The understandable yearly tradition of NFL player disdain for Madden ratings

Jul 15, 2020, 8:25 PM

This image provided by EA Sports shows the cover of the Madden 21 video game, featuring Baltimore R...

This image provided by EA Sports shows the cover of the Madden 21 video game, featuring Baltimore Ravens quarterback Lamar Jackson, which will be released in August. (Photo courtesy of EA Sports via AP)

(Photo courtesy of EA Sports via AP)

Athletes have bad memories. They forget how good they have it.

They take charter planes to luxury buses idling on a tarmac. They are dropped off on doorsteps of opulent hotels. They have personal chefs at home and a permanent hand in life’s candy jar.

But there are downfalls and pitfalls, even for the absurdly rich and famous. Like Madden ratings, if you’re a NFL player.

Imagine how awful that could be in our respective lives.


Writing ability: 99

Insight: 97

Speaking ability: 90

Likeability: 72


Sources: 99

Self-promotion: 99

Stamina: 89

Speaking ability: 71 (*87 if speaking Italian)

Seriously. Imagine having your own video game persona. You’ve probably made up a few over the years. Mine were enormous distortions of the truth, configured to kick major backside on digital golf courses, football fields and baseball stadiums across America.

Now, imagine that digital persona competing in your actual profession. Like comprehensive Madden ratings for waiters, doctors and those who sell insurance for a living.

It could get very unnerving. Especially in businesses without batting averages, where subjectivity reigns, where insecurities and paranoia thrive, where greatness is in the eye of the beholder.


Professionalism: 99

Versatility: 99

Recognizable hooks/catch-phrases: 60


Observation skills: 99

Likeability: 96

Rhythm guitar: 75


Tone: 99

Charm: 99

Empathy for referees: 3

We would all recoil at the numbers assigned to our weaknesses by others. Especially if we felt slighted. Which would inevitably happen because all want to believe the best versions of ourselves are the versions that everyone else see on a daily basis.

Alas. It doesn’t work that way.

And sometimes, those in charge of the ratings are way off.

Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray recently took offense to his speed qualities in “Madden 21”, where he was assigned an underwhelming 91 rating. Ravens star Lamar Jackson was the best in that category, well above Murray with a 96.

“Na,” Murray tweeted.

Na, indeed.

Meanwhile, Murray bristled at the quarterback rating assigned to Packers star Aaron Rodgers (89 overall), who ranked sixth among his profession, behind the fast-diminishing Tom Brady.

“So disrespectful to AR,” he tweeted.

Especially with over 10 million people playing Madden football every year.

The annual unveiling of Madden ratings causes a lot of ill will. Players have threatened to boycott the Madden video game franchise in the past. Bruised egos always represent the first injuries of the football season.

Jackson seemed genuinely hurt by his overall rating of 94, which ranked third-best among quarterbacks and far behind the Chiefs’ Patrick Mahomes. Even though Jackson is the reigning MVP of the NFL and on the cover of “Madden 21”.

It sounds petty, but put yourselves in their position. It’s hard recognizing the truth. Especially when it’s false.

Presented By
Western Governors University

Dan Bickley


Arizona Sports Video

Video: Bickley Blast: March Madness nears but the Phoenix Suns are more of a March Mystery as they enter the home stretch

College basketball has March Madness, but Dan Bickley explains how the Phoenix Suns are more of the NBA's March Mystery heading into the final home stretch of the regular season.

1 day ago

President John Mara of the New York Giants speaks with President Michael Bidwill of the Arizona Car...

Dan Bickley

The 2024 NFLPA report card grades don’t disappoint

The NFL Players Association released their annual report cards for each of the league's franchises this week and the grades don't disappoint.

1 day ago

The Arizona Diamondbacks celebrate winning Game Seven of the Championship Series against the Philad...

Dan Bickley

Diamondbacks’ young guns ready to apply invaluable postseason experience

For a young and blossoming team like the Diamondbacks, the value of a second-place finish can be impossible to quantify.

3 days ago

Presented By...

Arizona Sports Video

Video: Bickley Blast: Is the Kyler Murray love for real?

In this edition of the Bickley Blast, Dan Bickley reflects back on the history with the Arizona Cardinals and quarterback Kyler Murray, and if the latest social media love from the team to Murray is genuine. Bickley & Marotta also talk about Phase 2 with the Cardinals, and what they need to do to have success in the 2024 NFL Draft.

3 days ago

Kyler Murray celebrates with Monti Ossenfort postgame...

Dan Bickley

Pressure’s on 3 Arizona Cardinals as renovation enters new phase

Renovation of the Arizona Cardinals has entered Phase Two. It's time for Monti Ossenfort, Michael Bidwill and Kyler Murray to step up.

4 days ago

Presented By...

Arizona Sports Video

Video: Bickley Blast: Is Kyler Murray’s future set with the Arizona Cardinals?

With reports of the Arizona Cardinals doing their homework on several quarterbacks coming out in the 2024 NFL Draft, Dan Bickley wonders what the future holds for Kyler Murray in the Desert.

4 days ago

The understandable yearly tradition of NFL player disdain for Madden ratings