Upton means most to his team, but is he the MVP?

Aug 19, 2011, 6:30 PM | Updated: 9:15 pm

There is a stat out there that judges a player by his wins above replacement value, better known as WAR.

Essentially, it looks at how much a team would suffer if a player was replaced in the lineup. So, how much better is one guy compared to his backup?

By the metric, according to Jayson Stark of ESPN.com, Arizona’s Justin Upton is the most valuable player in the National League.

Does that mean the Diamondback should win the MVP award?

Not necessarily, as Stark writes.

So if this is about “value,” Upton might be positioning himself to run away with this election if the D-backs can just hold off the Giants. But here’s where perception — and numbers — might diverge from how voters and people within the sport see this.

Upton’s home/road splits are even more lopsided than Fielder’s: .359/.429/.658/1.087/16 HR at home, .242/.314/.445/.759/9 HR on the road.

Stark also notes Upton’s defense as a drawback, saying a scout told him about Upton: “[He] hasn’t played well in the outfield. He’s got 11 errors, which is a huge amount of errors. And most of them are because he loses concentration. I don’t think he’s a complete player.”

As the scout said and Stark agreed, if the voting was done today Upton would finish no higher than third, as he trails a pair of Brewers in the race for NL MVP.

That’s not to say Upton doesn’t have a chance. If the right fielder can continue his assault on Major League pitching and the D-backs hold off the Giants, he absolutely will be in the conversation.

And, in a year like this one where there is no clear-cut favorite, the D-backs may ultimately find themselves with their first-ever league MVP award winner.

Arizona Diamondbacks

Mike Hazen, Torey Lovullo, and Ken Kendrick of the Arizona Diamondbacks look on as Corbin Carroll a...
Arizona Sports

Roundtable: What are our expectations for the 2023 Diamondbacks?

What our Arizona Sports hosts and ArizonaSports.com editors think this D-backs team can achieve this season.
15 hours ago
D-backs P Ryne Nelson (Photo by John E. Moore III/Getty Images)...
Tyler Drake

D-backs eager to get season into full swing after strong spring

With Tuesday's final exhibition of the spring now in the rearview, it's time to look ahead to the regular for the D-backs.
2 days ago
This is a 2023 photo of Arizona Diamondbacks relief pitcher Carlos Vargas. This image reflects the ...
Arizona Sports

Carlos Vargas earns final D-backs bullpen spot, Mantiply to IL

Arizona Diamondbacks righty Carlos Vargas has made the Opening Day roster, skipper Torey Lovullo announced Tuesday.
2 days ago
Arizona Diamondbacks outfielder Corbin Carroll. (Zac BonDurant/Getty Images)...
Jake Anderson

Diamondbacks’ young prospects have Torey Lovullo looking at ‘very bright future’

It's hard to get excited about results in the penultimate game of spring training when Opening Day is on the horizon.
3 days ago
Arizona Diamondbacks right-handed pitcher Drey Jameson speaks to reporters prior to a spring traini...
Jake Anderson

D-backs’ Drey Jameson ‘doesn’t give a (expletive)’ about not starting, only wants to win

Competition between teammates can bring out the worst in individuals, but that's not the case for D-backs' Drey Jameson and Ryne Nelson.
3 days ago
Corbin Carroll #7 of the Arizona Diamondbacks hits the ball during the first inning of the Spring T...
Alex Weiner

Five of the D-backs’ Cactus League standouts

Corbin Carroll and Gabriel Moreno were amongst the top performers for the Arizona Diamondbacks during Cactus League games.
3 days ago
Upton means most to his team, but is he the MVP?