Panthers WR Tetairoa McMillan flashes but does not explode vs. Cardinals

GLENDALE — An early-game injury at cornerback could have spelled doom for the Arizona Cardinals, but they held on through two more late ones against the Carolina Panthers in a 27-22 win.

Max Melton (knee) did not return after hurting himself in the mid-first quarter, while late knocks for Garrett Williams (knee) and Will Johnson (groin) left the Cardinals in major trouble for the last drive of the game.

The relevance was heightened considering who those corners were tasked with stopping.

No. 8 overall pick Tetairoa McMillan has arrived in the NFL instantly looking the part of a top wideout, with the former Arizona Wildcat having his second straight strong afternoon to begin his career. But despite his six catches for 100 yards, it was not as loud of a performance for McMillan as it easily could have been, a positive for Arizona’s DB room to take into Week 3.

Melton was injured on the tackle of a McMillan catch that is exactly the one you worry about, as a brief outside-inside move saw him seamlessly breeze by Melton and into a gap of the middle of the field, where he picked up a total of 40 yards on the reception.

Just a few plays later, fifth-round rookie Denzel Burke checked in to play on the outside, and McMillan roasted him in a short-yardage route on the sideline, spinning by to gain a first down.

It was an ominous play that teased a theme developing, but from that point on, McMillan wasn’t all that involved. It was 10 targets for the rookie, and he should have been closer to 20 than 10 considering the context of how the game unfolded.

McMillan is the prototypical receiver from a skill set standpoint that Arizona will struggle with this year at 6-foot-5 with dynamic ball skills.

Only Johnson at 6-foot-2 has a real shot at competing with him in the air, where McMillan shows incredible feel at just 22 years old. While this was only his second ever NFL game, McMillan’s fundamentals are raved about, to the point where he will establish himself as one of the better wide receivers immediately and could go to even further heights if Carolina’s offensive ecosystem can find a way to consistently involve him.

Arizona did not shadow McMillan with any specific corner, and while sprinkling in double-teams at times, it was was not an every-down type of showering. He was used as a decoy fairly often, sent to a specific part of the Cardinals’ zone coverage to suck in multiple defenders. When McMillan wasn’t, he was getting open. Carolina quarterback Bryce Young, however, was under pressure or not seeing his star wideout enough to capitalize.

The former is a large point of differentiation. The Cardinals’ pass rush legitimately factoring into games could be a great equalizer to an injury-ravaged cornerbacks room, even more so if any injury is serious. It faded in a major way across the second half before relocating a spark while the Panthers had a chance to absolutely steal the game late after a successful onside kick, keeping McMillan out of the picture.

When the pressure didn’t come, Carolina had its chances.

In the second quarter, McMillan burned Williams up the sidelines on what would have been a go-ball touchdown had Young waited an extra second and not taken the easy check-down toss for five yards. Young did have enough time in the pocket on that instance, which could have been a play that shifted the momentum before things got out of hand. Later on in the mid-fourth quarter, McMillan broke free over the middle of the field toward the endzone but Young again took a check-down too early, and that one earned some frustrated body language from McMillan.

That was about it in terms of close calls, a win for the Cardinals.

Burke had good coverage on a fade toward the endzone in the third quarter, while a two-point conversion attempt later in the drive drew a pass interference call on Burke.

In the early fourth quarter, McMillan had a preposterous one-handed snag over Burke toward the sideline, just landing out of bounds on the signature example of him at his best.

Tetairoa McMillan’s near catches are becoming a highlight reel by themselves pic.twitter.com/KWt6Ts7nd4

— Nate Tice (@Nate_Tice) September 14, 2025

The majority of the second half featured McMillan in single coverage but Carolina wasn’t looking to exploit that too often, lacking the infrastructure to execute to that degree. It’s something to keep an eye on when better teams match up with Arizona and have the offensive stability to try that with a great wideout. Arizona clouded up that space a bit more on the last drive of the game, which also included Burke getting a holding call on McMillan that extended the game after a fourth-down stop.

Related

Rapid reactions: Cardinals off to 2-0 start after holding off Panthers' comebackCardinals narrowly escape another Carolina catastropheCardinals CB Garrett Williams helped to locker room vs. PanthersCardinals CB Max Melton carted to locker room with knee injury vs. PanthersSam Darnold injured in NFL season opener, Seahawks play Cardinals in Week 2Cardinals-Chargers injury report: Jeremiyah Love, Garrett Williams limited ahead of Week 1