Kevin Kolb’s divisive Arizona stint conjures Leinart flashbacks

Mar 15, 2013, 4:05 PM | Updated: 4:42 pm

So the Kevin Kolb era has come to an end in the Valley of the Sun — if two injury-plagued seasons can constitute an era, that is.

Give the Arizona Cardinals credit, though. Knowing they had to bring in a franchise quarterback on the heels of a disastrous 2010 season that saw Derek Anderson and Max Hall stink up the joint, they targeted Kolb, traded for him and signed him to a fat five-year, $63 million deal.

And from the minute the ink dried on the contract, Kolb’s mere presence divided the Cardinal fan base. Supporters of the team split like a group of teenage girls waiting in line to see the latest Twilight Movie. “Team Kolb” and “Team Skelton” became keywords for the next two seasons of Cardinals football.

Hell, Kolb got booed in a mini-camp practice. By his own team’s fans!

Many who denounced Kolb while he was here will relish the opportunity to sum up his Cardinal tenure in two words — “Kolb sucked.”

Here we go again.

Kevin Kolb didn’t “suck” as the quarterback for the Arizona Cardinals. In games that he started, Arizona went 6-8. His touchdown-to-interception ratio was a respectable 17-to-11. His passer rating was 83.2 — again, very respectable. In fact, of the 40 NFL quarterbacks who have started ten or more games over the last two seasons, Kolb is 21st in quarterback rating. That’s a figure better than Chicago’s Jay Cutler, Philadelphia’s Michael Vick, Tampa Bay’s Josh Freeman, St. Louis’ Sam Bradford and Minnesota’s Christian Ponder, just to name a few.

What did “suck” was his luck. Turf toe injuries, like the one that sidelined Kolb for four weeks in 2011, happen. Freak concussions, like the one he suffered when the back of his head was struck by San Francisco linebacker Ahmad Brooks’ knee, don’t happen often.

Another freakish injury — this one to his ribs — ended a once-promising 2012 season for him and his team. The Cardinals were 4-1 at the time of the injury and finished 5-11.

I certainly don’t believe Kolb “sucked” while he wore Cardinal red, but there’s still a lot of mystery surrounding his future in the league. The above numbers do indicate that when he’s healthy, Kolb is more than serviceable. And that’s all the Cardinals really needed to win games in 2012 — a serviceable signal caller who wouldn’t cripple the team with turnovers and mistakes. After his injury, the Cardinals were saddled with John Skelton and Ryan Lindley, who crippled the team with turnovers and mistakes.

Kolb is, in a lot of ways, Matt Leinart Part II.

Leinart, of course, was the Cardinals’ quarterback of the future when he was drafted back in 2006 and enjoyed a pretty solid rookie campaign on a bad football team. He struggled to maintain control of the starting position — but then again, Kurt Warner was on the roster.

The former USC Heisman Trophy winner was cut following Warner’s retirement in 2010 by then-head coach Ken Whisenhunt despite completing 78.6 percent of his passes and posting a quarterback rating of 104.61 in four preseason games.

Leinart wasn’t Whisenhunt’s guy. It was former head coach Dennis Green who was instrumental in nabbing the quarterback with the 10th overall selection of the 2006 NFL Draft. Whisenhunt had a built-in excuse not to choose Leinart as his starter, and ultimately cut him.

Kolb is not Bruce Arians’ guy, so he too has a built-in excuse to jettison the quarterback. Plus, Kolb’s salary cap figure made it a lot easier to cut him. The Cardinals offered a revamped deal, but Kolb balked.

And like Leinart, Kolb will leave Arizona with question marks surrounding just who he really is as a quarterback. The reasons are different — Leinart was never granted an opportunity while Kolb was often injured — but the result is the same. The Arizona Cardinals still need a quarterback.

Step on up, Drew Stanton. Bring your four career starts in five seasons and see if you can be the answer to the question that has puzzled the Cardinals organization for three years and counting.

Here we go again.


Comment guidelines: No name-calling, personal attacks, profanity, or insults. Please keep the conversation civil and help us moderate comments by reporting abuse.
comments powered by Disqus

Arizona Cardinals

Larry Fitzgerald, Pittsburgh Panthers, college football...

Arizona Sports

Larry Fitzgerald, 3 ASU players on 2024 College Football Hall of Fame ballot

Former Arizona Cardinals great Larry Fitzgerald and three Arizona State Sun Devils are on the 2024 College Football Hall of Fame ballot.

14 hours ago

Dallas Goedert #88 of the Philadelphia Eagles jumps out of a tackle by Dennis Gardeck #45 of the Ar...

Alex Weiner

Cardinals OLB Dennis Gardeck working to improve pass rush technique this offseason

Cardinals edge rusher Dennis Gardeck said he is improving his technique with new OLBs coach Rob Rodriguez to become a more complete rusher.

2 days ago

Kyler Murray #1 of the Arizona Cardinals warms up prior to his game against the Philadelphia Eagles...

Tom Kuebel

Bleacher Report: Cardinals’ Kyler Murray is NFL’s most overrated QB

Bleacher Report's Gary Davenport ranks Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray as the most overrated player at his position in the NFL.

2 days ago

Monti Ossenfort...

Arizona Sports

Barnwell: Arizona Cardinals 12th-most improved team this offseason

In ESPN analyst Bill Barnwell's eyes, the Cardinals are among those who have used the offseason to their advantage.

4 days ago

Budda Baker #3 of the Arizona Cardinals looks on during the second quarter against the Carolina Pan...

Wills Rice

ESPN’s Bowen: Best potential landing spots for Budda Baker, DeAndre Hopkins

ESPN's Matt Bowen gave the best potential landing spots for both wideout DeAndre Hopkins and Cardinals safety Budda Baker.

3 days ago

James Conner...

Tyler Drake

No complaints: Cardinals’ James Conner excited to ‘prove people wrong’ with new regime

While outside expectations are some of the lowest they have been in Cardinals history, RB James Conner isn't focused on the external noise.

3 days ago

Kevin Kolb’s divisive Arizona stint conjures Leinart flashbacks