DOUG

Is cheating worth it?

May 12, 2015, 12:56 PM | Updated: 12:56 pm

...

The New England Patriots are the most successful North American sports franchise of the 21st century.

The New England Patriots have been caught violating more rules to secure a competitive advantage than any other North American sports franchise in the 21st century.

Is it worth it?

Would the joy of watching ASU march down the field in Glendale for a Championship Game-winning touchdown be worth the NCAA death penalty?

How much would you care if the Arizona Diamondbacks completely changed course and started signing thugs on their way to a second World Series Championship?

The Minnesota Timberwolves lost five first-round picks for salary cap violations at the beginning of the century and have yet to recover. If they had won a championship, would you have wondered why the Suns didn’t do the same thing despite almost 10 years of futility for the T-Wolves ever since?

It matters how the game is played. The rules must be consistent across the board. Look at every other NFL franchise. Why is it that the New York Giants rise and fall while New England never does? Are the Patriots clearly a better franchise than Baltimore or do the Ravens just follow the rules more closely? If Peyton Manning can only win one Super Bowl when playing by the rules but could have had two more rings by lowering his conscious, where would he rank all-time?

No one knows how much the cheating of the Patriots led to Super Bowl victories. It’s impossible to quantify what methods made New England better. Only the naive would claim every other team in the NFL toes the line in every situation. Maybe if New England never recorded opposing coach signals and systematically circumvented the rules to deflate footballs to create a competitive advantage, the Patriots would still be the most successful North American sports franchise this century.

If you think teams that do things the right way need to be applauded, shouldn’t you be going to more games to support our local teams who are never involved in issues of competitive imbalance yet still play in front of abysmal crowds? If you don’t think Kraft, Belichick and Brady did anything wrong, why aren’t you screaming at the Cardinals to sign more LeGarrette Blounts, place cameras in opposing teams’ hotel meeting rooms or deflate more footballs?

Tom Brady…four rings.

Tom Brady…four games.

The Patriots have proven that if 31 teams play by one set of rules and they don’t, they are the winningest organization in the history of the salary cap era of the NFL. If “cheaters never win” and “winners never cheat,” there’s only one thing the Patriots can be: losers. So, why doesn’t it feel that way?

Doug

Houston Astros starting pitcher Corbin Martin throws against the Seattle Mariners during the first ...

Doug Franz

Diving deeper with the D-backs on the trades they made

I talked to different members of the Diamondbacks’ front office tonight. It was made clear to me they never looked at themselves as a typical seller.

5 years ago

The Arizona Diamondbacks from left, Jon Jay, A.J. Pollock, Nick Ahmed celebrate the team's 7-1 win ...

Doug Franz

Facing a daunting September, D-backs need to get hot in August

The Diamondbacks desperately needed their April domination to create a buffer for their collapse in May. They might need the same in August for September.

6 years ago

Baltimore Orioles' Manny Machado (13) celebrates in the dugout his home run off Chicago White Sox's...

Doug Franz

Get Manny: For a playoff berth, D-backs need to go after Machado

The Arizona Diamondbacks are wasting time. Every day Manny Machado is in another team's lineup is another day playing a game of chicken the D-backs will lose.

6 years ago

Arizona State's Kimani Lawrence (14), along with Colorado's McKinley Wright IV (25) and Namon Wrigh...

Doug Franz

ASU’s NCAA Tournament resume pokes holes in selection process

If Arizona State is included in the NCAA tournament field, the system is flawed. If ASU is not included in the field, the system is run by hypocrites.

6 years ago

(Matt Layman/Arizona Sports)...

Doug Franz

Thoughts from Newsmakers Week, Day 3: Majerle and Anderson in studio

GCU coach Dan Majerle, Suns President/CEO Jason Rowley, Suns VP of Basketball Ops James Jones and ASU AD Ray Anderson joined Doug & Wolf on Newsmakers Week.

6 years ago

(AP Photo/Ron Schwane)...

Tom Kuebel

Kerwynn Williams plays through pain and brings stability to the offense

Kerwynn Williams provided a bright spot in the Cardinals backfield and helped propel the team to their sixth win of the season by beating the Titans 12-7. 

6 years ago

Is cheating worth it?