Should Joshua Dobbs remain the starter until Kyler Murray returns?

Oct 29, 2023, 7:22 PM | Updated: 9:18 pm

Joshua Dobbs celebrates...

Joshua Dobbs #9 of the Arizona Cardinals celebrates his touchdown with teammates during the first quarter against the Baltimore Ravens at State Farm Stadium on October 29, 2023 in Glendale, Arizona. (Photo by Norm Hall/Getty Images)

(Photo by Norm Hall/Getty Images)

GLENDALE — Arizona Cardinals head coach Jonathan Gannon made no ifs, ands or buts about it when it came to his confidence level in quarterback Joshua Dobbs following a 31-24 loss to the Baltimore Ravens on Sunday.

Despite yet another inconsistent showing and multiple turnovers, the signal caller lives to see another start in Week 9 against his former team in the Cleveland Browns.

But after five straight weeks of a lot of the same result and the honeymoon phase of the new regime a thing of the past, is that the best move for the team moving forward until franchise quarterback Kyler Murray is activated and playing again?

Let’s take a look:

Reasons against Joshua Dobbs starting in Week 9

Let’s get the big one out of the way first.

Dobbs’ turnovers are killing the Cardinals’ momentum on a weekly basis.

Sure, he can beat opposing defenses with his legs — scoring yet another rushing touchdown on Sunday — but it’s all for naught if he hands the opposition extra possessions due to carelessness with the football on a weekly basis.

Dobbs has now tossed five interceptions and has lost the handle of the football five times, losing it twice.

And when he is finding his pass catchers, it’s only been at a 62.7% clip for 1,569 passing yards and seven touchdowns, with overthrows and missed reads plaguing his output.

No matter how good the defense plays — it turned in a respectable day against Lamar Jackson and a tough Ravens offense — making up for multiple turnovers and long offensive lulls a game is just too tough to get overcome for this version of the Cardinals.

Given where this team came from and where it’s trying to get to, making a switch for morale alone could be something to consider.

Reasons for Joshua Dobbs starting in Week 9

A lot of Cardinals fans have had this thinking over recent weeks:

Would it really be that bad to have rookie Clayton Tune get a shot under center?

As the only other healthy quarterback option currently on the team, the suggestion is a natural one.

But is it really worth the potential of stunting Tune’s growth by throwing him into the fire against the likes of Myles Garrett in Week 9?

At 1-7, the playoffs are but a dream for Arizona, and making that kind of move could have added repercussions for the rookie down the line.

Tune stood out in training camp, but clearly didn’t do enough to win the job, leading Arizona to trade for Dobbs ahead of the regular season.

There’s also the fact that the Cardinals don’t seem in a hurry to activate Murray off the physically unable to perform list despite having the ability to do so.

Until Murray is officially activated and back starting, the options are simply limited for Arizona.

And while Dobbs will be the first one to tell you the losses and the turnovers are on him, his teammates remain in his corner.

“The energy from Josh could have been down and out,” rookie lineman Paris Johnson Jr. said postgame. “But not at all. … I told him after the game, ‘Despite of everything that happen, you fought, you kept going, you reminded us of who you were. You’re not a quitter.’ … When I talked to him, he was on the same page already, so it was kind of cool.”

Cardinals Corner

Greg Dortch looks on during OTAs...

Tyler Drake

Cardinals’ Greg Dortch hungrier than ever in expanded offensive role

After seeing limited offensive opportunities in the past, Cardinals wide receiver Greg Dortch is getting a legit chance to shine in 2024.

4 days ago

Kyzir White and his teammates look on during OTAs...

Tyler Drake

White: Cardinals showing new level of maturity in Year 2 of regime

Kyzir White isn't big on comparing teams. He has, however, seen some early similarities between the 2024 Cardinals and 2022 Eagles.

5 days ago

Kyzir White runs through drills during OTAs...

Tyler Drake

Arizona Cardinals’ Kyzir White letting his play do the talking in 2024

Arizona Cardinals inside linebackers Kyzir White and Mack Wilson Sr. are expecting big things out of the newly formed tandem in 2024.

6 days ago

Michael Wilson looks on...

Tyler Drake

Cardinals’ Michael Wilson, Marvin Harrison Jr. building off one another

Arizona Cardinals WR Michael Wilson has been a valuable resource for fellow wide receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. and vice versa.

7 days ago

Max Melton at Cardinals minicamp...

Tyler Drake

Max Melton, Elijah Jones ‘growing together’ alongside Arizona’s young CBs

The makeup of the Cardinals CBs room calls for added competition. It also brings a level of togetherness that's been on display early on.

11 days ago

Max Melton and Elijah Jones stop by the Cardinals Corner podcast...

Tyler Drake

Cardinals Corner(s): Max Melton, Elijah Jones talk offseason, smooth NFL transition

It was a double dose of Cardinals guests on the latest episode of Cardinals Corner, with rookies Max Melton and Elijah Jones swinging by.

12 days ago

Should Joshua Dobbs remain the starter until Kyler Murray returns?