Should the D-backs want the Phillies in the first round?

Sep 14, 2011, 12:50 AM | Updated: 2:12 am

PHOENIX – The Arizona Diamondbacks pretty much have the NL West division locked up and heading for the playoffs.

Now the attention has turned to whether or not Arizona can finish with a better record than the Brewers which would mean the D-backs wouldn’t have to face the vaunted Philadelphia Phillies in the first round of the playoffs.

However, it might work out better for Arizona to face Philadelphia in the first round.

Look, no doubt the Phillies’ team with their starting rotation of Roy Halladay, Cliff Lee and Cole Hamels will be the toughest team for anybody to defeat in the National League, but that’s why it would be better for the D-backs to play them in the first round.

If the Phillies are the best team, do you think Arizona has a better chance of beating them three out of five times or four out of seven games?

Over a longer period of time, the better team will usually rise to the top and Arizona would have a better chance to knock them off if they have to defeat them the fewest amount of times.

Sure, Milwaukee could upset the Phillies in the first round and Arizona would never have to play them, but how many people really see that happening.

It may not matter as the D-backs may end up with the second seed in the National League and draw the more favorable match-up in the Atlanta Braves in the first round, but most likely the Phillies will still be waiting for them in the second round.

I would rather see the D-backs face the Phillies right off the bat when Arizona can have their rotation set up how they want it against what would be their greatest challenge.

Arizona Diamondbacks

Corbin Carroll #7 of the Arizona Diamondbacks hits the ball during the first inning of the Spring T...
Alex Weiner

Five of the D-backs’ Cactus League standouts

Corbin Carroll and Gabriel Moreno were amongst the top performers for the Arizona Diamondbacks during Cactus League games.
16 hours ago
Kyle Lewis #1 of the Arizona Diamondbacks hits a home run during the first inning of the Spring Tra...
Alex Weiner

D-backs OF Kyle Lewis focused on hitting his marks in stout spring

Arizona Diamondbacks outfielder Kyle Lewis got off to a late start playing in spring training games, but he caught fire quickly. 
2 days ago
(D-backs Give Back photo)...
Wills Rice

D-backs raise $3.2 million for charity at Evening on the Diamond fundraiser

The Arizona Diamondbacks held their annual Evening on the Diamond Fundraiser on Saturday at Chase Field and raised $3.2 million for charity.
2 days ago
Ryne Nelson (Arizona Sports/Alex Weiner)...
Wills Rice

Report: Ryne Nelson wins D-backs’ No. 5 starting rotation spot, Jameson to bullpen

The D-backs will be moving forward with RHP Ryne Nelson as the team's No. 5 starter in the rotation,'s Steve Gilbert reported Sunday.
2 days ago
Arizona Diamondbacks right fielder Pavin Smith throws during an MLB spring training baseball practi...
Wills Rice

D-backs OF Pavin Smith, INF Emmanuel Rivera optioned to Triple-A Reno

The Arizona Diamondbacks announced Sunday that outfielder Pavin Smith and infielder Emmanuel Rivera were optioned to Triple-A Reno.
2 days ago
C Jose Herrera

With Carson Kelly beginning the season on the IL, Herrera has an opportunity for ad...
Alex Weiner

D-backs opt for familiarity with backup catcher Jose Herrera

Jose Herrera and P.J. Higgins were the two prime competitors for the Diamondbacks' backup catcher role after Carson Kelly's injury.
2 days ago
Should the D-backs want the Phillies in the first round?