Share this story...
Latest News

Analyst: Justin Upton to the Mariners makes sense for D-backs

This time of year, baseball writers have a lot of time on their hands. The hot stove is just heating up, the Winter Meetings are less than a month away and the holidays are keeping them at home with their respective families.

So when reading the following trade idea, know that’s Dave Schoenfield is merely suggesting a theoretical blockbuster deal, not reporting on a potential one.

In his SweetSpot blog, Schoenfield came up with five plausible blockbuster trade suggestions to keep with the theme of big shopping deals on Black Friday.

While Ken Kendrick spoke out in favor of his right fielder last weekend, of course, the Diamondbacks’ Justin Upton still found his name in a proposed trade. As did former No. 3 overall pick Trevor Bauer.

Here’s the trade:

Arizona Diamondbacks trade RF Justin Upton and RHP Trevor Bauer and receive SS Asdrubal Cabrera, RHP Vinnie Pestano and OF Michael Saunders

Cleveland Indians trade SS Asdrubal Cabrera, OF Shin-Soo Choo and RHP Vinnie Pestano and receive RHP Trevor Bauer, LHP Danny Hultzen and RHP Hector Noesi

Seattle Mariners trade LHP Danny Hultzen, OF Michael Saunders and RHP Hector Noesi and receive RF Justin Upton and OF Shin-Soo Choo

Like was said earlier, this was just done on a whim but a baseball writer trying to have fun over the holidays.

Although, it does seem he’s convinced in the deal’s feasibility.

OK, we couldn’t avoid Upton and there’s nothing more creative than a good three-way deal. This trade works for all three teams. The D-backs get the shortstop they need and also part ways with Bauer, whom’s Jerry Crasnick reported earlier “has fallen out of favor” with some in the organization. Saunders gives them a starting outfielder to hedge against the production of Gerardo Parra and prospect Adam Eaton and Pestano provides a killer right-hander for the bullpen alongside J.J. Putz and David Hernandez.

Despite Schoenfield’s best laid intentions, from an analysis standpoint, the trade doesn’t seem that realistic for Arizona. The team would be giving up their star right fielder and a potential future No. 1 on their staff for a talented shortstop, right-handed reliever (which they already have a surplus of) and a fringe starting outfielder.

Here’s hoping your shopping brought about more bargains than this trade would bring the Diamondbacks.