Arizona Cardinals’ Carson Palmer listed as one of NFL’s ‘okayest’ QBs

Jul 23, 2015, 11:16 AM | Updated: 11:17 am

Just to set the record straight, we’re not totally sure if this is a compliment, an insult, or something in between.

But it is something, we guess.

Over at USA Today’s FTW Blog, Mike Foss put together a piece going over The 5 okayest NFL quarterbacks in 2015. And wouldn’t you know, it, Arizona’s Carson Palmer is tops on the list.


Palmer is the quintessential okay quarterback. You look at his 2014 record with the Cardinals, a team resplendent with talent, and you see that he was 6-0, averaging 270 yards, nearly two touchdowns a game and half an interception along with a 95.6 passer rating. Palmer’s season was cut short due to injury, but if you project those numbers out over a 16-game season, you’re looking at season comparable to that of Matthew Stafford or Ryan Tannehill. Without Palmer, Arizona went 5-5, a stark dropoff, but impressive considering they had a fourth-string quarterback for their final three games.

In contrast, Arizona had the ninth-best defense in yards allowed, and fifth-best in points conceded last season. This was a team that won through phenomenal defense and a passable offense. If Palmer stayed healthy, who knows the damage the Cardinals might have done in the playoffs.

It’s true, the Cardinals’ defense was, for the most part, a unit that carried the team for much of the last couple of seasons.

However, as the numbers (and record) indicate, Palmer was doing more than his fair to help the team win games when he was on the field. There’s a reason he has the best winning percentage of any QB since Week 8 2013, and it’s not only because of the defense — Palmer made plays, too.

That’s not to say the 35-year-old should be listed alongside elite passers like Aaron Rodgers, Tom Brady or Peyton Manning. But assuming he picks up where he left off last season, saying Palmer is merely OK seems to be underselling him, if only a little.

Life Changer Loans

Arizona Cardinals

Arizona Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray is tackled by Carolina Panthers defensive end Brian Burn...
Jordan Leandre

By the numbers: Arizona Cardinals’ consistently inconsistent offense

The Arizona Cardinals have the most consistently inconsistent offenses in football through the first four weeks of the season.
12 hours ago
Arizona Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray (1) runs for a touchdown against the Carolina Panthers d...
Tyler Drake

Cardinals’ Kyler Murray: Slow starting offense ‘can’t last forever’

"I know this can't last forever," Kyler Murray told reporters postgame. "We will figure it out. I'm not making it a thing because it's not."
12 hours ago
Arizona Cardinals safety Jalen Thompson (34) celebrates with safety Budda Baker after an intercepti...
Wills Rice

Cardinals locker room unites after 1st win in Carolina since 2009

The Arizona Cardinals left Bank of America Stadium with their first win against the Panthers in Carolina since 2009.
12 hours ago
Baker Mayfield #6 of the Carolina Panthers runs with the ball against Zach Allen #94 of the Arizona...
Tyler Drake

Arizona Cardinals defense dictates Week 4 win over Panthers

While the Cardinals offense started out flat for yet another week of play, the defense was there to pick up the slack against the Panthers.
12 hours ago
Arizona Cardinals defensive end J.J. Watt plays against the Carolina Panthers during the first half...
Tyler Drake

J.J. Watt tearfully talks heart issue after Cardinals’ win over Panthers

Despite going into atrial fibrillation on Wednesday, Cardinals DL J.J. Watt still managed to suit up on Sunday against the Panthers.
12 hours ago
Arizona Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray scores against the Carolina Panthers during the second h...
Arizona Sports

Rapid reactions: Arizona Cardinals shake off slow start in win vs. Panthers

Despite another slow start from the Cardinals against the Panthers, Arizona's offense and defense found a groove for a 26-16 victory.
12 hours ago
Arizona Cardinals’ Carson Palmer listed as one of NFL’s ‘okayest’ QBs