D-backs get mostly positive marks for addition of Madison Bumgarner

Dec 16, 2019, 11:31 AM
Madison Bumgarner #40 of the San Francisco Giants during their MLB game against the Los Angeles Dod...
Madison Bumgarner #40 of the San Francisco Giants during their MLB game against the Los Angeles Dodgers at Oracle Park on September 27, 2019 in San Francisco, California. (Photo by Robert Reiners/Getty Images)
(Photo by Robert Reiners/Getty Images)

The Arizona Diamondbacks’ reported acquisition of Madison Bumgarner has some pros and cons. But in large part, the reaction to it has been positive.

It’s not the splash the D-backs made in December of 2015 by signing Zack Greinke to a deal worth $206.5 million, but it’s still the signing of a longtime ace who won 2014 World Series MVP. Not bad.

Last year, Bumgarner had a career-worst 3.90 ERA in 34 starts, owning a 1.127 WHIP. Those are fine numbers, but not ace-caliber stats. He did pitch 207.2 innings, though, which was a good sight to see after he pitched only 38 starts in 2017 and 2018 combined.

Two well-known baseball voices, USA Today’s Bob Nightengale and ESPN’s Tim Kurkjian, each joined Doug & Wolf on 98.7 FM Arizona’s Sports Station on Monday, the day after the Bumgarner signing was reported. Both gave largely positive reviews of GM Mike Hazen’s decision.

“He’s better than anyone else on your pitching staff, which is great,” Kurkjian said. “You didn’t have to trade anybody to get him. He’s only 30 years old. He’s as big and as strong and as mean as any pitcher you’ll meet. He hates hitters. He hates the opposition. If someone takes their time running around the bases, he’s going to hear it from Madison Bumgarner, and I like that throwback quality to him. And I think he will bring an edge to the Diamondbacks. Maybe they don’t need it, but he will bring it, I promise. And he wanted to pitch there.

“Even though five years is a lot for a pitcher and $85 million is a lot for a pitcher, I thought he would get more. And with all those other teams that had interest, including the Dodgers, you made sure he didn’t go there. So all of that suggests that this was a good move for the Diamondbacks.”

Five years and $85 million amounts to an average of $17 million per season. Cole Hamels, who is five years older than Bumgarner and had a comparable ERA last year (3.81), got $18 million on a one-year deal with the Braves.

Nightengale had similar remarks to Doug & Wolf.

“I’m surprised he didn’t get more money from somebody else, I really was,” Nightengale said. “Considering all the other contracts, I figured he’d at least get 100 (million dollars).”

He noted that Bumgarner had four-year offers from at least two other teams — the Dodgers and the Giants — but the D-backs were ultimately willing to go the fifth year. It’s also worth noting, as pointed out by The Athletic’s Ken Rosenthal, that because of tax implications, a California team would’ve had to offer north of $100 million for Bumgarner to make the same amount of net income as he would in Arizona on an $85 million deal.

That being said, it’s isn’t as if there’s no downside. Bumgarner is entering his 12th MLB season and is coming off the worst ERA mark of his career. As ESPN’s Buster Olney pointed out, Bumgarner’s home/road splits, fastball effectiveness and hard hits against are all trending in the wrong direction.

“He’s got a lot of mileage on that arm,” Kurkjian said. “I’ve seen all the studies of guys who throw a lot of innings in their late teens and early 20s, like Felix Hernandez, for instance, and eventually that arm wears you down. You just lose the life, you lose your fastball, you lose your velocity and we’re seeing some of that in Bumgarner. I’m not saying in any way that he’s the pitcher he was five years ago — he’s not. But he’s still pretty darn good.”

If it doesn’t work out for the D-backs, well … it’s not $206.5 million.

“In this case, the only thing you risk is the money,” Nightengale said. “But the money’s not that great. If it doesn’t work out the last couple of years, it’s not the end of the world.”

Penguin Air

Penguin Air

Arizona Diamondbacks

Arizona Diamondbacks manager Torey Lovullo gives a fist bump to Daulton Varsho after their 5-2 win ...
Associated Press

Offense pops in 5th inning and Kelly stops Giants again in D-backs win

Arizona right-hander Merrill Kelly kept up his mastery of the San Francisco Giants this season, pitching the D-backs to a win Saturday night.
1 day ago
Sergio Alcantara #43 of the Arizona Diamondbacks throws to first for an out during the fifth inning...
Kellan Olson

Arizona Diamondbacks lose to Giants, fall in 9th inning for 2nd straight night

For the second straight night, the Arizona Diamondbacks lost in the ninth inning.
2 days ago
Tommy Henry #47 of the Arizona Diamondbacks pitches during the first inning of the game against the...
Jake Anderson

D-backs recall Tommy Henry, Pavin Smith from Reno; option Tyler Holton

The D-backs made a handful of roster moves on Friday that included LHP Tommy Henry, OF/1B Pavin Smith, LHP Tyler Holton and OF Jake McCarthy.
2 days ago
Zac Gallen #23 of the Arizona Diamondbacks pitches against the Los Angeles Dodgers during the first...
Associated Press

Zac Gallen’s career night spoiled by latest D-backs bullpen loss vs. LAD

Zac Gallen had a career-high 13 strikeouts and 8.0 innings pitched but the Arizona Diamondbacks' bullpen blew another lead in the ninth.
3 days ago
Arizona Diamondbacks starting pitcher Drey Jameson throws to the plate during the first inning of a...
Jordan Leandre

Arizona Diamondbacks throw the numbers out for pitching prospects

Arizona Diamondbacks senior VP and assistant GM Amiel Sawdaye said they have to look more at a Reno pitcher's stuff than their numbers.
3 days ago
Arizona Diamondbacks starting pitcher Madison Bumgarner throws to the plate during the sixth inning...
Associated Press

Madison Bumgarner gets 1st win since July, D-backs beat Dodgers

Madison Bumgarner tossed six innings of one-hit ball, giving him his first win in nearly two months, and the Diamondbacks beat the Dodgers.
4 days ago
D-backs get mostly positive marks for addition of Madison Bumgarner