Valley in the vaunted UCCU Center.

In no way can I justify the ridiculous standard set up by the NCAA. I won’t justify including ASU basketball on Sunday’s Selection Show, either.

If the Devils wanted to be in the tournament, run an offense against Oregon. Make your free throws against Stanford. Guard the three-point line against Colorado.

Arizona State does not deserve a tournament bid but by the foolish criteria set-up for inclusion by the NCAA, they belong in the field. If ASU is left out, the entire tournament is a sham run by unqualified buffoons who are not worth the words they speak.

Do you think Ohio State is a tournament team? Everybody does. Ohio State has three wins versus Quadrant 1 teams and a .375 winning percentage in those games. ASU has three wins versus quadrant one teams and a .375 winning percentage in those games.

The NCAA committee for years has included “last 10” as a major criteria. How are you playing to end the season? Going 7-3 to end the season shows fire, playing your best at tournament time and separating yourself from the other teams on the bubble.

I thought “last 10” was a good type of bubble tie-breaker. The NCAA disagrees. For the 2018 season, they’ve done away with weighting February and March over November. They like the golf method. It doesn’t matter where the birdie or bogey occurs on your scorecard. You are judged by your total number of shots after 18 holes, or, in this case, following the conclusion of the season.

Since ASU’s end of the season flameout doesn’t matter, their 1-5 finish is irrelevant. Arizona State has the two biggest nonconference wins of the entire NCAA field beating Xavier in Vegas and Kansas in Lawrence. Arizona State played the third hardest nonconference schedule. ASU can’t control its conference schedule was 109th most difficult.

The NCAA for decades has stressed the importance of nonconference schedule in order to earn a bid to the tournament. One year, the NCAA went so far as putting in a below average Georgia team under Jim Harrick in the tournament because they played a brutal nonconference schedule. Following their new rules and elements of their old precedents, the Devils belong in the dance, even if they have to go to Dayton to begin the party.

ASU Basketball

Tempe brewery NIL...

Arizona Sports

Tempe brewery signs sponsorship and NIL deal with ASU

Tempe-based Huss Brewing Co. announced it has signed a multifaceted sponsorship deal with Arizona State University, which includes the creation of a Sun Devil specific ale.

6 hours ago

Bobby Hurley...

Damon Allred

ASU AD Graham Rossini agrees Bobby Hurley’s handling of Arizona loss was unacceptable

Arizona State AD Graham Rossini on Thursday was critical of how men's basketball coach Bobby Hurley handled Saturday's loss to Arizona.

1 day ago

ASU...

Damon Allred

Kansas State loss the latest example of ASU basketball coming up just short

ASU's unbreakable habit of losing winnable games continued on Tuesday, as it again came up just short in a loss to Kansas State.

3 days ago

Arizona State Guard Adam Miller vs. GCU on Nov. 14, 2024. (Jeremy Schnell/Arizona Sports)...

Lance Hartzler

ASU’s Adam Miller ejected after reportedly slapping a Kansas State player

Arizona State guard Adam Miller was ejected from Tuesday night's basketball game against Kansas State after he was assessed a flagrant 2 foul after he reportedly slapped Wildcat guard Dug McDaniel.

3 days ago

Arizona State...

Alex Weiner

Missed free throws bury ASU basketball vs. Kansas State

A pair of missed free throws by Jayden Quaintance in the final seconds clinched a loss for Arizona State basketball against Kansas State.

3 days ago

Jayden Quaintance...

Lance Hartzler

Arizona State stifles Kansas State offense with 15-0 opening run

The Arizona State men's basketball team got off to a blistering 15-0 start against Kansas State Tuesday night in Tempe.

3 days ago

ASU’s NCAA Tournament resume pokes holes in selection process