Pros and cons of the Diamondbacks making a Ketel Marte trade
Are the Diamondbacks better off moving on from Ketel Marte or keeping their longtime franchise staple around?
Watch: Exclusive: Diamondbacks GM Mike Hazen talks Ketel Marte and the MLB deadline | 12 mins
Last winter, the Arizona Diamondbacks had a massive decision to make about the present and the future of the franchise: Trade Ketel Marte or not.
Arizona listened to teams calling about Marte, reports came out of potential packages that were offered by the Boston Red Sox and Tampa Bay Rays and ultimately, the club opted to keep Marte in town. General manager Mike Hazen sat down with Marte ahead of spring training to get back on the same page, apologizing for the publicity of the trade rumors.
One year later, the Diamondbacks are asking the same question about whether they are better off with Marte moving forward or not, but several variables have changed:
- Marte has 10-5 rights (10 years in MLB, five on the same team), giving him a full no-trade clause
- Marte no-showed another game in 2026, a recurring issue
- Marte was not as impactful on the field. He had a decent, not elite season
- Marte ended the season quite poorly with one home run over his last 23 games
Manager Torey Lovullo said he will no longer protect Marte like he has in the past, a tone shift after re-signing with the organization. Team owner Ken Kendrick said Marte’s “acts of immaturity” need to end.
And there are teams with reported interest circling overhead, including the Toronto Blue Jays and Baltimore Orioles. Offseason activity is moving quicker than usual with the expected lockout on Dec. 1.
So, what are the pros and cons of trading Marte, with the caveat that they D-backs have to find an agreeable destination for the three-time All-Star?
Pros and cons: Ketel Marte trade
Pro: No longer have to worry about his no-shows
The most obvious reason why the Diamondbacks would move off Marte is the years of distraction and mistrust his no-shows have created, which came to a boiling point on Aug. 17 when he never arrived at Fenway Park. Marte spent the next three days on the restricted list before moving to the injured list after having a meeting with his agent and D-backs brass.
Marte admitted he was frustrated by his sore knee and did not handle the situation well, but for a team fighting for postseason positioning, the ordeal was harmful. Considering this was not the first time something like this has happened, the incident hit Lovullo hard. Marte no-showed a game late in 2023 during a pennant chase and the first three games out of the All-Star break in 2025 when the team was battling to avoid being a seller.
Lovullo said he could not provide any reassurance it won’t happen again.
Con: Marte is really good at baseball
There are no players in Major League Baseball like Marte, a switch-hitting second baseman who from 2023-25 was among the 10 most productive hitters in the game.
Last season was a down year for Marte, who finished with a .748 OPS and 22 home runs, a solid albeit unspectacular output, especially for his standards. From 2023-25, Marte was ninth in MLB with an .887 OPS and eighth in slugging at .519.
He won back-to-back Silver Slugger awards and made the All-Star team in 2024 and 2025. Even in 2026, his start to the season was mired in misfortune, as he was among the hardest hitters through the first six weeks with few results to show for it. He was dominant for the next six weeks, good enough to carry the offense before he slowed down, and eventually his season was bogged down by the controversy.
Second base has not been a position of need in Arizona for a long time. The D-backs have young options to fill the void, including top prospect Demetrio Crisantes, Tim Tawa and Tommy Troy, but Marte’s power production will be difficult to replace for a lineup that lacked consistent juice last season.
Pro: Save money to use elsewhere
Marte is owed $13.75 million in 2027, $20 million in 2028, $22 million in each of the 2029 and 2030 seasons with an $11.5 million player option for 2031.
That’s five years and over $89 million left, including the option year, with some escalators for plate appearances and MVP votes.
Arizona is expected to lower its payroll this offseason after the club reached a franchise high in 2026 with no postseason appearance to show for it, so getting off the Marte deal could open avenues to add in free agency or take on money in other trades.
The D-backs have shown a reported interest in Japanese star Teruaki Sato, and perhaps the money saved by dealing Marte could lead to money opening for another big move. The D-backs have not been shy over the past three offseasons in going after big fish in free agency (which typically has not worked out, however).
Con: Probably not getting equal value in a trade
The Diamondbacks did not find what they considered fair value for Marte a year ago, but talent for talent, it is hard to imagine they get a better deal this time around. There is too much baggage along with a no-trade clause, and money could factor in a return.
Would the D-backs prefer to add a better package but have to eat some of the money, or would they take a lesser deal to get off the contract and allocate those dollars elsewhere?
Another variable is that Diamondbacks officials are not sure which teams Marte would waive his no-trade clause for even after meeting with his agent, according to AZCentral.com’s Nick Piecoro.
If Marte was dominant again last year, that could have helped with leverage, but he wasn’t.
Pro: Avoid his potential decline
Marte turned 33 years old earlier this offseason, and while his expected numbers were better than his raw production in 2026, they still were down from 2024 and 2025.
Marte also has injury concerns to manage carefully as the D-backs have attempted to do, but he has spent time on the IL in each of the past three seasons.
Perhaps his expected numbers suggest he is primed for a resurgent 2027 season, at least that is what the D-backs can sell to interested clubs. But what will Marte look like in 2028? In 2030? Will there become a point when trading him is no longer possible if injuries or decline come for him?
Con: Unceremonious end to a franchise icon’s tenure
It would undoubtedly be a bummer for one of the franchise’s greatest players to end his tenure with another controversy followed by a lackluster trade to get him out of town.
Marte may end up in the Diamondbacks’ Hall of Fame one day, as he is first in franchise history in games played, second in hits, third in home runs and third in RBIs. He won the 2023 NLCS MVP, setting the MLB record for the longest postseason hitting streak at 20 games.
Even in a year clouded by the no-show, he hit walk-off home runs against the San Francisco Giants and Los Angeles Dodgers that were electric to watch at Chase Field.
Breakups between teams and star players are not always clean, and this would be a very messy end to a journey that started before the 2017 season.
Potential pro: Shaking up the core
Hazen has said several times this offseason that he needs to look at his core of players, the one that has been together since the 2023 World Series run, and decide where change is necessary.
The D-backs have missed the playoffs three straight seasons by a total of five games, taking each race right down to the final weekend of the regular season before falling short.
Continuity was stressed as a positive last spring when Arizona brought Merrill Kelly and Zac Gallen back while keeping Marte, but the tone has shifted.
The D-backs need to find a way to get from winning mid-80s games to the next tier. There is always the risk that shaking up the roster could lead to a step in the wrong direction, but there is clearly a feeling that this team is running into a wall as currently constructed.
A Marte trade, no matter how telegraphed it may be, would obviously be a massive change to the core both on the field and in the clubhouse.







Comments
0 Comments