Diamondbacks shifting to closer by committee after Mark Melancon’s struggles

Aug 5, 2022, 3:55 PM | Updated: 4:51 pm
Mark Melancon #34 of the Arizona Diamondbacks walks off the mound after giving up a walk off two ru...
Mark Melancon #34 of the Arizona Diamondbacks walks off the mound after giving up a walk off two run home run to Jack Suwinski #65 of the Pittsburgh Pirates in the ninth inning at PNC Park on June 4, 2022 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Justin Berl/Getty Images)
(Photo by Justin Berl/Getty Images)

It has been a rough go for Arizona Diamondbacks closer Mark Melancon this season, something manager Torey Lovullo said he is “very well aware” of when he joined Arizona Sports’ Burns & Gambo on Friday.

Lovullo shortly after in his pregame press availability said the club will be shifting to a closer by committee approach, with Melancon, Ian Kennedy and Joe Mantiply among the names that will be considered each night.

“We’re gonna (go) back into a situation where we don’t have one closer at this point,” Lovullo said. “Had a discussion with Mark about making this move and he understood. He didn’t necessarily like it but he understood (it’s) for the good of the team. If it was a decision I was making then he was going to support it.

“For right now, it’ll be a fluid situation who it will be. It will be undetermined. It will mostly be matchup based.”

Lovullo reiterated that Melancon will still close some games but just won’t be the sole name in that spot anymore.

Kennedy received the ball for the D-backs’ last save situation in a 6-3 win over the Cleveland Guardians on Tuesday and struck out the side.

This, however, came after Melancon pitched two straight days, so it still isn’t 100% clear if that was a full role change or just a one-time deal.

Melancon has already set the franchise record for most losses by a reliever with 10, besting the previous high of eight from Chad Qualls (2008) and Aaron Heilman (’10), per Baseball-Reference.

He has notoriously struggled this season in non-save situations when Lovullo has brought the righty in during a tie game.

That happened first on Sunday, with Melancon taking the loss against the Atlanta Braves by giving up a run in a 0-0 game for a ninth-inning walk-off.

Melancon then came in for a save opportunity in Cleveland one day later with a 5-4 lead over the Guardians in the 10th inning, only to give up a run to extend the game. From there, Melancon stayed in at a 5-5 scoreline for the following inning and lost in another walk-off situation.

With Melancon’s collapses noted, both he and Kennedy are tied for the team lead in blown saves at three apiece while Melancon’s 14 saves top Kennedy’s five. Mantiply is the only other D-back reliever with a save (2) and he’s also blown three of them.

Arizona, of course, invested in its bullpen this offseason with a two-year, $14 million contract for Melancon and then Kennedy as well on a one-year deal for up to $4.75 million.

The D-backs return to Chase Field with a 6:40 p.m. first pitch against the Colorado Rockies you can hear on 98.7 FM.

Penguin Air

Arizona Diamondbacks

AMARILLO, TEXAS - MAY 22: Outfielder Stone Garrett #11 of the Amarillo Sod Poodles stands on deck d...
Arizona Sports

D-backs call up OF Stone Garrett, option Seth Beer, DFA Paul Fry

The D-backs announced OF Stone Garrett was called up from Triple-A Reno while the team optioned 1B Seth Beer and DFA'd LHP Paul Fry.
22 hours ago
(Screenshot/Bally Sports)...
Arizona Sports

Bally Sports+ streaming service announces launch date in September

Bally Sports announced the launch of a new streaming service for the Suns, Coyotes and regional college sports coming Sept. 26.
22 hours ago
Alek Thomas #5 of the Arizona Diamondbacks can not catch a home run ball hit by Brandon Crawford #3...
Kellan Olson

Ian Kennedy blows save, gives up walk-off HR in D-backs’ loss to Giants

The Diamondbacks were one strike away from a win over the Giants on before Brandon Crawford's two-run walk-off homer.
2 days ago
Rodolfo Castro #14 of the Pittsburgh Pirates slides into third base as his cell phone falls out of ...
Associated Press

Pirates’ Castro suspended 1 game for phone goof vs. Diamondbacks

Pirates infielder Rodolfo Castro was suspended for one game by Major League Baseball on Tuesday for having a cellphone in his back pocket.
2 days ago
Infielder Nick Ahmed #13 of the Arizona Diamondbacks whips the ball to first base after tagging out...
Kellan Olson

Diamondbacks’ Lovullo expects SS Nick Ahmed to miss rest of season

Arizona Diamondbacks manager Torey Lovullo said on Burns & Gambo Tuesday he thinks shortstop Nick Ahmed will miss the rest of the season.
2 days ago
Corbin Carroll #7 of the Arizona Diamondbacks prepares for batting practice prior to the 2022 Siriu...
Arizona Sports

D-backs’ Corbin Carroll rises to No. 1 in prospect rankings for ESPN’s McDaniel

Arizona Diamondbacks prospect Corbin Carroll's stature has grown as quickly as he's recovered from a shoulder injury.
2 days ago
Diamondbacks shifting to closer by committee after Mark Melancon’s struggles