Ranking every D-backs closer in MLB save stat’s 50th year

Jun 22, 2019, 6:30 AM

On the left, reliever Jose Valverde. In the middle is reliever Byung-Hyun Kim. On the right is reli...

On the left, reliever Jose Valverde. In the middle is reliever Byung-Hyun Kim. On the right is reliever J.J. Putz. (AP photos)

(AP photos)

The Arizona Diamondbacks have had their fair share of closers in their first 21 years as a franchise.

Fifty years ago this year, the “save” became an official statistic for MLB after a sportswriter, Jerome Holtzman, introduced the specific rules for a save in the early 1960s.

Saves are a primary stat used for relievers and they are an indication of how well a pitcher performed in a close game situation with their team winning.

On the 50th anniversary, we rank which closers had the most saves in D-backs history.

1. Jose Valverde (2003-2007): 98 saves in 114 attempts

Valverde has the most saves in D-backs history. He also was their most consistent closer in his time with Arizona. He was signed in 1997 as an amateur free agent out of the Dominican Republic. Valverde got his shot at the major league level in 2003 converting 10 of his first 11 save opportunities that year. Between 2005 and 2006 Valverde had 33 saves in 39 opportunities. Valverde’s best season in Arizona was 2007, during which he earned an All-Star spot and converting 47 of his 54 save opportunities, the most saves in MLB that year. The D-backs went to the postseason in 2007 and Valverde had one save and only allowed one run in both the NLDS and NLCS. In the 2007 offseason, Valverde was traded to the Houston Astros for Chris Burke, Juan Gutierrez and Chad Qualls.

2. J.J. Putz (2011-2014): 83 saves in 97 attempts

Putz is the only D-backs closer to have two seasons of 30 or more saves in a season. After signing as a free agent in 2010, he converted 45 of his 49 save opportunities in 2011, which was 4th-most in MLB. In the playoffs, Putz gave up only one run, which was the Game 5 walk-off single by Milwaukee Brewers outfielder Nyjer Morgan to win the series. In 2012, Putz had a 2.82 ERA and had 32 saves in 37 tries. Putz had minimal closing success in 2013, converting only six of his 11 save opportunities. Putz’s career ended with the D-backs in 2014 and he currently serves as the assistant to the president and CEO Derrick Hall.

3. Matt Mantei (1999-2004): 74 saves in 87 attempts

Mantei has the third-most saves in D-backs history. He was traded by the Marlins in 1999 and helped the D-backs get to the postseason by converting 22 of his 25 save opportunities from July to the end of the season. After an impressive half season, it looked like the D-backs had their closer. However, in the middle of the 2000 season, Mantei injured his elbow. That injury carried into the 2001 season and he eventually needed Tommy John Surgery in April. Mantei had a bounce-back year in 2003 when he picked up 29 saves in 32 opportunities. But 2004 wasn’t the same for Mantei as he picked up only four saves and had an ERA of 11.81.

4. Byung-Hyun Kim (1999-2003, 2007): 70 saves in 89 attempts

Kim was an important part of the D-backs’ 2001 World Series team. Before that run, Kim had 14 saves in 2000 after taking over for the injured Mantei. In 2001, Kim and teammate Bret Prinz got most of the saves that season. But Kim got a majority of them, racking up 19 saves in 23 tries. He was the D-backs closer heading into the postseason and didn’t disappoint in the first two rounds. Kim had three saves and didn’t allow a run in the NLDS and NLCS. However, the World Series was a different story. He allowed five runs and blew saves in Game 4 and Game 5 after giving up a home run in the ninth inning in both games. Despite the dismal end to the postseason for Kim, he was an All-Star in 2002 and had 36 saves in 42 save appearances with a 2.04 ERA. After a successful season, Kim wouldn’t get another save for the D-backs, as he was traded to the Red Sox in the 2003 season for Shea Hillenbrand. Kim returned to the team in 2007 for two games, both of them starts.

5.  Brad Ziegler (2011-2016, 2018): 62 saves in 78 attempts

(AP Photo/Rick Scuteri)

After being traded by the Oakland Athletics in 2011, Ziegler proved to be one of the D-backs’ best relievers. That catapulted him to the closer’s role in 2013 getting 13 saves in 15 opportunities. But 2014 didn’t go as planned. Ziegler only had one save and blew eight other save opportunities that season. However, he recovered in 2015, going 30-for-32 in save opportunities and posting a 1.85 ERA. In half as many games in 2016, Ziegler converted 18 saves in 20 tries. He was traded mid-season to the Boston Red Sox and was brought back to the D-backs in 2018 after being traded by the Miami Marlins.

6. Chad Qualls (2008-2010): 45 saves in 62 attempts

Qualls was acquired in a trade that sent closer Jose Valverde to the Houston Astros in 2007. After becoming a D-back, Qualls had nine saves in 17 opportunities. In 2009, he had 24 saves in 29 tries with a 3.63 ERA. After getting 12 saves in 2010, Qualls was traded to the Tampa Bay Rays.

7. Greg Olson (1998): 44 saves in 57 attempts

After playing for seven different teams, Greg Olson decided to sign with the D-backs in 1998. Olson had 30 saves in 34 attempts and had an ERA of 3.01 as the team’s first-ever closer. In 1999, Olson blew nine saves in 23 attempts, forcing the team to find another closer as it was vying for its first-ever postseason appearance.

8. Brandon Lyon (2005-2008) 42 saves in 58 attempts

Lyon was traded by the Red Sox in 2003 for starter Curt Schilling with the D-backs getting minor leaguer Mike Goss and two pitchers, Casey Fossum and Jorge De La Rosa in return as well. Lyon had 14 saves in 15 attempts in 2005 but blew all seven of his save opportunities the next season. Lyon had his most saves in 2008 when he posted a 4.70 ERA converting 26 of his 31 opportunities before leaving for free agency in 2009.

9. Fernando Rodney (2017): 39 saves in 45 attempts

In his only season with the D-backs, Rodney converted 39 of his 45 save attempts. His ERA in 61 games pitched was 4.23.

10. Addison Reed (2014-2015): 35 saves in 43 attempts

(Photo by Christian Petersen/Getty Images)

In 2013, Reed was acquired by the D-backs for infielder Matt Davidson. Reed had 32 saves in 38 tries in 2014 with a 4.25 ERA. However, in 2015 Reed struggled and only had 3 saves. The D-backs ended up trading Reed in the middle of the season to the New York Mets for starter Matt Koch.

11. Brad Boxberger (2018): 32 saves in 40 attempts

Boxberger had a good start to the first half of the season. He had 24 saves and an ERA of 3.06. However, the second half of the season was completely different. Boxberger only had eight saves and an ERA of 7.00.

12. Juan Gutierrez (2009-2011): 24 saves in 28 attempts

Gutierrez was part of the trade that sent Jose Valverde to the Astros for Chris Burke and Brandon Lyon in 2007. In 2009, Gutierrez had nine saves in 10 tries. Despite an ERA of 5.08 in 2010, Gutierrez saved 15 games in 17 opportunities. He was later released in 2011 by the D-backs after a disappointing season.

13. David Hernandez (2011-2015, 2017): 18 saves in 30 attempts

Hernandez was traded by the Orioles in 2010 for infielder Mark Reynolds. His most saves in a season came in 2011 when he picked up 11 saves in 14 opportunities. After that season, Hernandez had other save opportunities despite not being a closer for the team.

14. Greg Aquino (2004-2006): 17 saves in 22 attempts

After being signed as an amateur free agent in 1995, Aquino made his major league debut in 2004. He had a good start to his career converting 16 of his 19 save opportunities with a 3.06 ERA. However, after that season he was only able to get one more save. In 2006, the D-backs traded him to the Brewers for pitchers Doug Davis and Dana Eveland and right fielder Dave Krynzel.

15. Heath Bell (2013): 15 saves in 22 attempts

(Photo by Christian Petersen/Getty Images)

Bell was involved in a 3-team trade that sent Chris Young to the Athletics and the Marlins sent Bell to the D-backs. Despite having three straight All-Star seasons with the San Deigo Padres from 2009-2011, Bell’s time with the D-backs was a disappointment. He was only able to get 15 saves in 22 opportunities and had an ERA of 4.11. Bell was traded to Rays after his only season with the D-backs in 2013.


Arizona Diamondbacks

Kevin Durant walking off court...

Dan Bickley

Is this year the worst in Arizona sports history?

After the Coyotes left, the Suns were swept, ASU hit rock bottom and the D-backs' bad luck, is this year the worst in Arizona sports history?

7 hours ago

Ketel Marte #4 of the Arizona Diamondbacks hits an RBI single against the Philadelphia Phillies dur...

Kellan Olson

Diamondbacks’ Ketel Marte jumps to 1st in NL All-Star voting at 2B

Arizona Diamondbacks second baseman Ketel Marte has moved up to first in National League All-Star voting at second base.

13 hours ago


Arizona Sports Video

Video: Bickley Blast: Could this year be the worst in Arizona sports history?

Bickley Blast: Could this year be the worst in Arizona sports history? Dan Bickley argues it might.

17 hours ago

Starter Zac Gallen...

Kevin Zimmerman

D-backs pitcher Zac Gallen ‘feeling pretty good’ ahead of Monday live BP

Zac Gallen knows the Arizona Diamondbacks will protect his long-term health even if he comes out cleanly from a live bullpen session.

17 hours ago

Malcolm Moore...

Arizona Sports

Diamondbacks mock drafts roundup: College World Series, MLB combine wind down

A fresh batch of MLB mock drafts has the Diamondbacks going in different directions with the No. 29 overall pick.

1 day ago

Philadelphia Phillies pitcher Cristopher Sánchez threw seven shutout innings as they take the win ...

Bailey Leasure

Diamondbacks’ bats go quiet in series loss to the Phillies

Philadelphia Phillies pitcher Cristopher Sánchez threw seven shutout innings as they take the win and series over the Diamondbacks.

2 days ago

Ranking every D-backs closer in MLB save stat’s 50th year