For baseball pundits, D-backs and Padres will race for 2nd place

Jul 22, 2020, 10:03 AM | Updated: Jul 23, 2020, 6:47 am
Eduardo Escobar #5 of the Arizona Diamondbacks hits a double during the the fourth inning of a base...
Eduardo Escobar #5 of the Arizona Diamondbacks hits a double during the the fourth inning of a baseball game against the San Diego Padres at Petco Park September 21, 2019 in San Diego, California. (Photo by Denis Poroy/Getty Images)
(Photo by Denis Poroy/Getty Images)

The Arizona Diamondbacks had a hard time keeping up with the Dodgers in Los Angeles on Sunday and Monday.

Sure, they were exhibition games and not indicative of regular season effort and the pitchers weren’t who the Diamondbacks expect to start, and so on. That’s all true. But the baseball analysts have loudly shouted into the digital ether that the Los Angeles Dodgers are not only the favorite in the NL West but are one of the best teams in baseball.

ESPN even debated whether the Yankees or Dodgers are baseball’s better “superteam.”

So where does that leave Arizona?

By most accounts, Arizona is at least one of the favorites to be the runner-up in the division, with some expecting the San Diego Padres to put up a good fight.

The love for the Dodgers is warranted and obvious. A lineup with Mookie Betts, reigning NL MVP Cody Bellinger, Corey Seager, Justin Turner and Max Muncy among other heavy hitters is good enough, but when combined with a rotation that features Clayton Kershaw and Walker Buehler at the top, there’s plenty reason for optimism. They also have seven straight postseason appearances going into this year.

The argument for the Diamondbacks is multi-faceted: Ketel Marte returns after finishing fourth in NL MVP voting. Acclaimed starter Madison Bumgarner joins as the team’s new ace. Starling Marte adds a proven bat to a lineup that already has some pop, and the pitching depth across the board is some of the best out there.

The Padres again boast a lineup with some star power, with names like Manny Machado, Eric Hosmer, Will Myers, Tommy Pham and Fernando Tatis Jr. Kirby Yates highlights a bullpen that has a chance to be one of the best in the National League. The question is the rotation: After Chris Paddack at the top, will it be enough to compete with the starters that Arizona and Los Angeles have?

Here’s what some of the experts are saying going into Friday’s D-backs opener, which coincidentally is in San Diego.


A panel of 32 ESPN baseball experts unanimously picked the Dodgers to win the division. Writer David Schoenfield sees the Diamondbacks as his runner-up pick.

The Padres are a chic pick, but I’ll go with the Diamondbacks, who have an excellent defensive team anchored by shortstop Nick Ahmed, a star in Ketel Marte and a potentially top rotation with Madison Bumgarner, Robbie Ray, Zac Gallen, Luke Weaver and Merrill Kelly.

The Diamondbacks were tied with the Mets as the second-most popular pick to be an NL Wild Card team. The Nationals got the most votes there.


Three out of six panelists chose the Diamondbacks as the second-place finisher in the NL West this year, while the other three chose the Padres.

Two panelists chose the Diamondbacks as a participant in the Wild Card game, with one having them winning that game and one having them losing it.


The Ringer’s Michael Baumann has the Padres at 19th and the Diamondbacks at 21st on his power rankings.

“[The Padres’] bullpen is going to be unbelievably good. Emilio Pagán, who arrived via trade from Tampa Bay, was nearly unhittable last year, and he’ll be the Padres’ third-best reliever. Pomeranz has reinvented himself as a shutdown lefty out of the pen. And last season, closer Kirby Yates held opponents to a .262 slugging percentage, struck out nearly eight batters for every walk, and posted a 1.19 ERA.

I hope Yates gets more notoriety in 2020, but I worry that with Pagán and Pomeranz ahead of him in the bullpen, everyone will just assume the Padres are going to win every game they lead after six innings and turn off the TV.

Of the Diamondbacks, Baumann wrote:

There’s a lot to like about this D-backs team, and in a more winnable division, they’d be a realistic playoff contender. But the NL West is going to be very tough to navigate until the Dodgers fall off.

Arizona Diamondbacks

Arizona Diamondbacks' Carson Kelly (18) is greeted by Christian Walker (53) after scoring against t...
Jake Anderson

D-backs tender contracts to arbitration-eligible Kelly, Walker, Weaver

The Arizona Diamondbacks have tendered contracts to arbitration-eligible players: C Carson Kelly, 1B Christian Walker and RHP Luke Weaver.
1 day ago
Arizona Diamondbacks manager Torey Lovullo watches from the dugout during the sixth inning of the t...
Arizona Sports

Diamondbacks fill out rest of coaching staff around Torey Lovullo

The D-backs announced five additions to its restructured staff, naming three assistant hitting coaches and two assistant pitching coaches.
1 day ago
Tampa Bay Rays' Jordan Luplow celebrates in the dugout after his grand slam during the first inning...
Wills Rice

Arizona Diamondbacks acquire outfielder Jordan Luplow from Rays

The Diamondbacks have acquired outfielder Jordan Luplow from the Tampa Bay Rays in return for infielder Ronny Simon.
5 days ago
Kyler Murray #1 of the Arizona Cardinals celebrates after Eno Benjamin #26 (not pictured) scores a ...
Kevin Zimmerman

What Arizona sports fans can be thankful for in 2021

The spirit of Thanksgiving is about the gratefulness that comes with not having it all, but enjoying the some that you do have.
2 days ago
Kyle Nelson #30 of the Cleveland Indians pitches against the Minnesota Twins during the ninth innin...
Jake Anderson

D-backs claim left-hander Kyle Nelson from Cleveland Guardians

LHP Kyle Nelson has pitched 10.1 innings over 11 appearances in his two years in the MLB, all of which have come out of the bullpen.
7 days ago
San Diego Padres relief pitcher Kirby Yates works against an Arizona Diamondbacks batter during the...
Arizona Sports

Report: D-backs ‘in mix’ to sign reliever Kirby Yates

The Diamondbacks are among six teams in the running to sign 2019 MLB All-Star and free agent Kirby Yates, reports Ken Rosenthal.
8 days ago
For baseball pundits, D-backs and Padres will race for 2nd place