ADVERTISEMENT

ARIZONA WILDCATS BASKETBALL

Court rules RJ Godfrey eligible to play for Arizona as UConn game looms

The ruling should make him eligible to play Wednesday against No. 3 UConn, though he must be certified by the NCAA beforehand.

Watch: Rob Gronkowski makes his grand entrance to FOX's "Big Noon Kickoff" being hosted at Arizona, his alma mater. | 1 min

Power forward RJ Godfrey has been granted eligibility to play for the Arizona Wildcats after a hearing through the Pima County Superior Court granted him a temporary restraining order and a motion for a preliminary injunction, reports the Arizona Daily Star’s Bruce Pascoe.

The ruling should make him eligible to play Wednesday against No. 3 UConn, though he must be certified by the NCAA beforehand.

Judge Jeffrey Bergin gave the order after an evidentiary hearing in which Godfrey, UA coach Tommy Lloyd and UA players Derek Dixon and Ivan Kharchenkov were called to testify.

Bergin said he based his order entirely on the NCAA’s Bylaw 12.6, which he ruled was a contract between the NCAA and its member schools. Godfrey’s attorneys had worked to establish the Manual as a contract, since their lawsuit was against UA and the Arizona Board of Regents for a breach of contract in not certifying Godfrey.

Bylaw 12.6, which specifies that players have five years of eligibility to play within a five-year window starting upon enrollment in college or their 19th birthday, does not have a written exclusion for players such as Godfrey who graduated high school in 2022.

It is his third attempt to gain eligibility after hearings in Texas and Georgia.

ADVERTISEMENT

The 6-foot-8, 240-pound fifth-year forward and Clemson transfer Clemson forced coach Tommy Lloyd to significantly shift his lineup and rotations.

“(Godfrey) puts the pieces in the right place for our roster to kind of have the depth it needs to have and kind of the impact we would love to have off the bench,” Lloyd said at Big 12 Media Days on Oct. 21. “RJ is going to help put all the pieces in the right place.”

Arizona’s arguably best perimeter defender, Ivan Kharchenkov, who was a standout at small forward last season as a freshman, has been pushed to play power forward.

Godfrey withdrew from Georgia and refiled in Texas

Godfrey, along with other athletes, including Gonzaga’s Chauncey Wiggins, were attempting to join the Wheeler v. NCAA lawsuit filed in Waco, Texas, in search of a quicker path to eligibility. Other plaintiffs in the aforementioned suit have a preliminary injunction granted through Dec. 14, keeping those players temporarily eligible to play at least until then, when arguments are scheduled to be heard.

Godfrey and the other players withdrew from their Georgia “five-for-five” case and refiled in Texas after oral arguments in the Georgia suit were not scheduled until Jan. 12, well into the college basketball season.

Ryan Downton, Godfrey’s attorney, argued Godfrey and the 19 players were no different than the rest of the class of 2022 athletes receiving eligibility, but were being unfairly punished for filing their lawsuits first, where they received injunctions before the NCAA published its 2026-27 manual, where “five-for-five” athletes are eligible to compete.

Downton suggested the players would “suffer irreparable harm” if they were not able to play a fifth season due to missing out on name, image and likeness (NIL) opportunities.

An overwhelming majority of “five-for-five” players seeking an additional year of eligibility have been ruled eligible, especially in the Big 12.

ADVERTISEMENT

Godfrey’s attorney also argued the players had a legal right to voluntarily dismiss their previous lawsuits in Tennessee and Georgia, and they had a legal right to refile those lawsuits in Texas. 

How Arizona and RJ Godfrey got to this point

Over the past year, the Wildcats struck out on a series of high-profile power forwards, from five-star Phoenix Saint Mary’s High School product Cameron Williams to other established players in the transfer portal like Bryson Tiller and Milan Momcilovic. To make matters worse for the Wildcats, Koa Peat opted to remain in the NBA draft, and Arizona was left without many remaining options to fill its hole at power forward coming off the trip to the Final Four.

Godfrey signed with Arizona on Aug. 2 after a federal judge in Colorado granted blanket eligibility to all 2022 high school graduates two days prior, but the continuation of a legal battle over his eligibility status has followed in the ensuing months.

ADVERTISEMENT

After playing four seasons, Godfrey, 23, sued the NCAA on July 9 seeking a fifth year of eligibility as part of the group lawsuit filed in Georgia involving 15 other Division I college basketball players whose eligibility ran out after this past season.

In the complaint, Godfrey and the 15 other players argued that the NCAA “unfairly” restricted the number of games athletes could play during their five-year eligibility window, ultimately “unjustifiably” restraining their earning potential through NIL.

The legal pressure came on the heels of the NCAA updating its eligibility model on June 23, replacing the traditional five-year clock to play four seasons with a blanket five years of total competition, effectively eliminating traditional redshirts and limiting future waivers strictly to pregnancy, military service or religious missions.

Godfrey and the other plaintiffs were granted an injunction on Aug. 5, making them eligible.

ADVERTISEMENT

However, on Sept. 9, Godfrey was no longer considered eligible after the NCAA was granted a stay of the injunction by the Georgia Court of Appeals. Godfrey and the other plaintiffs’ attorneys then filed an emergency motion with the Georgia Court of Appeals to reconsider the stay granted.

Godfrey later filed a writ with the Georgia Supreme Court on Oct. 7, requesting to lift the stay and to make him eligible pending a decision on the case, which remained pending until he withdrew himself from the Georgia case, ending that pathway to eligibility.

Attorneys in Godfrey’s case previously said he would be suspended four games to start his season at Arizona because, although Godfrey never signed a professional contract, he played in the Reese’s College All-Star Game and signed with a professional agent prior to attempting to return to college.

Godfrey traveled with the Wildcats to Lithuania in the preseason but did not participate in any of the team’s three exhibition games abroad and did not participate in any of Arizona’s three exhibition games at McKale Center before the official start of the season.

ADVERTISEMENT

Godfrey worked out for the Golden State Warriors prior to last summer’s NBA Draft but wasn’t selected or signed to an undrafted free-agent contract. He was gearing up for NBA workouts when his friend and former Utah State player MJ Collins encouraged him to consult a lawyer about the possibility of returning to college for another season.

Godfrey began his collegiate career at Clemson, where he played for two seasons and made one start over 69 games. He transferred to Georgia ahead of the 2024-25 season and started all 33 games as a junior for the Bulldogs.

He averaged 6.4 points, 3.8 rebounds and 1.0 assists per game. He then transferred back to Clemson, where he led the team in scoring at 12.0 points per game last season. He also averaged 5.3 rebounds and 1.6 assists per game.

Godfrey and Clemson defeated Arizona in the Sweet 16 of the NCAA Tournament in 2024. The forward had seven points, one rebound and four personal fouls in 11 minutes.

David Veenstra ArizonaSports.com editor

David Veenstra is a web content editor and writer for ArizonaSports.com and KTAR.com, where he covers the Arizona Wildcats and more. Prior to joining Arizona Sports and KTAR, he earned his bachelor’s degree in journalism from the University of… Read more

Comments

0 Comments