Hour 1: The D-backs shut out the Pirates, the crew debates Nelson vs. E-Rod, a loaded "Replay: Rewind", and Nick Piecoro previews Arizona’s homestand.

Tuesday, May 27, 2025 | 49:13

Hour one kicks off with a recap of the Arizona Diamondbacks dominant 5-0 victory over the Pittsburgh Pirates, followed by a lively debate between Manuch and Jimmy B. about whether Ryne Nelson or Eduardo Rodriguez gives the D-backs a better chance to win moving forward. In the “Replay: Rewind” segment, the guys react to key highlights from last night’s playoff action—including Oklahoma City taking a 3-1 lead over Minnesota, Karl-Anthony Towns erupting in the fourth to keep Indiana alive vs. New York, and Carolina getting their first win over Florida in the NHL postseason. Later, Arizona Republic D-backs beat writer Nick Piecoro joins the show on the Right Toyota Guest Line to discuss the team’s pitching situation, recent fan frustrations with E-Rod, and the importance of this next homestand in a tough NL West. The hour wraps with historical notes in “On This Day” and the daily “Football at 50” segment.